13 Year Old Realizes His Twin Brother Just Killed Someone

Original Media · 59m · English · YouTube · Dr Insanity

TLDR

In Fairfax, Ohio, 13-year-old Levi Cart strangled his 64-year-old neighbor Sheila Tenpenney after months of planning and obsessive research into serial killers like Ted Bundy. Despite Levi's cerebral palsy and the initial suspicion falling on the victim's brother, DNA from the crime scene matched Levi and his identical twin Hunter, though the lab could not distinguish between them. A search of Levi's room uncovered a journal with violent writings, a shirt covered in the victim's blood, gloves matching the crime scene, and his watch beneath the body. Phone records revealed searches for "how to strangle someone" and "how to defeat a police interrogation." Levi pleaded guilty to aggravated murder and will be held in a juvenile facility until age 21, with the lead investigator warning he may reoffend after release.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Standard DNA testing cannot distinguish between identical twins, so both brothers matched the crime scene evidence equally despite only one being the killer.

•

A 13-year-old with cerebral palsy who uses a shower chair and cannot stand for long periods successfully overpowered a 64-year-old woman who fought back violently, leaving blood and hair under her fingernails.

•

The killer's watch was found beneath the victim's body, a critical piece of evidence police initially overlooked during their first crime scene processing.

•

Levi researched "how to defeat a police interrogation" before the murder, yet during his actual interrogation he never asked for a lawyer or his mother, and fell for a basic DNA bluff.

•

Juvenile sentencing laws require Levi's release at age 21 regardless of the severity of the crime — aggravated murder, aggravated burglary, and strangulation — meaning a premeditated killer will be free in his early twenties.

Key takeaways

•

A 13-year-old with cerebral palsy planned and executed a violent strangulation murder after months of researching serial killers and murder methods online, demonstrating that physical disability does not preclude lethal violence when motivation and preparation are present.

•

Identical twins share the same STR DNA markers, making it impossible for standard forensic testing to distinguish which twin left biological evidence at a crime scene, creating a rare investigative obstacle that required corroborating physical evidence to overcome.

•

The investigation initially focused on the victim's brother Daryl Tenpenney due to his odd behavior and living situation, illustrating how confirmation bias and a convenient suspect can divert resources from the actual perpetrator living next door.

•

Levi's twin brother Hunter was more talkative and cooperative during early interviews, voluntarily discussing the suspicious scratches on Levi's face and the watch found at the scene, yet insisted Levi could not have committed the murder — leaving detectives uncertain whether Hunter was protecting his brother or genuinely unaware.

•

Police used a deliberate bluff during Levi's interrogation, claiming his DNA was uniquely identified at the scene despite knowing the twin issue, and Levi failed to recognize the deception, instead offering increasingly implausible explanations for how his blood could be in the victim's house.

•

A search of Levi's phone revealed the murder was premeditated: he had searched for how to choose a victim, how to strangle someone, and how to defeat a police interrogation, and posted "This one was a fighter" the day after the killing.

•

Despite overwhelming evidence including the victim's blood on Levi's shirt, his watch under the body, gloves matching the crime scene, and his own writings, juvenile sentencing laws limit his incarceration to age 21, with an expected release in 2033 — a outcome the lead investigator explicitly warned the court may not protect the public.

•

The case highlights how true-crime media consumption by minors can evolve from curiosity into actionable violence, with Levi modeling his methods on content from YouTube and shows like Dexter, and believing he could outsmart law enforcement using techniques learned online.

Notable quotes

“It's 2:00 a.m. in the small village of Fairfax, Ohio, and tonight, a 13-year-old boy decides this is the night he becomes a serial killer.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:29

“He moves silently through the house before approaching the bedroom of an elderly woman. At 2:40, he begins strangling her. But despite months of preparation, he quickly realizes this will be far more difficult than he expected.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:06

“The forensic analyst, the lab cannot tell Levi's DNA apart from Hunter's because identical twins share the same STR markers.”

▸ Notable quotes · 25:15

“That's Louis's watch. That's Louis's watch.”

▸ Notable quotes · 42:00

“This one was a fighter.”

▸ Notable quotes · 54:22

“He made a mistake. It was good luck for us that he did, but in the future, is he going to learn from those mistakes? That's what I'm concerned about.”

▸ Notable quotes · 58:14

Chapters

•

1:29 — The Murder: At 2:00 a.m., 13-year-old Levi Cart leaves his house, enters his neighbor Sheila Tenpenney's home wearing gloves learned from YouTube, and strangles her after she wakes and fights back, leaving defensive wounds on him. He returns to bed by 3:15 a.m.

•

2:42 — Discovery and Initial Response: Sheila's brother Daryl calls 911 around 11:00 a.m. Sunday. Police initially suspect suicide due to pills and a staged scene, but blood spatter, hair under fingernails, and Daryl's premature certainty about murder shift the investigation to homicide.

•

7:50 — Wrong Suspect: Daryl Tenpenney: Police focus on Daryl due to his odd living conditions and behavior, making him the primary suspect for days while the actual killer watches the investigation unfold from next door.

•

11:00 — The Cart Twins Emerge: Canvassing leads to Rebecca Cart and her twin sons Hunter and Levi. Levi has fresh deep scratches he claims are from a cat; both boys are obsessed with true crime and Dexter. DNA swabs are taken.

•

25:06 — DNA Dead End and Search Warrant: DNA results match both twins identically due to shared STR markers. Police execute a search warrant at the Cart home, finding Levi's watch under the victim's body, a bloodied shirt, gloves, and a journal with violent writings.

•

31:00 — Station Interrogations: Twins are brought to the station. Hunter is interviewed casually and volunteers that Levi's watch was at the scene. Levi is pressed hard in a cold room; detectives bluff that his DNA is uniquely identified. Levi fails to catch the bluff.

•

54:00 — Digital Evidence and Confession: Phone forensics reveal months of planning: searches for victim selection, strangulation methods, and interrogation defeat. Levi posts "This one was a fighter" the day after. Overwhelming physical and digital evidence leads to guilty plea.

•

57:00 — Sentencing and Warning: Levi pleads guilty to aggravated murder, aggravated burglary, and strangulation. Juvenile law mandates release at 21 (2033). Lead investigator warns the court Levi may reoffend, calling the outcome luck, not justice.

Speakers

•

Narrator — Narrator

•

Officer War — Police Officer

•

Special Agent Richard Ward — Special Agent

•

Detective Lauren — Detective

•

Hunter Cart — Suspect / Witness

•

Levi Cart (Louis) — Perpetrator

•

Rebecca Cart — Mother

•

Daryl Tenpenney — Victim's Brother

•

Sheila Tenpenney — Victim

⋮