"American Scoundrel": From Roy Cohn to Stephen Miller, "McCarthyism Lives On," Says Author Kai Bird

Original Media · 16m · English · YouTube · Democracy Now!

TLDR

Pulitzer Prize-winning biographer Kai Bird discusses his new book "American Scoundrel" on Roy Cohn, drawing direct parallels between Trump's new chief of staff Stephen Miller and Cohn, who mentored Trump in the 1970s-80s. Bird argues McCarthyism never ended but evolved through Nixon and Reagan to today's more dangerous iteration, with Miller and Trump using identical tactics of fear, loyalty demands, and attacks on institutions.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The current wave of McCarthyism has produced more victims and institutional capitulation than the 1950s original, with major universities and law firms complying preemptively.

•

Roy Cohn was a closeted gay man who died of AIDS while denying his sexuality, yet Trump — who has an aversion to germs — still hosted a farewell dinner for him and wept at his memorial.

•

Cohn's mafia clients taught him that loyalty and keeping one's word were paramount values, which he then instilled in Trump as the supreme virtue above law or ethics.

Key takeaways

•

Roy Cohn served as Joe McCarthy's chief counsel at age 27, then became a mafia lawyer for all five New York crime families before mentoring Donald Trump for 13 years, teaching him to never back down, never apologize, and threaten opponents with lawsuits.

•

Stephen Miller's appointment as chief of staff after the midterm losses mirrors Trump's first-term cry of "Where's my Roy Cohn?" — Miller's scowling demeanor, hooded eyes, press attacks, and pledge of "absolute loyalty" echo Cohn so closely Bird calls it "spooky."

•

Cohn secured Irving Kaufman's judgeship and assignment to the Rosenberg case, then held illegal ex parte conversations pressuring Kaufman to impose death sentences — Cohn later bragged he would have "pulled the switch himself."

•

Bird contends McCarthyism was never defeated; it resurfaced under Nixon and Reagan and has returned "much worse" in the last decade, with thousands of civil servants fired and major institutions — Ivy League universities, law firms, corporations — "bending the knee."

•

Trump maintained a deep, enduring friendship with Cohn despite distancing himself when Cohn developed AIDS; Trump hosted a lavish farewell dinner at Mar-a-Lago and wept quietly at Cohn's memorial, revealing the mentor's profound emotional hold.

•

Stephen Miller's midterm rhetoric — warning Democrats would "hand over our nation to illegal aliens, criminals, jihadists, and communists" — directly channels McCarthyite fearmongering, though Bird notes the Communist Party in the 1950s had only ~10,000 members, half of them FBI informants.

Notable quotes

“Where's my Roy Cohn? Donald Trump cried out early in his first term in the White House. Mr. Cohn, the lawyer and fixer who mentored Mr. Trump during his ascent through New York real estate and who taught him never to back down, never to apologize, and always to threaten opponents with multi-million dollar lawsuits, was then dead for 31 years.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:49

“40 years after his mentor's death, Mr. Trump found his Roy Cohn. The similarities are almost spooky.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:12

“Well, thank you Amy for having me. This is uh a great moment in history. It's very troubling though that he has chosen someone like Stephen Miller who resembles in a spooky way Roy Cohen, the man who mentored the young Donald Trump and taught him you know, taught him his politics, taught him how to deal with the press, the courts and to never back down, to never apologize and uh to engage in lie after lie, the big lie.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:23

“You know, Roy was a mafia law lawyer. He represented all five mob families in New York City in the 1970s. And uh you know, he he liked his mob clients and he valued them because they were straight with their word and they were loyal and he taught this kind of this mantra to Trump too and uh that's that's what matters to to Donald Trump is absolute loyalty”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:48

“But it turns out in retrospect that McCarthyism was never defeated. Roy Cohn planted the seeds of a sort of politics of resentment and divisiveness. And it's reared its head again and again during the Nixon era, during the Reagan era. And now in the last 10 years, we've had a vicious renewal of McCarthyism and it's much worse than the period that the witch hunts that we lived through in the early '50s.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:11

“I I don't think you can understand Donald Trump without understanding Roy Cohn. Uh Donald Trump is sort of an ephemeral character. Journalists and and biographers try to capture who he is. Uh but he's a con artist. And but if you read the biography of Roy Cohn, you suddenly something clicks and you suddenly get an insight into the soul of Donald Trump.”

▸ Notable quotes · 13:14

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction: Miller as Cohn's heir: Trump appoints Stephen Miller chief of staff after midterm losses; Kai Bird's New York Times piece draws parallels between Miller and Roy Cohn, Trump's former mentor who taught him to never back down or apologize.

•

1:21 — Bird on Miller-Cohn parallels: Bird details the "spooky" resemblance: similar demeanor, hooded eyes, press attacks, and Miller's pledge of absolute loyalty mirroring Cohn's mafia-derived code that Trump values above all.

•

3:17 — Loyalty and the mafia connection: Cohn represented all five New York mob families in the 1970s, admired their loyalty, and transmitted this value to Trump; Miller's public loyalty oath signals a dangerous doubling down rather than outreach to Democrats.

•

5:04 — McCarthyism's enduring legacy: Bird traces a straight line from Joe McCarthy through Cohn to Trump: McCarthyism was never defeated but resurfaced under Nixon and Reagan, and now manifests more severely with thousands of civil servants fired and major institutions capitulating.

•

8:34 — Trump's complex bond with Cohn: Despite distancing himself when Cohn developed AIDS, Trump hosted a lavish Mar-a-Lago farewell dinner and wept at Cohn's memorial, revealing a deep, enduring friendship between two narcissistic personalities.

•

10:22 — The Rosenberg case and judicial corruption: Cohn secured Judge Kaufman's appointment and assignment, then held illegal ex parte conversations pressuring death sentences for both Rosenbergs despite thin evidence against Ethel; Cohn later bragged he would have executed them himself.

•

13:04 — Understanding Trump through Cohn: Bird argues Trump is an ephemeral con artist whose soul becomes legible only through Cohn's biography — the mentor molded Trump's politics, press strategy, and worldview over 13 years.

•

13:43 — McCarthyism today: Miller's rhetoric: Miller's midterm fearmongering about "illegal aliens, criminals, jihadists, and communists" revives McCarthyite tactics; Bird notes the Communist Party was minuscule in the 1950s and the current paranoia targets immigrants and the free press.

Speakers

•

Amy Goodman — Host

•

Kai Bird — Guest

⋮