TLDR
Former NFL player and Bachelor star Colton Underwood recounts his journey from a closeted athlete in the Midwest to an out gay father and advocate. He details the extreme compartmentalization he used to survive — hooking up only with married straight men for protection, abusing Xanax, and even viewing The Bachelor as a form of conversion therapy — before a blackmail crisis forced him out. Now married to political strategist Jordan Brown with a son via surrogacy, Underwood reflects on the privilege of a supportive family, the ongoing legal barriers for LGBTQ+ parents, and learning to relinquish the control that once kept him safe.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Underwood got a cross tattoo on his wrist specifically so he'd be identifiable during hookups, then wrapped it and claimed a wrist injury to explain the covering.
He intentionally avoided letting his college friends meet his high school friends, telling each group he was dating someone in the other location to maintain the facade.
Underwood credits the blackmail attempt as the push he needed to come out, calling it a 'glass half full' perspective on a traumatic event.
His father — who admitted to making homophobic locker-room comments — became his strongest ally, immediately asking 'Who can I tell for you?' and 'How can I take this off your plate?'
Underwood learned to completely sever emotional connection during sex as a survival skill, a pattern that later made intimacy with his husband difficult to relearn.
The Bachelor franchise producers manipulated his 'virgin' storyline despite his request not to, and he only disclosed it because their interviewing tactics mirrored therapy.
Key takeaways
Underwood grew up in a hyper-masculine, conservative Illinois town where the only gay kid was a punchline for coaches and players, and every coach he had made homophobic remarks — including his own father.
To protect himself while closeted, Underwood created a 'folder of boobs' on his phone and exclusively hooked up with married straight men, calculating they had more to lose and wouldn't expose him.
He viewed becoming The Bachelor as a form of self-imposed conversion therapy, believing the public pressure of a televised heterosexual engagement would force him to become straight.
After The Bachelor, Underwood was blackmailed with timestamped evidence of a hookup, which led to a Xanax and alcohol spiral where he dissociated for weeks, taking pills at every meal while hiding in his car for therapy sessions.
His publicist, a gay man, asked him point-blank 'Are you gay?' in a driveway; for the first time Underwood immediately said yes, which began his coming-out cascade to family and the public.
Underwood's father reacted on camera with full support, then off camera said: 'I love you. I'm so proud of you. Go be gay. Just don't become a Democrat.'
He and husband Jordan Brown (a Democratic strategist) spent two and a half years navigating surrogacy, facing legal hurdles including 13 U.S. states where agencies can legally refuse same-sex couples for adoption.
Underwood's greatest hope for his son Bishop is that he never has to compartmentalize his life the way Underwood did — that he can let everyone in at all times without the exhausting control strategies that once kept his father alive.
Notable quotes
“I would only hook up with married straight men. I had a folder of boobs on my phone because it was the only way to protect myself. I didn't want to be gay by any means.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:00“I just remember for me it was like it it just like, you know, people talk about being like shoved into the closet. I just like have this like feeling of like just being pressed like down into myself and just it was rough.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:12“I thought like that was like it like why else would an opportunity like that fall into my lap if if not like sort of put there to sort of help me and like what I was telling myself is like this is going to force me. I'm going to be so publicly straight that I will never be able to be gay again.”
▸ Notable quotes · 46:03“I was quite literally doing therapy in my closet my dad's because I moved back in with him because I was abusing my my medication. So, like I was doing my therapy session from my car outside in the driveway or his closet just to have privacy because I wasn't ready to tell him that I was out yet.”
▸ Notable quotes · 59:35“I love you. I'm so proud of you, go be gay. Just don't become a Democrat.”
▸ Notable quotes · 73:50“I would I would say I I hope that he would never have to compartmentalize his life to the extreme measures that I did. I think looking back it that was something that really hindered me and still affects me even at times today where I'm just I'm not I I just like I like having my life so organized and tidy and and clean and and control, right?”
▸ Notable quotes · 89:54Chapters
1:50 — Athletic Upbringing and Early Signs: Underwood describes growing up in a sports-obsessed family — both parents were All-American athletes — where college scholarships were assumed, not saved for. He was an awkward, uncoordinated kid until a late growth spurt in high school coincided with his realization that he was gay.
6:30 — Closeted in a Conservative Midwest Town: In early-2000s Illinois, the only gay kid in town was a joke used by coaches to shame players. Underwood internalized the homophobia, prayed to be straight, and built elaborate cover stories — including a 'folder of boobs' on his phone and fake girlfriends in different cities — to survive the locker-room culture.
24:10 — NFL Dreams and the Michael Sam Moment: After going undrafted and signing for a $3,500 bonus, Underwood watched fellow draftee Michael Sam come out and get cut despite being SEC Defensive Player of the Year. The league's silence and locker-room ridicule reinforced Underwood's decision to stay closeted, calculating the risk as too high for a practice-squad player.
38:17 — The Bachelor as Conversion Therapy: Underwood joined The Bachelorette and then The Bachelor partly to take a 'year off' from football, but also hoping the public heterosexual narrative would force him straight. Producers exploited his virginity storyline despite his request to protect his top three contestants, and he jumped a fence in Portugal to escape the pressure.
50:00 — Post-Show Crisis: Blackmail and Addiction: After the show ended, Underwood was blackmailed with photographic evidence of a hookup. He spiraled into daily Xanax and alcohol use, dissociating for weeks while hiding therapy sessions in his dad's closet and car. The blackmail forced him to come out to his professional team before his family.
70:00 — Coming Out to Family and Public: His publicist asked point-blank 'Are you gay?' — the first time Underwood said yes aloud. He came out to his mom at dinner (she thought it was a prank), then to his brother and dad on camera. His dad's off-camera quip — 'Go be gay. Just don't become a Democrat' — captured their dynamic.
77:30 — Meeting Jordan, Marriage, and Fatherhood: Underwood met Jordan Brown at his Netflix wrap party; they fell in love during a rainy weekend in Provincetown. Both wanted kids immediately. They navigated a two-and-a-half-year surrogacy journey, confronting legal barriers like 13 states allowing adoption discrimination against same-sex couples.
80:30 — Advocacy, Healing, and Letting Go of Control: Now a father to Bishop, Underwood advocates for LGBTQ+ family rights and reflects on the '15 versions of me' he's lived through. His core lesson: the hyper-control that once protected him now hinders intimacy; he hopes Bishop never has to compartmentalize his life and can let everyone in fully.
Speakers
Colton Underwood — Guest
Host — Interviewer