Trump DOJ Create Their OWN MESS as FIRINGS SCREW THEM!!!

Original Media · 13m · English · YouTube · Legal AF

TLDR

The Trump administration claims to have reduced the immigration court backlog, but hosts Sean Krennik and Brian Cabek argue this was achieved by firing up to 175 immigration judges who ruled against the government, stacking courts with enforcement-friendly personnel, and pressuring judges to change rulings. They discuss a proposed Rule of Law Act of 2026 that would create independent Article I immigration courts with 15-year terms and Senate-confirmed appellate judges, supported by major nonpartisan legal organizations but opposed by Republicans. Kansas City's 40,000-case backlog illustrates the ongoing crisis masked by manipulated national statistics. The DOJ blames the Biden administration for current backlogs. The hosts emphasize that judicial independence is critical because immigration judges currently serve at the pleasure of the Attorney General, creating a system where the executive branch controls both prosecution and adjudication. They express skepticism about reform passing under the current administration. The episode is from Civil Action on the Legal AF Network. The hosts are law partners Sean Krennik and Brian Cabek (also spelled Ketchek).

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Immigration judges are not Article III lifetime appointees but serve at the pleasure of the Attorney General, meaning they can be fired for their rulings.

•

The administration pressured a judge to change her ruling on bond for former unaccompanied minors without any formal appeal or reconsideration request — just a directive from 'higher-ups.'

•

The organizations supporting judicial independence in immigration courts (ABA, AILA, Federal Bar Association, NAIJ) are nonpartisan professional associations, not 'radical left-wing' groups as might be assumed.

•

The executive branch currently controls both the prosecution and the adjudication in immigration cases, a structural conflict of interest that is unique in the U.S. legal system.

Key takeaways

•

Immigration judges serve at the pleasure of the Attorney General, not for life, allowing the executive branch to fire judges who rule against government deportation efforts — up to 175 judges have reportedly been fired.

•

The administration's claimed reduction in the immigration court backlog is misleading because it was achieved by gutting the bench and pressuring remaining judges, not by improving efficiency or fairness.

•

Judge Karen Denoso Stevens in Virginia was pressured by supervisors to overturn bond grants for four former unaccompanied minors without any formal appeal process, illustrating direct political interference in judicial decisions.

•

The Rule of Law Act of 2026 would move immigration courts out of the Department of Justice and establish them as independent Article I courts with 15-year judicial terms, Senate-confirmed appellate judges, and removal protections — mirroring structures like the Tax Court and Veterans Court.

•

Major nonpartisan legal organizations including the American Bar Association, American Immigration Lawyers Association, Federal Bar Association, and National Association of Immigration Judges support the Rule of Law Act, contradicting claims that it is a partisan measure.

•

Republicans oppose the Rule of Law Act, and the hosts express skepticism that the Trump administration or Stephen Miller would support any reform that increases judicial independence in immigration proceedings.

•

Kansas City's 40,000-case backlog serves as a case study showing that courts remain overwhelmed where the administration has not yet fired judges or fast-tracked cases, revealing the national statistics as doctored.

•

The Department of Justice blamed the Biden administration for the Kansas City backlog, which the hosts criticize as an evasion of responsibility by the current administration.

Notable quotes

“It would be like if every single one of our cases that we handle, our civil cases we handle for our clients, if we appointed the judge and if you know the judge Sean came back in the office one day and said, "You know what, Brian? Judge uh ruled against me today." And I went, "Come on, Sean. Judge, it's your boss, Mr. Cabet, here. Yeah, I need you to go back and change that ruling. Can you do that for me?" or um you know or you're fired.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:10

“Apparently, her supervisor told her that unidentified higherups wanted her to overturn the decision without a formal appeal or reconsideration request. Just higherups, the the man the man behind the curtain wants you to wants you to change your mind as a judge.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:07

“The minute the judge doesn't do something that you want them to do, you put pressure on them. The minute the pressure doesn't work, you fire them.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:35

“This is exactly the kind of area where if the Republicans wanted to make traction with the public, they'd come out and they said, "Look, we're going to come up with a new check and balance on the executive. This is going to be very fair. It's a way for them to have their case heard."”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:44

“It is really absurd. Um, and it it's pretty unique in in politics in the United States for this to exa exist.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:34

“These courts are actually still jammed and backlogged. the national statistic statistic are doctorred numbers that the Trump administration has sort of created by firing judges who won't rule favorably for them um and fasttracking things.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:11

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction and Backlog Claims: The hosts introduce the topic: the Trump administration claims to have solved the immigration court backlog, but achieved this by firing judges, stacking courts with enforcement-friendly personnel, and pressuring judges to rule favorably.

•

1:00 — Judges Serve at the Pleasure of the AG: Brian explains that immigration judges serve at the pleasure of the Attorney General, not for life, and up to 175 have been fired. He details the case of Judge Karen Denoso Stevens, who was pressured to overturn bond grants for former unaccompanied minors without formal appeal.

•

4:44 — Rule of Law Act of 2026 Proposal: The hosts discuss the Rule of Law Act of 2026, which would create independent Article I immigration courts with 15-year terms, Senate-confirmed appellate judges, and removal protections, supported by major nonpartisan legal organizations.

•

6:35 — Republican Opposition and Political Reality: Republicans oppose the reform bill. The hosts express skepticism that the Trump administration or Stephen Miller would support judicial independence, suggesting they would prefer to eliminate immigration courts entirely.

•

8:45 — Kansas City as Case Study: Kansas City's 40,000-case backlog illustrates the real state of immigration courts where the administration hasn't yet fired judges or fast-tracked cases, revealing national statistics as manipulated.

•

10:35 — DOJ Blames Biden Administration: The Department of Justice blamed the Biden administration for the Kansas City backlog, which the hosts criticize as an evasion of responsibility by the current administration.

•

11:39 — Conclusion and Sign-off: The hosts conclude that judicial independence is critical but unlikely under the current administration, thank listeners, and promote their Legal AF Substack.

Speakers

•

Sean Krennik — Co-host, attorney

•

Brian Cabek — Co-host, attorney

⋮