TLDR
Critical Role's Magic: The Gathering Commander Showdown Group 2 features Taliesin Jaffe, Whitney Moore, Elise Work, and Olivia Gobert-Hicks playing randomly assigned decks for two finals spots, with live auctions of signed merchandise benefiting the Critical Role Foundation. Olivia dominates with a Hazel squirrel deck she's piloted before, while Elise advances with a landfall deck. The event showcases the Foundation's $4M+ raised for seven partner charities since 2020. Commentary by Irene and Bosco provides humor and analysis throughout. Loser decks are auctioned off at the end, with Taliesin's dragon deck and Whitney's Grixis spellslinger deck fetching $350 and $360 respectively. Alex Ward and Zac Rinaldo await in Friday's finals. The tournament emphasizes community, charity, and chaotic fun over competitive perfection. 100% of auction proceeds support the Critical Role Foundation. The event is sponsored by eBay Live. The Critical Role Foundation supports 826LA, Red Nose Day, Outright International, Shanti Bhavan, First Nations Development Institute, The Pablove Foundation, and NCWIT. The show blends gameplay, charity, and entertainment. The players' varying experience levels create dynamic interactions. The auction items include signed playmats, binders, and booster packs. The commentary team provides both play-by-play and comedic relief. The game features memorable moments like Taliesin's misplayed Beast Within and Olivia's overwhelming squirrel board state. The event concludes with the announcement of the top four finalists.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Taliesin's Beast Within removal on Olivia's Vine Reap Mentor backfired: it created a Food token and a 3/3 Beast token, ultimately strengthening her board.
Maskwood Nexus on Olivia's side made all her Squirrel tokens into every creature type, including Krakens/Leviathans, which nullified Elise's Serpent of the Yawning Depths' unblockable ability (which only allowed blocking by Krakens, Leviathans, Octopuses, and Serpents).
Olivia had extensive prior experience with the exact Hazel deck she was assigned, having built and played it multiple times before.
Taliesin's dragon deck only managed to put one dragon (Chaos Dragon) onto the battlefield before being overwhelmed by Olivia's squirrel horde.
The commentary team (Irene and Bosco) have access to the live auction feed and chat during the broadcast, allowing real-time interaction with bidders.
Whitney's Anhelo deck was intentionally placed with its back face (Terror of the Peaks lantern side) visible during deck selection — a subtle hint from deck builders about which side to play.
Key takeaways
Critical Role Foundation has raised over $4 million since 2020 for seven partner charities including 826LA, Red Nose Day, Outright International, Shanti Bhavan, First Nations Development Institute, The Pablove Foundation, and NCWIT.
Players receive randomly assigned preconstructed Commander decks, not decks of their choosing, creating unpredictable gameplay.
Olivia Gobert-Hicks won decisively with Hazel of the Root Bloom (Golgari squirrels), a deck she had previously built and piloted multiple times.
Elise Work advanced with Aesi, Tyrant of Gyre Strait (Simic landfall), though she missed several landfall triggers due to complexity.
Taliesin Jaffe hadn't played Magic since 1994 (Arabian Nights) and received a dragon tribal deck (Rondel, Rage of the Ancients).
Whitney Moore, a relatively new player, struggled with the complex Grixis spellslinger deck (Anhelo, the Painter) which requires intricate stack management.
Live auctions of signed Ultra Pro playmats, binders, and booster packs run throughout the event, with 100% proceeds to the Foundation.
Loser decks are raffled/auctioned at the end — Taliesin's dragon deck sold for $350, Whitney's Anhelo deck for $360.
Notable quotes
“Since 2020. Thanks to this incredible community, the Critical Role Foundation has raised over $4 million to help people around the world.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:37“You have shown us what's possible when a community comes together and we're not all just dreaming of change. We're doing our best to leave the world better than we found it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:32“I've been accumulating power. Slowly building it up. I did watch a bunch of YouTube videos.”
▸ Notable quotes · 33:30“My goal is never to win a game of magic. It's always to be the most annoying.”
▸ Notable quotes · 54:45“She's dog walking. She's running amuck.”
▸ Notable quotes · 76:37“The point is love.”
▸ Notable quotes · 108:26“Olivia was showing them how it's done so fiercely... Molly whopped the absolute loving shit out of every person playing this game.”
▸ Notable quotes · 123:30“Hazel is definitely the deck to get, especially for Olivia... when she is allowed to, she will absolutely dog walk.”
▸ Notable quotes · 126:25Chapters
0:00 — Critical Role Foundation Charity Overview: Promotional segment highlighting the Foundation's seven partner charities and $4M+ raised since 2020, with repeated messaging about community impact.
29:07 — Live Auction: Signed Binder & Booster Pack: Irene and Bosco open an Avatar: The Last Airbender booster pack, reveal cards, sign the binder, and run a live auction that closes at $166.
27:56 — Player Introductions & Deck Selection: Irene and Bosco introduce Group 2 players (Taliesin, Whitney, Elise, Olivia). Players randomly select preconstructed decks: Taliesin gets dragon tribal (Rondel), Elise gets Simic landfall (Aesi), Whitney gets Grixis spellslinger (Anhelo), Olivia gets Golgari squirrels (Hazel).
46:40 — Gameplay: Early Turns & Ramp: First several turns focus on land drops, ramp, and setup. Taliesin uses Beast Within on Olivia's Vine Reap Mentor. Elise plays landfall enchantments. Olivia establishes Skullclamp and begins squirrel token generation.
76:31 — Commentary Break & Auction: Signed Playmat: Irene and Bosco analyze board states while a Critical Role Baddies playmat (Fresh Cut Grass vs. bird) auctions for $340. They discuss missed triggers, threat assessment, and Olivia's commanding position.
89:40 — Gameplay: Mid-Game Explosion: Olivia explodes with Chatterstorm (3 squirrels), Camellia, and Squirrel Nest. Taliesin casts Aesi and plays multiple lands. Elise's Serpent of the Yawning Depths hits board. Whitney casts Anhelo and Kas, Dissident Mage.
100:00 — Gameplay: Olivia's Dominance & Taliesin's Exit: Olivia's squirrel army overwhelms. Taliesin's Andre's Forerunners pumps team for 33 damage but Olivia blocks with three Spellbinding Sopranos. Taliesin dies to squirrel combat damage, stays for commentary.
122:50 — Post-Game Analysis & Final Auctions: Irene and Bosco recap: Olivia's dog walk, Elise's landfall potential, Whitney's deck complexity, Taliesin's misplays. Loser decks auctioned: Taliesin's dragon deck ($350), Whitney's Anhelo deck ($360). Finalists announced: Alex Ward, Zac Rinaldo, Olivia Gobert-Hicks, Elise Work.
Speakers
Irene — Host/Commentator
Bosco — Host/Commentator
Taliesin Jaffe — Player / Critical Role Cast
Whitney Moore — Player
Elise Work — Player
Olivia Gobert-Hicks — Player
Alex Ward — Finalist (mentioned)
Zac Rinaldo — Finalist (mentioned)