TLDR
In a prison interview, Julius Mullins recounts the 2019 murder of his ex-girlfriend's mother, Manuela Allen, claiming it was a botched burglary for guns. The interviewer and behavior expert Greg Hartley challenge this, presenting evidence of Mullins' obsessive rage after the breakup, his calculated stalking of the home, the extreme violence of 38 stab wounds plus strangulation and a gunshot, and his post-murder manipulation — framing the husband, comforting the daughter to win her back, and showing pleasure when disparaging his ex. Mullins admits revenge drove other actions but denies it for the murder, displays flat affect, claims religious conversion, and remarkably states he considers himself less fortunate than the family he destroyed. The episode reveals a killer who masks rage behind a veneer of impulse and faith.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Mullins maintained a literal 'to-do list' of planned burglaries targeting homes with gun collections, including the Allen residence, weeks before the murder.
Mullins methodically checked every room in the Allen house before the attack, confirming the locations of all four family members, yet claims he 'wasn't there for them.'
Mullins told the interviewer he felt 'glad' that the murder resulted in Melanie talking to him again, admitting the tragedy created the reconnection he desired.
Behavior expert Greg Hartley identified genuine amusement and pleasure — not remorse — leaking through Mullins' flat affect when he discussed his 'bad boy' persona and insulted his ex-girlfriend.
Mullins believes he is less fortunate than the family whose mother he murdered, arguing they have more 'opportunities and resources' to heal while he only has 'something to look forward to.'
Key takeaways
Mullins spiraled from a promising athlete into homelessness and crime after his breakup with Melanie Allen, using drugs and alcohol to numb the pain and developing a 'to-do list' of burglaries targeting homes with gun collections, including the Allens'.
Despite claiming the murder was an unplanned panic reaction during a burglary, Mullins admitted he canvassed the entire Allen home beforehand — checking each room to locate occupants — and chose to enter the master bedroom knowing Manuela was there, where he found a knife and attacked her.
After the murder, Mullins engaged in calculated deception: he disposed of the body, cleaned up at the school gym, spread false rumors implicating Melanie's father and brother, then inserted himself as a supportive presence in Melanie's life, which the behavior expert identifies as a manipulative tactic to regain access to her.
Behavior analyst Greg Hartley detected 'contained pleasure' in Mullins' micro-expressions — specifically when he smirked discussing his 'bad boy' image and when trash-talking Melanie — revealing amusement rather than remorse, and noted the absence of sorrow's distinct facial markers.
Mullins explicitly admitted he was 'glad' the murder brought Melanie back into his life and acknowledged revenge motivated his robbery of the Allen home and sleeping with Melanie's best friend, yet he denies the murder itself was revenge, creating a contradiction the interviewer presses.
The extreme violence — 38 stab wounds mostly to the head, strangulation, and a gunshot — combined with Mullins' prior threats to 'slash her tires' and messages calling Melanie a 'sadistic bitch,' strongly indicates a crime of personal rage rather than a property crime gone wrong.
Mullins displays a profound empathy deficit: he claims he is 'less fortunate' than the Allen family because they 'lost' something while he has 'something to look forward to,' dismisses their victim impact statements as unread, and objects to being labeled a 'killer' despite his guilty plea.
Mullins frames his current identity through religious conversion, stating he has 'worked through' his 'dark and sadistic' past, but the interviewer challenges whether faith erases the reality that he will 'always and forever be a murderer.'
Notable quotes
“I looked at my hands and saw all the blood that was everywhere”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:04“I knew that more than likely I was either going to die or that I was going to prison”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:32“It was on my to-do list”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:02“I've always been a sneaky individual”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:44“Yeah, sadly. I guess you could say that”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:21“To let emotion go is to be out of control. Which I'm not going to do”
▸ Notable quotes · 38:32Chapters
0:00 — Teaser and case overview: The episode opens with Mullins describing the bloody aftermath of the murder and the central question: was it a robbery gone wrong or a crime of rage against his ex-girlfriend's family?
3:45 — Background: Mullins and Melanie: Mullins recounts his upbringing, academic struggles, football success, and relationship with Melanie Allen — a valedictorian from a loving family — and how the breakup triggered his spiral into drugs, homelessness, and criminal planning.
12:12 — The night of the murder: Mullins gives a detailed account of entering the Allen home, canvassing rooms, finding a knife in the master bedroom, and attacking Manuela when she woke up, describing the violence and his immediate cleanup efforts.
21:49 — Aftermath and manipulation: Mullins describes disposing of the body at a lake, cleaning up at the school gym, framing the husband and son, and then inserting himself into Melanie's grief to regain her trust, which she initially resisted.
28:50 — Investigation and confession: Police evidence — bike surveillance, footprint match, DNA — led to Mullins' confession after four hours of interrogation, during which he falsely accused Peter Allen of masterminding the murder.
32:15 — Behavior analysis with Greg Hartley: Former Army interrogator Greg Hartley analyzes Mullins' nonverbal cues, identifying contained pleasure when discussing his crimes and the absence of genuine sorrow, concluding Mullins feels anger and disappointment but not remorse.
35:40 — Confrontation on motive: revenge vs. robbery: The interviewer challenges Mullins' robbery narrative with logical inconsistencies — breaking in armed, knowing the family was home, targeting a house with locked safes — and presses him on revenge, which Mullins admits drove other actions but denies for the murder.
39:40 — Wrath, religion, and empathy deficit: Mullins discusses his Christian conversion, rejects the 'killer' label, claims he is less fortunate than his victims, and the episode closes with Melanie's victim impact statement describing her life as a 'living nightmare.'
Speakers
Interviewer — Journalist/Interviewer
Julius Mullins — Convicted murderer
Greg Hartley — Behavior analysis expert