TLDR
The Lawyer You Know podcast analyzes the Matthew Farwell federal trial where the jury reported being deadlocked after approximately 10 hours of deliberation. Host Peter Traos and his father, a former assistant U.S. attorney, discuss the significance of the jury's note wording, the judge's decision to send jurors home without giving an Allen charge, and the potential for state prosecution regardless of the federal outcome.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The jury reported deadlock after only ~10 hours of deliberation in a complex 20+ day trial with hundreds of exhibits — far shorter than comparable Massachusetts cases (Karen Read: 5 days; Lindsay Clancy: 7 days).
The federal charge does not require proving premeditation, only that Farwell killed Birchmore to prevent her from communicating with federal law enforcement — meaning a jury could believe he killed her but still acquit if they don't buy the federal nexus.
The incoming DA stated she wishes her office had prosecuted the case originally, calling it 'literally the job of your community and your district attorney.'
Two witnesses (Billy Farwell and Picard) received federal use immunity but may not have state immunity, leaving them potentially exposed to state charges if the grand jury uncovers new evidence.
Key takeaways
The jury sent two notes: first asking about schedule/timing, then stating they are deadlocked and unlikely to change 'anytime soon' after only ~10 hours of deliberation in a 20+ day trial with ~450 exhibits.
The judge declined to give an Allen (dynamite) charge immediately, instead instructing jurors to take the time they need and resume deliberations the next day.
In the First Circuit (federal), the Allen charge can only be given once, making timing strategic for both sides.
Double jeopardy does not bar a separate state prosecution for first-degree murder because the federal charge requires proving a federal nexus (killing to prevent communication with federal law enforcement) while state murder requires proving premeditation — different elements.
The incoming Norfolk County DA plans to open a grand jury investigation into the Stoughton Police Explorers program regardless of the federal verdict.
If the federal trial ends in a hung jury, the U.S. Attorney's Office will almost certainly retry the case due to the commitment made in taking over from local authorities.
The defense would view a hung jury as a win; the prosecution would view it as a significant setback.
Alternate jurors are being kept separate and allowed to use devices for work, avoiding exposure to deliberation dynamics.
Notable quotes
“We truly never know what a jury is going to do. That's why a lot of cases end in plea deals. That's why a lot of civil cases end in settlements.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:29“I would be very surprised if at this moment there is impossible to have any movement on their votes. I just think it's way too early.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:55“There is no double jeopardy issue between federal and state. She can prosecute him for anything she wants to and the federal prosecutions don't affect it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 30:54“If the jury thinks that she was not reasonably likely to get to the feds... then yes, he would be not guilty even if he killed her. Even if the jury thinks he killed her.”
▸ Notable quotes · 49:16“To not retry this case if it's a hung jury is just far too embarrassing for the US attorney's office. They've made a commitment opposing a local law enforcement agency.”
▸ Notable quotes · 54:40“The federal nexus... when they appeal this case that's going to be a tremendous appellate issue about whether or not a federal nexus was in fact proven.”
▸ Notable quotes · 33:10Chapters
2:06 — Jury Deadlock Note and Judge's Response: The jury sent two notes: first about scheduling, then declaring deadlock unlikely to change soon. The judge declined to give an Allen charge, instead sending jurors home with instructions to take the time they need and resume deliberations the next day.
5:00 — Analysis of Jury Note Wording and Timing: The hosts analyze the phrase 'looks like it will not change anytime soon' as likely meaning jurors need more time, not that they are hopelessly deadlocked. They compare deliberation length to other high-profile Massachusetts cases (Read: 5 days, Clancy: 7 days).
7:00 — Allen Charge Strategy and First Circuit Rules: In the First Circuit, the Allen charge can only be given once. The defense would want it given early; the judge is likely to wait. The judge's instruction referenced page 31 of jury instructions (not the Allen charge) and sent a hard copy back with jurors.
30:00 — Double Jeopardy and Potential State Prosecution: The incoming Norfolk County DA plans a grand jury investigation into the Explorers program. Both hosts agree state prosecution for first-degree murder is legally permissible regardless of federal outcome due to different elements (premeditation vs. federal nexus), though Massachusetts law may have nuances.
60:00 — Predictions and Viewer Poll: Hosts predict deliberations will continue through the day with a verdict likely Thursday (Veterans Day closes court Wednesday). Viewer poll: 50% expect continued deliberations, 24% expect verdict today, 27% expect second deadlock note.
Speakers
Peter Traos — Host / Attorney
Dad (Papa T) — Co-host / Former Assistant U.S. Attorney
Grant Smith Ellis — Courtroom Reporter
Christina Rex — Courtroom Reporter
Incoming Norfolk County DA — Prosecutor (unnamed)