TLDR
In the final episode of the Jade Benning series, hosts Stephanie Harlow and Derrick Levasseur detail how Blaze Taylor was convicted of murdering his pregnant girlfriend Jade and their unborn daughter Ivy. Despite a largely circumstantial case — no video, no recovered poisoned drink, no confession, and an inconclusive manner of death — a Nashville jury deliberated only two to two-and-a-half hours before finding Taylor guilty. The prosecution proved Taylor gave Jade an ultimatum ("me or the baby"), returned to her life while secretly planning a future with another woman, brought a massive dose of cocaine to their date night, put it in her drink, took photos with her as she deteriorated, stood by for six minutes while she said "What did you put in my drink?" and "I can't feel my legs," and was outside the apartment when he called 911. Taylor received two consecutive life sentences totaling approximately 102 years before parole eligibility. The defense plans to appeal, citing evidentiary issues and the admission of prior-bad-acts testimony from Taylor's ex-girlfriend Apple.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Taylor took staged, happy photographs with Jade *after* he had already poisoned her, documenting a domestic scene he knew would never happen.
Taylor was outside the apartment building — moving around per GPS data — during the 911 call, not inside with the dying woman as he claimed.
The cocaine concentration in Jade's blood was so high the medical examiner said it is typically seen only in people smuggling cocaine balloons across borders.
Taylor had discussed putting abortion medication in a previous girlfriend's drink years before meeting Jade, showing a pre-existing pattern of reproductive coercion via covert drugging.
The jury convicted Taylor of first-degree premeditated murder for the unborn daughter Ivy but only second-degree murder for Jade, meaning they unanimously agreed he *planned* to kill the baby but not necessarily the mother.
Key takeaways
The prosecution's case relied on a convergence of circumstantial evidence: Taylor's "me or the baby" ultimatum to Jade (mirroring one he gave to a previous girlfriend, Xavier), his secret planning with Xavier the night before the murder, the extreme cocaine concentration in Jade's system (comparable to drug smugglers), the precise 30-minute medical timeline matching when Taylor was alone with her, and Jade's real-time accusation to her best friend Nijea Jackson: "What did you put in my drink?"
Taylor's behavior after poisoning Jade was damning: he took posed photographs with her after she had ingested the cocaine, stood silently for six minutes and nine seconds while she lost feeling in her legs and vomited, never asked what was wrong or tried to help, and was physically outside the apartment — moving around the building — when he called 911, contradicting his claim that he was "running back to the room" to check on her.
The defense attempted to portray Jade as a voluntary drug user by introducing texts about marijuana and Adderall, but the forensic analyst testified these messages showed Jade obtaining substances for friends and coworkers, not herself, and no drugs or paraphernalia were found in her apartment or system besides the cocaine. The judge explicitly called out the defense for trying to "trash the victim" by introducing irrelevant sexual history (nude photos sent to other men months earlier when Taylor was not in the picture).
Testimony from Taylor's ex-girlfriend Apple Danni — that Taylor had discussed putting abortion medication in Xavier's drink years earlier — was pivotal for the jury, establishing a modus operandi of secretly drugging a pregnant partner to end a pregnancy. The defense plans to appeal the admission of this prior-bad-acts evidence, citing a recent appellate ruling in the Adam Montgomery case that excluded similar testimony.
The jury's split verdict — second-degree murder (not first-degree premeditated) for Jade, but first-degree premeditated murder for Ivy — indicates they believed Taylor's primary intent was to kill the baby, and his failure to act once Jade showed symptoms constituted depraved-heart murder for her death. The judge imposed consecutive life sentences, reasoning that concurrent sentences would mean "effectively none" additional punishment for Ivy's death.
Significant investigative gaps remain: the poisoned cup was never recovered, the apartment was not secured as a crime scene (family and friends entered first), Taylor's phone from that night was never found, and no evidence was presented showing Taylor purchased the cocaine. Derrick Levasseur, a former detective, criticized lead investigator Detective Adam Reese for a pattern of incomplete documentation and tunnel vision, warning these holes make a successful appeal likely.
Notable quotes
“He is there and knows what he has done and for 4 minutes takes picture after picture with Jade Benning.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:39“Blaze Taylor went there with a plan. There was a plan. He has already poisoned her and he is taking pictures with her.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:56“He stood there for 6 minutes and 9 seconds knowing that he put cocaine in her drink and she drank it while she said these things to him of I know you did this.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:51“What did you put in my drink? I knew something was off, you know.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:23“The amount of cocaine he was using was overshooting and then some. They said that they only saw this amount of cocaine, this concentration of cocaine in people that are like smuggling balloons of cocaine across like borders.”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:20“So, you want to trash her? ... To trash the victim. I got you.”
▸ Notable quotes · 61:51Chapters
0:00 — Case Overview and Verdict: Hosts introduce the final episode of the Jade Benning series. Despite a circumstantial case with no direct evidence, a Nashville jury convicted Blaze Taylor of murdering Jade and their unborn daughter Ivy after only a few hours of deliberation on July 1, 2026.
2:35 — Prosecution's Theory: Motive and Plan: Taylor gave Jade a "me or the baby" ultimatum (same as he gave Xavier). When she chose the baby, he returned to her life not to support her but to remind her life would change. After she refused to terminate, he devised a plan to put something in her drink — a method he had discussed using on a previous girlfriend.
5:50 — Timeline of the Murder Night: Taylor arrived at 7 p.m. with cocaine. Friends visited 7:30–8:00 p.m. Photos at 8:29 p.m. show Jade fine. Medical examiner testified cocaine ingestion causes pulselessness within 30 minutes. Symptoms began ~9:24 p.m.; Jade called Nijea at 9:28 p.m. saying "What did you put in my drink?" Taylor stood by for 6+ minutes doing nothing.
16:57 — 911 Call and GPS Evidence: Taylor called 911 from outside the apartment (GPS showed movement around the building), not from inside as he claimed. He was not with Jade when she needed help. This raised questions about what he was disposing of outside (the cup, cocaine bag, etc.).
24:00 — Defense Strategy: Drug Use and Character Attacks: Defense argued Jade voluntarily used drugs, citing texts about marijuana/Adderall. Forensic analyst showed texts were for friends, not her. Defense also tried to introduce Jade's nude photos sent to other months earlier (when Taylor was gone) and her Bumble usage; judge shut this down as victim-trashing.
73:00 — Toxicology Disputes: Defense toxicologist challenged hospital blood sample (no preservative), comforter testing (contamination), and fentanyl presence. Prosecution countered fentanyl was given at hospital. Defense argued the massive cocaine dose would have been detectable in a drink; prosecution noted Jade tasted something wrong and said so on the call.
82:00 — Verdict, Sentencing, and Appeal Outlook: Jury convicted: second-degree + felony murder for Jade; first-degree premeditated + felony murder for Ivy. Judge imposed consecutive life sentences (~102 years before parole). Defense will appeal, focusing on Apple Danni's prior-bad-acts testimony and consecutive sentencing. Hosts note investigative holes (no cup, no phone, unsecured scene) make appeal plausible.
Speakers
Stephanie Harlow — Host
Derrick Levasseur — Host / Former Detective