Alexa Nikolas Tells All: “Adam McIntyre Tried to Ruin My life.” Exclusive Interview

Original Media · 1h 49m · English · YouTube · H3 Podcast

TLDR

Former child actor Alexa Nicholas (Zoey 101) is suing MSNBC journalist Cat Tenbarge for defamation after Tenbarge falsely claimed Nicholas leaked sealed court documents about Drake Bell — the documents were public records. Tenbarge communicated with Nicholas's court-ordered stalker, shared Nicholas's private responses with him, and was filmed giving alcohol to underage YouTuber Adam McIntyre — the exact behavior Tenbarge built her career exposing. Adam McIntyre then launched a coordinated video campaign attacking Nicholas, while the 'snark' community weaponized survivor language to destroy an actual survivor who introduced nuance.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The documents Cat Tenbarge claimed were 'sealed court documents' from Drake Bell's case were actually public records available on the Cleveland Police website — anyone could download them by searching 'Jared Bell.'

•

Cat Tenbarge wrote her career-making exposé about the Vlog Squad giving alcohol to underage girls in March 2021, then in November 2021 was filmed herself giving vodka Red Bulls to 18-year-old Adam McIntyre in a hotel room.

•

Adam McIntyre admitted in his own video that he purchased the alcohol with Cat Tenbarge (Venmo receipts shown), and room service would have required Tenbarge (the only adult over 21) to sign for it — making her the legal provider.

•

Nicholas's stalker filed a motion to terminate the restraining order using Cat Tenbarge's emails to him as 'evidence' that he wasn't dangerous — the court rejected it, but it proves Tenbarge was actively communicating with a legally restrained stalker about his victim.

•

The 'Exposing Rich' account that led the harassment campaign against Nicholas was in a group chat with her stalker, yet branded itself as a survivor-protection account — Tenbarge followed and amplified it.

•

Nicholas was never told her rights as a child actor — not by SAG, not by set teachers, not by parents. She recalls being shushed in hair/makeup: 'Don't tell SAG' when production went over legal hours.

•

Dan Schneider normalized getting massages from employees on set in front of children, and sexual innuendos with kids were so normalized that Nicholas thought 'maybe this is just how adults behave' until she got older.

•

Nicholas's mother got her released from her Nickelodeon contract only after Dan Schneider screamed at 12-year-old Nicholas alone in a room — but Nickelodeon 'punished' her by banning her from the Kids' Choice Awards despite releasing her.

Key takeaways

•

Alexa Nicholas, a former Zoey 101 child actor, is suing MSNBC journalist Cat Tenbarge for defamation after Tenbarge published provably false claims that Nicholas leaked 'sealed court documents' about Drake Bell — the documents were public Cleveland police records Tenbarge could have verified herself.

•

Tenbarge communicated with Nicholas's court-ordered stalker (who had a restraining order prohibiting him from discussing her) and shared Nicholas's private responses with him, effectively helping him violate the restraining order while Tenbarge was supposedly reporting on Nicholas.

•

Video evidence shows Cat Tenbarge drinking vodka Red Bulls with Adam McIntyre when he was 18 (underage) and she was over 21 — the exact behavior Tenbarge built her career exposing when she wrote about the Vlog Squad giving alcohol to underage girls in 2021.

•

Adam McIntyre, Tenbarge's close friend, produced over 30 videos attacking Nicholas, never addressed the actual defamation claims in the lawsuit, and focused entirely on his own grievances while calling himself a survivor advocate — Ethan Klein describes him as 'the human embodiment of snark' and a 'crybully.'

•

Nicholas explains that child actors are conditioned from toddlerhood to please adults for survival — every interaction is an audition, behavior off-camera is monitored, and they're never told their rights. This creates adults who freeze under scrutiny and struggle to reclaim autonomy, which Nicholas says is why child stars 'act out' — it's a delayed 'fuck off' to a lifetime of people-pleasing.

•

The 'snark' community (anonymous accounts like Exposing Rich, YouTubers like Adam McIntyre) performs moral superiority while collaborating with actual abusers and stalkers. They demand black-and-white narratives, destroy nuance, and attack anyone who introduces complexity — even fellow survivors.

•

Nicholas's lawsuit includes 115 pages of receipts: texts, emails, court filings, video timestamps, and the restraining order against her stalker. Ethan Klein calls it a 'slam dunk' defamation case because Tenbarge's own words show reckless disregard for truth (e.g., admitting she didn't want the documents, then claiming they were sealed).

