Her Phone Turned Off Before He Left her Apt…Then He Wiped His Phone | Sandra Birchmore Trial

Original Media · 1h 03m · English · YouTube · Annie Elise

TLDR

This episode covers the federal trial of former Stoughton police officer Matthew Farwell, charged with murdering 23-year-old pregnant Sandra Birchmore and staging her death as suicide. Sandra was groomed from age 12 in a police Explorer program and sexually abused for years by Matthew, his twin brother William, and program head Robert Divine. The trial revealed 40,000+ text messages, surveillance footage, DNA evidence, and testimony from 50 witnesses over 18 days. The jury is currently deliberating.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Three police officers — including the head of the youth Explorer program — systematically groomed and sexually abused a girl from age 12 for years, passing her among themselves.

•

The biological father of Sandra's baby was Jason Pickard (her Army recruiter), not Matthew Farwell, meaning Matthew killed her (if guilty) to silence her about statutory rape, not to hide paternity.

•

A police dispatcher allegedly tipped off Matthew about the internal report against him, enabling him to act before investigation began.

•

Matthew went from Sandra's apartment directly to the hospital where his wife was giving birth to their third child — the same night Sandra died.

•

Officers routinely had sex in their police cruisers while on duty, treating it as a convenient location for concealment.

•

The original state police investigation did 'very little' and pushed the medical examiner toward a suicide ruling despite suspicious circumstances.

Key takeaways

•

Sandra Birchmore was groomed from age 12 in a police Explorer program and sexually abused by three officers: Matthew Farwell (from age 15), his twin brother William, and program head Robert Divine.

•

Matthew Farwell visited Sandra's apartment on February 1, 2021 (surveillance shows 30-minute visit), and her Apple Watch activity stopped 3 minutes before he left; she was found dead three days later with a duffel bag strap around her neck attached to a closet door handle.

•

DNA testing revealed Jason Pickard (Army recruiter who had a relationship with Sandra) was the biological father of her unborn child, not Matthew — undermining the presumed motive but Matthew's DNA was primary on the duffel bag strap used in the staging.

•

A police dispatcher allegedly tipped off Matthew about a report filed against him on January 20, 2021, giving him motive to silence Sandra before his crimes were exposed.

•

Matthew wore a COVID mask entering Sandra's building despite reportedly despising masks, suggesting consciousness of guilt; he also deleted Google searches about statutory law and erasing phone records.

•

Police Chief Donna McNamara launched an internal affairs investigation that uncovered the three officers' abuse and concluded Sandra's death was homicide, not suicide — without her, the case would likely have remained closed.

•

The defense argues Sandra died by suicide after Matthew ended their relationship and denied paternity, citing her ribbon searches, no defensive injuries, and alleged depression; prosecution argues staged scene, motive to silence, and forensic evidence of strangulation.

•

William Farwell testified under immunity that Matthew told him 'I have a problem and I need your help' regarding Sandra's pregnancy in December 2020, and admitted his own sexual relationship with Sandra (sometimes in his police cruiser).

Notable quotes

“You blackmailed me into getting what you wanted. Then he calls her, quote, the worst person on the face of the earth.”

▸ Notable quotes · 18:59

“I have a problem and I need your help.”

▸ Notable quotes · 48:58

“You are truly the worst person on the face of the earth.”

▸ Notable quotes · 50:37

“I can't wait to crush this motherfucker.”

▸ Notable quotes · 34:18

“She was ecstatic, upbeat, and so full of joy and happiness about becoming a mother.”

▸ Notable quotes · 43:16

“Doors open when you get here.”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:24

Chapters

•

0:24 — Introduction and Case Background: Annie Elise introduces the episode, explains the federal trial of Matthew Farwell is not televised, and provides a refresher on the Sandra Birchmore case: grooming from age 12 in Explorer program, abuse by three officers, pregnancy, and suspicious death initially ruled suicide.

•

10:07 — Timeline of Events Leading to Death: Details the relationship between Sandra and Matthew, her pregnancy announcement, his hostile reaction, the police report filed January 20, 2021, the dispatcher tip-off, Matthew's visit to her apartment February 1 (surveillance footage), his unusual mask-wearing, and his text to a colleague from the hospital asking about department activity.

•

17:41 — Discovery of Body and Internal Affairs Investigation: Sandra's body found February 4 with duffel bag strap around neck; Chief Donna McNamara launches internal affairs investigation, uncovers three officers' sexual relationships with Sandra, and concludes death was homicide. FBI takes over, arrests Matthew August 2024.

•

23:56 — Trial Overview and Opening Statements: Trial structure (federal, no cameras), charges (killing a witness/victim, causing death of child in utero), prosecution's theory (murder to silence, staged scene, deleted evidence), defense theory (suicide after rejection, depression, ribbon searches), and the 40,000 text messages central to both narratives.

•

31:27 — Key Prosecution Witnesses: Chief McNamara's testimony; Sergeant Robert identifies Matthew on surveillance wearing mask (unusual for him); Leslie Davis testifies Matthew violently pushed Sandra during argument over birth certificate; three former affair partners testify Matthew never wore masks or asked them to delete messages, showing different treatment of Sandra.

•

40:01 — Jason Pickard Testimony and DNA Revelation: Jason Pickard (Army recruiter) testifies under immunity about relationship with Sandra, her excitement about pregnancy, babyproofing visit where she mentioned Matthew inspecting bathroom/closet; cross-examination reveals 'our secret' call about conception date; bombshell: Jason's DNA proves he is biological father, not Matthew.

•

47:09 — William Farwell Testimony: Matthew's twin brother testifies under immunity: admits sexual relationship with Sandra (sometimes in police cruiser), reveals Matthew told him 'I have a problem and I need your help' regarding pregnancy in December 2020; Annie's commentary on the 'tunnel brothers' dynamic.

•

51:03 — Defense Case and Closing Arguments: Defense calls Sandra's ex-boyfriend William Kilroy to portray her emotional struggles, journal entry, alleged childhood trauma; prosecution cross-examines showing no prior suicide attempts; closing arguments: prosecution focuses on 3-minute timeline, staged scene forensics, motive; defense emphasizes reasonable doubt, medical disagreement, ribbon search, evidence contamination.

•

59:47 — Verdict Watch and Conclusion: Jury begins deliberating November 6, 2026; no verdict at recording time; Annie previews Thursday's Headline Highlights for updates; asks audience for thoughts on murder vs. suicide.

Speakers

•

Annie Elise — Host

⋮