State lawmakers seek greater control over what universities can teach

Original Media · 10m · English · YouTube · PBS NewsHour

TLDR

Texas laws restricting teaching on race, gender, and ideology at public universities have triggered widespread curriculum cuts, faculty self-censorship, and professor resignations. The restrictions, which shift curriculum control from faculty to governor-appointed regents, affect over half of U.S. college students in states with similar laws. A philosophy professor was told Plato's Symposium violated a 'gender ideology' policy, illustrating the broad interpretation of these statutes.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

A 2,000-year-old philosophical text by Plato was flagged as violating a modern 'gender ideology' policy at a major public university.

•

The laws restricting university curricula in Texas predate President Trump's similar demands but align with them, showing a state-level origin for a national movement.

•

A single student's viral video (over 5 million views) triggered a cascade of administrative changes across every public university in Texas, as presidents sought to avoid becoming the next target.

•

Courses on climate change were removed from core curriculum requirements alongside gender and LGBT studies, indicating the restrictions extend beyond identity-related topics.

Key takeaways

•

Texas Senate Bill 17 and related policies remove curricular authority from faculty and give it to political appointees, affecting what can be taught in classrooms across the state's public universities.

•

More than half of all U.S. college students are enrolled in states with at least one law limiting what can be taught or how campuses operate, making Texas part of a national trend.

•

A philosophy professor at Texas A&M was instructed not to teach Plato's Symposium — a 2,000-year-old foundational text — because a department head and dean deemed its discussion of same-sex relationships and gender a violation of policy on 'race and gender ideology.'

•

A viral video of a student challenging a professor's lesson on a nonbinary character in a children's book led to that professor's firing, the demotion of two administrators, and the university president's resignation — prompting leaders at other Texas public universities to preemptively restrict curricula to avoid similar pressure.

•

The University of Texas at Austin eliminated four undergraduate majors focused on race, ethnicity, and gender; Texas Tech faculty reported changes to nearly 300 courses; and the University of Houston cut over 45% of classes from core requirements, including courses on climate change, gender studies, and LGBT studies.

•

Faculty describe pervasive self-censorship: professors avoid teaching Karl Marx, add defensive disclaimers to lectures, and fear a single complaint could cost them their jobs.

•

State Representative Brian Harrison, who led the pressure campaign against Texas A&M, argues that taxpayer-funded universities must be controlled by elected representatives and that fear of consequences for 'indoctrination' is the intended effect.

•

Students argue that if the goal is to avoid political indoctrination, they should be allowed to choose from a full range of courses and decide for themselves what to study.

Notable quotes

“I've been teaching applied ethics for decades. And I was entirely free to design my own syllabus.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:54

“She together with the dean had concluded that it was a violation of policy, which prohibits instruction on topics related to race and gender ideology.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:11

“If you can't teach Plato -- what can you teach as a philosophy professor?”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:26

“The law takes away authority from faculty and professors over what students learn and hands it to regents appointed by the governor.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:02

“It feels in every classroom like you're constantly thinking about like what would a legislator think about what I'm saying right now?”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:27

“It is pointless to have experts in the classroom if you don't trust them to figure out how to teach your classes.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:15

Chapters

•

0:00 — Overview of Texas curriculum restrictions: Texas laws limiting what can be taught at public universities are part of a national trend affecting over half of U.S. college students; the restrictions shift curricular control to governor-appointed regents.

•

0:46 — Professor Peterson and the Plato controversy: Philosophy professor Martin Peterson was told his plan to teach Plato's Symposium violated a new policy prohibiting instruction on 'race and gender ideology' because the ancient text discusses same-sex relationships and a myth of more than two genders.

•

2:44 — Senate Bill 17 and the state-level push: Texas Senate Bill 17 removed faculty authority over curriculum and gave it to political appointees, aligning with a broader conservative push to counter what lawmakers call political indoctrination on campuses.

•

3:47 — Representative Harrison's pressure campaign: State Rep. Brian Harrison used social media and undercover video to target a Texas A&M professor's lesson on gender, sparking a viral controversy that led to firings, demotions, and the university president's resignation.

•

5:05 — Chilling effect across Texas universities: After the Texas A&M incident, presidents at other public universities preemptively restricted curricula to avoid similar political pressure, creating a statewide chilling effect.

•

6:01 — Curriculum cuts and eliminated programs: UT Austin eliminated four majors on race, ethnicity, and gender; Texas Tech modified nearly 300 courses; UH cut over 45% of core classes, including climate change, gender studies, and LGBT studies.

•

6:34 — Student and faculty experiences of self-censorship: Students report professors avoiding topics like Marx and adding defensive disclaimers; faculty describe constant fear that a single complaint could end their careers.

•

8:10 — Political justification and professor's resignation: Rep. Harrison argues taxpayer control via elected officials justifies legislative curriculum oversight; Professor Peterson resigned and moved to a private university, stating experts cannot teach if not trusted.

Speakers

•

Stephanie Sy — Reporter

•

Martin Peterson — Philosophy Professor

•

Brian Harrison — Texas State Representative

•

Melissa McCoul — Professor

•

Valentina Rivas Labarca — Student

•

Daniel Morales — Law Professor and Faculty Union President

⋮