Vote Save America x Sister District State Power Series: Getting out the Vote to Build State Power

Original Media · 53m · English · YouTube · Pod Save America

TLDR

This panel discussion emphasizes the critical importance of 2022 state legislative elections for the future of democracy, tracing how the 2010 Republican REDMAP strategy created entrenched minority rule through gerrymandering that persists today. Panelists detail key battleground states, warn of the Moore v. Harper Supreme Court case potentially giving gerrymandered legislatures unchecked power over federal elections, and urge immediate volunteer action in these high-impact, often low-margin races. They highlight a chronic Democratic disinvestment in state-level power building compared to Republicans' decades-long infrastructure strategy. The conversation frames state legislative work as both the most effective leverage point for policy change and a way to rebuild democratic engagement through concrete community conversations. The panel calls for sustained, long-term organizing beyond this election cycle. The transcript captures a live event from two weeks before the 2022 midterms. The panelists are David Daley (FairVote senior fellow, author), Dr. Abdul El-Sayed (physician, epidemiologist, podcast host, former Detroit health director), and Jessica Post (DLCC president), moderated by Gabby and Shaniqua from Sister District and Vote Save America.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Democrats have not regained a single legislative chamber lost in 2010 in Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, North Carolina, Michigan, Ohio, or Florida — 12 years later — due to the durability of modern gerrymandering technology.

•

The Republican State Leadership Committee (RSLC) is on pace to raise ~$90M this cycle vs. DLCC's ~$53M, and the GOP advantage is compounded by incumbent/lobbyist fundraising networks that entrench majority power.

•

Even after Michigan voters passed a referendum repealing the Emergency Manager law, the gerrymandered legislature re-enacted it via budget bill to make it referendum-proof — directly enabling the Flint water crisis.

•

In 2012, Democrats won 1.4M more votes nationwide for U.S. House but Republicans held a 234-201 majority due to 2010 gerrymanders — Obama's second-term agenda 'died on the vine on the night he was re-elected.'

•

The Powell Memo (1971) — a corporate blueprint for building conservative intellectual infrastructure — led directly to Lewis Powell's Supreme Court appointment, where he ruled on Buckley v. Valeo, seeding Citizens United and Shelby County decisions that enabled the 2010 strategy.

Key takeaways

•

The 2010 Republican REDMAP strategy captured state legislatures to control redistricting, creating durable minority rule that Democrats have failed to reverse in key states like Wisconsin, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, and Michigan for over a decade.

•

State legislatures are the primary lever for voting rights, reproductive rights, climate policy, labor laws, and election certification — making them more consequential than many federal races.

•

The upcoming Moore v. Harper Supreme Court case could enshrine the 'independent state legislature theory,' giving gerrymandered legislatures unchecked authority over federal elections and elector certification, potentially enabling 2024 election subversion.

•

Democrats suffer from chronic ballot roll-off: in contested state legislative races across 10 battleground states over 10 years, Democratic candidates experienced roll-off 80% of the time vs. only 37% for Republicans in Kentucky.

•

State legislative races are often decided by handfuls of votes (e.g., Virginia House 2021: 733 votes out of 3M+; Mississippi 2019: <100 votes), making volunteer contact extraordinarily high-impact per hour or dollar.

•

Republicans built a decades-long power infrastructure (Powell Memo → Heritage Foundation, Federalist Society, ALEC, RSLC, dark money post-Citizens United) while Democrats over-invested in federal litigation and advocacy, neglecting state-level capacity.

•

The 2022 map shows both defense (Colorado Senate, Minnesota House, Maine chambers, Nevada, New Mexico, North Carolina/Wisconsin supermajority protection) and offense opportunities (Michigan, Minnesota Senate, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania, Arizona, Georgia).

•

Engaging in state legislative campaigns yields concrete, community-level conversations about schools, roads, water, air quality — rebuilding democratic fellowship missing from national discourse.

Notable quotes

“We're within the margin of effort... we were always going to be underdogs this year. The fact that this is a fight, the fact that enthusiasm is tied — it's historic. It's a tremendous accomplishment. Don't worry about the polls.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:04

“President Obama's second term agenda died on the vine on the night he was re-elected because we lost state legislative races in crucial states in 2010.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:51

“Power consolidates. And when you put power in the hands of a minority hell-bent on sustaining that power, it means that they're going to flush democracy down with them.”

▸ Notable quotes · 20:23

“The U.S. Supreme Court is about to hear a case called Moore v. Harper which is going to give these already gerrymandered state legislatures... potentially the power to rewrite election law... what happened on January 6, 2021 will be a dress rehearsal for the kind of constitutional chaos that we will see on January 6, 2025.”

▸ Notable quotes · 42:20

“Democrats in contested state legislative races experienced ballot roll-off 80 percent of the time... Republicans in Kentucky running contested state legislative districts only experienced roll-offs 37 percent of the time.”

▸ Notable quotes · 25:12

“Your dollars go so much further at the state legislative level... Amy McGrath raised $96 million to run against McConnell. In that same 2020 cycle we raised $52 million to help legislators all across the country.”

▸ Notable quotes · 32:54

Chapters

•

0:00 — Opening: Urgency of State Legislative Races: Gabby frames the stakes: gerrymandered majorities rewriting history and engineering elections; urges ignoring polls and focusing on 'margin of effort' and long-term strategy.

•

4:00 — Historical Context: The 2010 REDMAP Strategy: David Daley details how Republicans targeted state legislatures in 2010 to control redistricting, creating durable minority rule that blocked Obama's agenda and persists today in key swing states.

•

9:00 — 2022 Battlefield Map: Jessica Post walks through defensive and offensive targets: protecting Colorado, Minnesota, Maine, Nevada, New Mexico, NC/WI supermajorities; flipping Michigan, Minnesota Senate, New Hampshire; building in PA, AZ, GA.

•

16:00 — Michigan Case Study: Gerrymandering's Human Cost: Dr. Abdul El-Sayed connects gerrymandered minority rule to the Flint water crisis via the Emergency Manager law — re-enacted after voter repeal — showing how consolidated power harms real communities.

•

23:00 — Asymmetric Power Building: Right vs. Left: Panelists analyze why Republicans built state power for decades (Powell Memo, think tanks, ALEC, RSLC, dark money) while Democrats over-invested in federal courts/litigation, creating chronic ballot roll-off and anemic state institutions.

•

42:20 — Moore v. Harper: Existential Threat: Daley warns the Supreme Court may adopt the independent state legislature theory, giving gerrymandered bodies unchecked power over federal elections — making 2022 races a firewall against 2024 chaos.

•

47:00 — Call to Action: High-Impact Volunteering: Panelists urge phone banking, canvassing, and relational organizing; emphasize state races decided by handfuls of votes where volunteer contact has outsized impact and rebuilds democratic connection.

Speakers

•

Gabby — Co-moderator

•

Shaniqua — Co-moderator

•

David Daley — Panelist

•

Dr. Abdul El-Sayed — Panelist

•

Jessica Post — Panelist

⋮