TLDR
This episode covers the case of 5-year-old Sailor Hayes, an autistic non-verbal girl who died while on vacation with her parents in South Carolina. Her parents, John (71) and Jordan (31) Hayes, called 911 claiming she wandered off, but her body was found the next day in a river behind their rental home. The parents were arrested and charged with child endangerment, denied bond, and have been jailed for over 70 days. The coroner ruled the cause of death as asphyxia due to drowning with child neglect as a contributing factor, but listed the manner of death as undetermined — unable to conclude whether it was accidental or homicidal. Key evidence includes a Project Lifesaver tracking device the parents said Sailor was wearing, which was later found in Virginia, not on her body.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The Project Lifesaver tracker is not a consumer device like an AirTag — it's a regulated, law-enforcement-affiliated device that must be physically applied/removed by authorities, making its absence from Sailor's body highly suspicious.
The 40-year age gap between the parents (71 and 31) and Jordan's social media documentation of Sailor's water attraction appear as foreshadowing.
The coroner explicitly included 'child neglect' as a contributing factor on the death certificate while leaving manner of death undetermined — a rare and significant classification.
The judge denied bond outright at the first hearing, stating 'there is no way on this earth that I am going to grant a PR bond,' despite the defense arguing it was an accident.
John Hayes was arrested for simple assault in jail just weeks after the bond hearing, indicating ongoing behavioral issues.
Key takeaways
Sailor Hayes, a 5-year-old non-verbal autistic girl, died in August 2024 while on vacation in Pawleys Island, SC; her body was found in a river behind the rental home.
Parents John (71) and Jordan (31) Hayes called 911 claiming she wandered off while they prepared for the beach, but were arrested days later in Tennessee and charged with unlawfully placing a child at risk/abandonment.
Both parents have been denied bond and held in Georgetown County Jail for over 70 days; the judge cited the 'egregious nature of these charges and past criminal history.'
A Project Lifesaver tracker (specialized law-enforcement device for at-risk individuals) was supposedly on Sailor, but authorities found it in the family's Virginia home, not on her body.
The coroner ruled cause of death as asphyxia due to drowning with child neglect as a contributing factor, but manner of death as 'undetermined' — cannot conclude accidental vs. homicidal.
Both parents have prior child abuse charges: Jordan charged in Feb 2024 (felonies involving a juvenile male, not Sailor); John arrested July 2023 for child abuse disregarding life (dismissed Feb 2024).
Investigators allege the parents misled search efforts and pointed them away from where Sailor's body was found.
John Hayes was charged with simple assault in jail after an altercation with another inmate.
Notable quotes
“I need help. My little uh four-year-old, 5-year-old girl is very autistic. Uh just escaped.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:08“There is no way on this earth that I'm going to grant a PR bond. That that's not going to happen on my watch.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:22“This classification reflects the inability to conclusively determine whether Sailor's death was accidental or the result of a homicidal act.”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:22“This has to be physically removed. And it was placed on by by police. So the only way to remove it is by somebody doing it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 21:23“If this goes the way it may go and this is an accident and you've incarcerated them I guarantee you're going to have a civil lawsuit civil lawsuit on this case.”
▸ Notable quotes · 27:14“Why was it removed? Why' you say it was on her when it was somewhere when it was out of state in a vehicle cut? And that's the answer. No one's gotten to yet.”
▸ Notable quotes · 23:25Chapters
0:00 — Case Overview and 911 Call: Introduction to the Sailor Hayes case: 5-year-old autistic girl found dead in SC river after parents reported her missing. Playback of John Hayes' 911 call describing her disappearance while getting ready for the beach.
2:00 — Parents' Background and Arrest: Details on John (71) and Jordan (31) Hayes, their 40-year age gap, Jordan's social media posts about Sailor's water attraction. Parents arrested in Tennessee, charged with child endangerment, denied bond.
8:00 — Project Lifesaver Tracker Evidence: Critical evidence: Sailor was supposed to wear a Project Lifesaver tracker (law-enforcement device for at-risk individuals), but it was found in Virginia, not on her body. Parents allegedly told investigators she had it on.
10:00 — Prior Child Abuse Charges: Both parents have prior child abuse charges: Jordan charged Feb 2024 with felonies involving a juvenile male; John arrested July 2023 for child abuse disregarding life (dismissed Feb 2024).
15:00 — Coroner's Findings and Undetermined Manner: Coroner ruled cause of death: asphyxia due to drowning, with child neglect as contributing factor. Manner of death: undetermined — cannot conclude accidental vs. homicidal.
16:00 — Expert Analysis with Retired NYPD Detective David Starney: Detective Starney explains the significance of 'undetermined' manner, the tracker removal implications, why the judge likely denied bond, and the investigative challenges in proving intent.
Speakers
Chris Stewart — Host
John Hayes — Father of Sailor Hayes
Jordan Hayes — Mother of Sailor Hayes
911 Dispatcher — Emergency Operator
Judge — Bond Hearing Judge
Defense Attorney (Mr. Axelrod/McCoy) — John Hayes' Attorney
David Starney — Retired NYPD Detective