'People's Court' Fiancé Charged with MURDER After Episode Airs | Michelle Parker Murder Case

Original Media · 43m · English · YouTube · Ashleigh Banfield x Drop Dead Serious

TLDR

Ashley Banfield details the 2011 disappearance of Michelle Parker, who vanished the same day her episode of The People's Court aired. After 15 years of investigation, her ex-fiancé Dale Smith Jr. was arrested for second-degree murder in October 2026, but the arrest affidavit remains sealed and Michelle's body has never been found.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The People's Court (1980s) is the progenitor of all modern judge shows — Harvey Levin was a consulting producer before founding TMZ.

•

Michelle's family and police initially said Dale was NOT a suspect (as late as Nov 27, 2011), then reversed 24 hours later.

•

A judge returned the twins to Dale despite child welfare officials citing alleged violence and recommending removal.

•

Dale's attorney was allowed to view the sealed affidavit in a secure setting but not keep a copy — highly unusual.

•

Second-degree murder is not death-penalty eligible, but prosecutors fear Dale might flee because he doesn't know if charges could be upgraded to first-degree.

•

Detective Maresca stated early on he believed this was a 'two-person crime' — yet only Dale has been arrested after 15 years.

Key takeaways

•

Michelle Parker disappeared on November 17, 2011, after dropping off her 3-year-old twins at ex-fiancé Dale Smith Jr.'s apartment — the same day their People's Court episode aired.

•

Dale Smith Jr. was named the primary suspect 11 days later but wasn't arrested until October 14, 2026, charged with second-degree murder and held without bond.

•

Key evidence includes: a one-word text 'Waterford' sent from Michelle's phone (which pinged near Dale's apartment, not Waterford Lakes), her phone recovered from a lake in 2013, and her abandoned Hummer with business decals removed.

•

Police believe it was a 'two-person crime' — raising questions about whether an accomplice exists and if another arrest is coming.

•

The arrest followed Dale's son (one of the twins) visiting police on October 2, 2026, and Dale booking a flight to Colombia for October 16, 2026.

•

The 46-page arrest affidavit is sealed; it reportedly contains recovered deleted text messages and a recent interview with one of Dale's friends.

•

Michelle's family, including her mother Yvonne Stewart, still seeks to find Michelle's remains for a proper burial after 15 years.

Notable quotes

“Never tell a judge with all due respect. Never do that.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:00

“She vanished. She fucking vanished.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:20

“Finding a phone at the bottom of the lake is a holy shit moment.”

▸ Notable quotes · 21:51

“You look outside before you go to bed... Did it snow? Fuck yeah, it snowed. Circumstantial.”

▸ Notable quotes · 30:58

“We are the fucking people's court.”

▸ Notable quotes · 32:18

“I just want my daughter back.”

▸ Notable quotes · 42:00

Chapters

•

0:00 — The People's Court Legacy & Michelle Parker's Appearance: Ashley introduces the show's move to Florida and traces reality court TV back to The People's Court (Judge Wapner, Harvey Levin). Michelle Parker appeared on Judge Milian's court in 2011 disputing an engagement ring with ex-fiancé Dale Smith Jr., describing their relationship as abusive.

•

3:00 — Disappearance & Immediate Aftermath: On the episode's air date (Nov 17, 2011), Michelle dropped off twins at Dale's Orlando condo and vanished. Surveillance shows her arrival at 3:18 PM; a one-word text 'Waterford' sent at 4:26 PM pinged near Dale's apartment, not Waterford Lakes. Her Hummer found abandoned next day with decals removed; red-light camera caught it at 8:55 PM without decals.

•

13:00 — Investigation & Early Suspicions: Police searched Dale's condo and father's home within days. Dale refused a polygraph and lawyered up. On Nov 27, police and Michelle's family said Dale wasn't a suspect; next day Chief Rooney named him primary suspect. Michelle's phone recovered from a lake in 2013. Detective Maresca called it a 'two-person crime.' Custody battle ensued; judge returned twins to Dale over child welfare objections.

•

25:00 — Cold Case & 2026 Arrest: Case went cold after years of searches. In August 2023, police searched Dale's father's property (concrete slab) — nothing found. On Oct 14, 2026, police arrested Dale at work for second-degree murder. Trigger: Dale's son (now adult) visited police Oct 2 asking about investigation; Dale booked flight to Colombia for Oct 16. Affidavit (46 pages) sealed; contains recovered texts and friend's interview.

•

35:00 — Legal Proceedings & Unanswered Questions: Dale pleaded not guilty, held without bond. Attorney calls case circumstantial; Ashley explains why circumstantial evidence can be strong (snow analogy). Prosecutors want affidavit sealed until Oct 26 to complete out-of-state witness interviews. Media fighting to unseal. Key questions remain: where is Michelle's body? Who drove the Hummer? Who sent the 'Waterford' text? Was there an accomplice?

•

41:00 — Family's Plea & Closing: Michelle's mother Yvonne Stewart expresses relief at arrest but still wants her daughter's remains for burial. Twins (now adults) grew up without mother. Ashley promises updates when affidavit unsealed and emphasizes transparency in the justice system.

Speakers

•

Ashley Banfield — Host

⋮