LISTEN LIVE: Supreme Court considers Labor Department power to fine farms breaching worker contracts

Original Media · 1h 43m · English · YouTube · PBS NewsHour

TLDR

This Supreme Court oral argument concerns whether the Department of Labor can administratively impose civil penalties and back wages on employers in the H-2A visa program without violating Article III. The government argues this falls within the public rights exception (immigration and government-granted privileges), while the respondent contends it is a private contract dispute requiring Article III adjudication.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The government conceded that if it loses, the narrowest path would be a statutory ruling allowing initial agency penalties with de novo court review — not a constitutional holding.

•

Justice Kavanaugh suggested the Court might have to write a carefully limited opinion to preserve some administrative immigration penalties (e.g., for employing undocumented workers) while striking down these.

•

The respondent acknowledged that over a third of the affected workers were domestic, not foreign, complicating the government's immigration-program framing.

•

The government argued that the Alien Friends Act of 1798 — which separated deportation power from property-affecting penalties — supports a historical limit on the immigration exception.

•

Justice Barrett noted the government's 'germaneness' test and the respondent's 'nature of claim/remedy' test may converge in practice, both asking how far from core immigration adjudication the penalty extends.

Key takeaways

•

The government asserts that the H-2A program involves two overlapping historical public rights categories: sovereign control of immigration and government-granted privileges, allowing administrative adjudication of penalties.

•

The respondent argues the claims are essentially breach of contract between employer and workers, not immigration adjudication, and that civil penalties historically require Article III courts.

•

Justices debated whether the immigration exception extends beyond the border to ongoing employment conditions, and whether civil penalties can ever be imposed administratively in immigration contexts.

•

The government warned that ruling against it would disrupt numerous federal programs (Medicare, federal contracts, student loans) that use similar administrative penalty schemes.

•

The respondent suggested a narrow ruling could preserve some immigration penalties (e.g., for unlawful employment) while invalidating these labor-condition penalties.

•

Several Justices expressed concern about the lack of a clear limiting principle if the government's broad public rights theory is accepted.

•

The case hinges on whether Oceanic Steamship Co. v. Stranahan (1909) — which upheld administrative fines for bringing inadmissible aliens — controls, or whether it is distinguishable because the violation occurred at the border.

•

Both sides acknowledged the practical consequences: the government emphasized enforcement volume and resource constraints; the respondent emphasized individual rights to jury trial.

Notable quotes

“The government is exercising its plenary immigration power on the employer's behalf to grant aliens visas and allow them to stay and work for that employer. In exchange, the employer agrees to comply with the government's conditions spelled out in 8 U.S.C. 1188 and the implementing regulations.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:20

“Oceanic Steam and Lloyd-Zoboto upheld near-identical remedies a century ago in similar circumstances.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:08

“The privilege is not just the right to enter the United States free and clear, you have a vested right to stay in the United States. Immigration and the visas upon which these aliens are entering have a continuing obligation to abide by the terms of that privilege.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:27

“If the court were to say civil penalties always have to be in Article III courts, that's kind of the nuclear option. Civil penalties are imposed by the government in all kinds of contracts... We've been relying on Oceanic Steam and this long tradition of public rights in all sorts of areas.”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:14

“The government points to no history extending the immigration adjudication doctrine to the imposition of what amounts to a judgment imposing penalties and back wages on a breach of contract theory or involving labor issues more generally.”

▸ Notable quotes · 49:11

“I think the Alien Friends Act, 1798, draws a fairly clear distinction between the executive's power to deport and then actions that affect property.”

▸ Notable quotes · 74:08

Chapters

•

0:00 — Government's Opening Argument: Public Rights Exception: Ms. Harris argues the H-2A program falls within two historical public rights categories — immigration control and government-granted privileges — and that administrative adjudication of civil penalties is supported by Oceanic Steam and longstanding practice.

•

2:01 — Justices Probe Scope of Immigration Exception: Justices question whether the immigration exception extends beyond the border to ongoing employment conditions, and whether civil penalties can be imposed administratively for violations occurring after entry.

•

6:20 — Contract vs. Regulation: Nature of the Claims: Debate over whether the claims are properly characterized as breach of contract (private rights) or enforcement of regulatory conditions (public rights), with discussion of the job order system and regulatory scheme.

•

10:00 — Historical Analogues and Limiting Principles: Extended discussion of Oceanic Steam, the Alien Friends Act, and other historical precedents; Justices press both sides for a workable limiting principle to avoid disrupting other federal programs.

•

48:44 — Respondent's Argument: Private Rights and Article III: Mr. Johnson argues the claims are essentially contract enforcement between employer and workers, not immigration adjudication, and that civil penalties historically require Article III courts under Tull and Jarkesy.

•

58:00 — Justices Test Respondent's Distinctions: Justices challenge whether the respondent's theory would invalidate other administrative penalty schemes, and whether a narrow ruling could preserve some immigration penalties while striking down these.

•

97:38 — Rebuttal and Practical Consequences: Ms. Harris emphasizes the need for clarity and warns of massive disruption to federal enforcement programs; Mr. Johnson highlights individual rights concerns and the government's broad theory.

Speakers

•

Ms. Harris — Counsel for the Government (Solicitor General's Office)

•

Mr. Johnson — Counsel for Respondent (Employer)

•

Chief Justice Roberts — Chief Justice of the United States

•

Justice Thomas — Associate Justice

•

Justice Alito — Associate Justice

•

Justice Kagan — Associate Justice

•

Justice Gorsuch — Associate Justice

•

Justice Kavanaugh — Associate Justice

•

Justice Barrett — Associate Justice

•

Justice Jackson — Associate Justice

•

Justice Sotomayor — Associate Justice

⋮