Stark Raving Mad | "The Woman in the Woods" | "48 Hours" Podcast (Episode 6)

Original Media · 35m · English · YouTube · 48 Hours

TLDR

This 48 Hours episode covers the trial and conviction of Nick Kassotis (also known as Nicholas Kilian James Stark) for the murder and dismemberment of his second wife, Mindi Mebane Kassotis. Nick took the stand in his own defense — a rare move — claiming a mysterious figure named Jim McIntyre controlled their lives and made suspicious purchases, but prosecutors argued Nick killed Mindi in a rage after discovering she wasn't pregnant. The jury deliberated about an hour before finding him guilty on 12 counts, sentencing him to life without parole plus 25 years. Jim McIntyre was never proven to exist.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Nick's defense attorney Doug Weinstein admitted he had no evidence Jim McIntyre existed — no photo, no records — yet still argued Nick might not have killed Mindi.

•

Nick changed his legal name to Nicholas Kilian James Stark (using 'KJ Stark' as a pen name) four days after marrying his third wife.

•

The stab wounds to Mindi's abdomen (uterus area) were separate from the dismemberment cuts, suggesting targeted rage about pregnancy.

•

Special Agent Tracy Sands, lead investigator, died of a heart complication just 16 days after Nick's sentencing — this was his final case.

•

Samantha, Nick's third wife, described her experience as 'rape by fraud' because Nick lied about his entire identity, and she pursued an annulment.

Key takeaways

•

Nick Kassotis testified in his own murder trial, a highly unusual move that his 30-year defense attorney had never done before.

•

Nick claimed a man named Jim McIntyre infiltrated their lives, convinced them they were in danger from hackers and Nick's own father, and gained total control over their finances and communications.

•

No evidence of Jim McIntyre's existence was found; the one real Jim McIntyre located was a dental implant salesman with no connection to Nick.

•

Prosecutors argued Nick killed Mindi because he desperately wanted children and flew into a rage when he learned she wasn't pregnant, noting stab wounds to her abdomen were 'gratuitous.'

•

Nick told his third wife Samantha that Mindi had died of COVID while Mindi was still alive, part of what McIntyre allegedly instructed.

•

The jury convicted Nick on all 12 counts after roughly one hour of deliberation.

•

Nick's parents continue to believe in his innocence, while Mindi's friends advocate for awareness of psychological abuse and isolation in relationships.

Notable quotes

“I absolutely did not. I've never put my hands on a woman. I've never hurt a woman. I would never have hurt Mindi.”

▸ Notable quotes · 12:59

“He wanted kids, and he found out Mindi wasn't pregnant, 'cause if Mindi was pregnant, you know what he doesn't do? He doesn't kill her, 'cause he wanted kids.”

▸ Notable quotes · 20:19

“I do not believe that was his name, no. ... Angry, betrayed, frankly dumb.”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:33

“I feel raped by him. I was not allowed to consent to a romantic and intimate relationship with Nicholas because he lied about his entire identity to me.”

▸ Notable quotes · 27:03

“The thought that he could take someone else's life is just unbelievable, honestly. ... I respect the jury's work that they did, but they got this one wrong.”

▸ Notable quotes · 29:54

“She would be advocating for those that are experiencing domestic violence in the form of psychological abuse and isolation. Like, she would stand on that, because she lived it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 34:48

Chapters

•

0:05 — Introduction and Nick's Substack Post: Four days after marrying his third wife, Nick Kassotis wrote a Substack post under the pen name KJ Stark, hinting at a hidden past. The episode introduces the murder trial of his second wife, Mindi.

•

3:35 — Nick Takes the Stand: In a rare move, defense attorney Doug Weinstein puts Nick on the stand. Nick testifies under his legal name, Nicholas Kilian James Stark, and describes his rural New Hampshire upbringing, Navy career, and failed first marriage to Heather.

•

7:00 — The Jim McIntyre Narrative: Nick explains how Jim McIntyre entered their lives after a Washington Post article brought unwanted attention. McIntyre claimed they were targeted by hackers and Nick's father, gaining total access to their finances and digital lives. Nick later learned McIntyre wasn't an FBI agent.

•

10:00 — Suspicious Purchases and Denials: Nick provides explanations for incriminating purchases (knife, etc.) around the time of Mindi's death, blaming McIntyre. He emphatically denies killing Mindi, but admits telling his third wife that Mindi had died of COVID.

•

14:00 — The Missing Jim McIntyre: Investigators find no evidence Jim McIntyre exists. The one real Jim McIntyre located is a dental implant salesman with no connection. Defense attorney admits McIntyre may be a fabrication but argues that doesn't prove Nick killed Mindi.

•

18:00 — Prosecution's Motive Theory: Prosecutors argue Nick killed Mindi in a rage after discovering she wasn't pregnant. Evidence includes Nick's history of wanting children, divorce from first wife over pregnancy issues, and gratuitous stab wounds to Mindi's abdomen.

•

23:40 — Verdict and Sentencing: Jury deliberates about one hour, returns guilty on all 12 counts. Nick sentenced to life without parole plus 25 years. No emotion shown. Lead investigator Tracy Sands dies 16 days later.

•

26:40 — Aftermath and Reflections: Victim impact statements from third wife Samantha (describing 'rape by fraud') and first wife Heather (survivor's guilt). Nick's parents maintain his innocence. Mindi's friends want her legacy to be advocacy against psychological abuse.

Speakers

•

Erin Moriarty — Host/Narrator

•

Nick Kassotis / Nicholas Kilian James Stark — Defendant

•

Doug Weinstein — Defense Attorney

•

Laurie Baio — Assistant District Attorney

•

Greg McConnell — Prosecutor

•

Tracy Sands — GBI Special Agent

•

Heather Thomas — First Wife

•

Samantha Koliesnik/Kolesnik — Third Wife

•

Wayne Kassotis — Father

•

Linda Kassotis — Mother

•

Angela Wynn — Mindi's Friend

•

Morgan Paddock — Mindi's Friend

•

Jack Frost — Investigator

⋮