•

Nicholas advocates for independent, union-funded therapists on all sets with children — not hired by production — because every adult a child can currently turn to (parents, agents, set teachers, studio teachers) has a financial interest in keeping production moving. She says this is the only way to break the cycle where abuse is normalized and children have no safe adult.

Notable quotes

“I think we were just taught at a very young age to please people. And we never like felt good enough in that way where everything it was an audition. Someone has to hire you, someone has to approve of you, you can't say anything or you're fired or you look like you're problematic at a very very young age.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:40

“When you're six or under 10, I mean, anything that adults are doing, you just presume is normal.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:54

“They wanted to punish me first. So, what they said to my mom was, 'Yes, we'll let go of her.' Um, but she's never allowed to a Kidage Choice Awards, even though I was the one who like dealt with something from them. They had to punish me for for leaving.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:25

“The biggest problem for me when I was a kid when something bad happened on set, whoever you go to has an invested interest in keeping the thing going. No one's really safe. No one's going to give you a neutral response. There's always another motive.”

▸ Notable quotes · 13:35

“They're not sealed. They're public. They are not sealed and I told her they were not sealed multiple times.”

▸ Notable quotes · 59:01

“She even says it in her own words that she was didn't want was trying not to get them.”

▸ Notable quotes · 60:41

Chapters

•

0:00 — Child Actor Trauma & Dan Schneider: Alexa Nicholas describes starting as a child actor at age 3-4, working on Zoey 101 at 12 under Dan Schneider, who normalized sexual innuendos with children, massages from employees, and bullying. She was screamed at alone in a room by Schneider at 12, and Nickelodeon released her from her contract but banned her from the Kids' Choice Awards as punishment.

•

15:00 — Grooming, Activism & E Predators: Nicholas reveals she was groomed at 16 into marriage with a 33-year-old man she met on MySpace. After having her daughter, she came forward with an open letter, received hundreds of DMs from other survivors, and founded 'E Predators' — protesting predators in entertainment (Diplo, Brian Friedman's law firm, Nickelodeon). This led to her involvement in 'Quiet on Set.'

•

28:00 — Drake Bell Documentary Chaos: Nicholas learned 24 hours before release that Drake Bell (a convicted predator) was in 'Quiet on Set' as a victim. She reviewed public court documents, found online misinformation (no nudes sent, victim was 15 not 12, he disengaged upon learning age), and faced backlash for stating facts — accused of 'defending a predator' by survivor advocates.

•

45:00 — Stalker, Exposing Rich & Cat Tenbarge: Anonymous account 'Exposing Rich' harassed Nicholas, calling her a pedophile supporter. Nicholas discovered the account was in a group chat with her court-ordered stalker (who moved 11 minutes from her home). Cat Tenbarge sent 18 accusatory questions clearly sourced from the stalker's delusional filings, communicated with the stalker, and shared Nicholas's private responses with him.

•

58:00 — Defamation Lawsuit & Sealed Documents Lie: Tenbarge published false claims that Nicholas leaked 'sealed court documents' about Drake Bell — they were public Cleveland Police records. Tenbarge's own texts admit she didn't want the documents. The documents are redacted, not sealed. Tenbarge never verified with the court or police. MSNBC killed the story and Tenbarge left the network.

•

82:00 — Adam McIntyre & Hotel Room Evidence: Adam McIntyre (Tenbarge's friend) made 30+ videos attacking Nicholas. Video evidence surfaces of Tenbarge drinking vodka Red Bulls with 18-year-old McIntyre in a hotel room at 10 AM — Tenbarge over 21, McIntyre underage. Tenbarge previously built her career exposing the Vlog Squad for the exact same behavior. McIntyre admits purchasing the alcohol; room service required Tenbarge to sign.

•

90:00 — Snark Culture & Moral Performance: Ethan and Nicholas analyze how 'snark' communities perform moral superiority while collaborating with abusers, demanding black-and-white narratives, and destroying nuance. They describe McIntyre as a 'crybully' and 'rat' who pivots allegiances for clout. The system rewards dogpiling over truth.

•

94:00 — Systemic Solutions & Therapy on Sets: Nicholas advocates for independent, union-funded therapists on all sets with children — not hired by production — because every current adult (parents, agents, teachers) has financial interest in keeping production moving. She says this is the only way to give children a safe adult with no conflicting motives.

Speakers

•

Ethan Klein — Host

•

Alexa Nicholas — Guest

•

Hila Klein / Crew — Co-host / Crew

⋮