How BAD Are Things In Indianapolis If Josh Downs Is Celebrating Being Traded?!

Original Media · 6m · English · YouTube · The Pat McAfee Show

TLDR

Colts podcast hosts react to the Josh Downs trade to Kansas City, framing it as the latest sign of a franchise in free fall. They mock players who publicly celebrate leaving Indianapolis — Downs, DeForest Buckner, Jonathan Taylor — and liken the current Colts to the 2016 Browns: a defeated roster entering a rebuild with no clear coach or GM plan. The Chiefs get needed slot depth, but the hosts argue Downs isn't the true X receiver Kansas City still lacks, and Mahomes' offense has already shrunk to screens and catch-and-run concepts.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The hosts, as paying season-ticket holders, openly root for the organization to bottom out and treat the idea of fan-run GM weeks as a plausible improvement.

•

Jonathan Taylor's 'thank you' social-media post was reportedly drafted as a contingency in case he was traded, not as a genuine farewell.

•

The Chiefs' offense has almost entirely abandoned downfield passing attempts, not just completions, and the hosts argue no single trade can reverse that schematic shift.

Key takeaways

•

Josh Downs was traded to the Chiefs at the deadline after a standout season, and the hosts view his 'thank God' tweet as emblematic of a locker room that wants out of Indianapolis.

•

Multiple former Colts — DeForest Buckner, Jonathan Taylor — have reacted with visible relief when leaving, which the hosts interpret as a damning indictment of the organization's culture and direction.

•

The Colts are effectively in a 'defeated year' and starting a rebuild comparable to the 2016 Browns, with no certainty at head coach, general manager, or even Jonathan Taylor's return next season.

•

The hosts, who identify as season-ticket holders, express resigned frustration: they feel the franchise doesn't care about winning, joking that suite holders might as well rotate as GM for a week.

•

Kansas City acquired Downs for immediate slot-receiver help given injuries to Rashee Rice, Xavier Worthy, and Marquise Brown, and his man-beating ability fits their current short-passing scheme.

•

The Chiefs' deeper problem remains the absence of a true X receiver who can win downfield and take the top off defenses; Mahomes and Andy Reid have already adapted the offense to shorter, quicker throws.

•

The Colts face the Chiefs in back-to-back weeks, and the hosts' only remaining rooting interest is avoiding further injuries to core players like Taylor and Quenton Nelson.

•

Reggie Wayne, now a Colts coach, joked about suiting up again — a moment the hosts treated as dark humor underscoring the receiver room's emptiness.

Notable quotes

“We are very thankful. Usually people are a little emotional. Usually people emotional right there to heal.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:58

“WHY ARE THEY DROPPING TO THEIR KNEES AND THANKING THE LORD THAT THEY'RE GETTING THE HELL OUT OF TOWN FOR US?”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:48

“You just got to accept that the Colts right now are the 2016 Browns. We are a defeated year.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:11

“I want the guy who's chewing on his tongue being the head coach. And then I want them to also tell him when he gets hired, hey, by the way, don't forget Josh Macau's going to be the head coach next year after you.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:30

“Is he going to help them? Absolutely. Is he the piece that unlocks it all in my opinion? I don't think so.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:36

“They are not attempting passes down the field, much less completing them really.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:30

Chapters

•

0:00 — Josh Downs trade reaction: Hosts discuss the last-minute trade of Josh Downs to Kansas City, criticize his 'thank God' tweet, and compare it to DeForest Buckner and Jonathan Taylor's relieved exits.

•

3:18 — Colts as a defeated franchise: The hosts declare the Colts a 'defeated year' akin to the 2016 Browns, question who will coach or run the team next season, and joke about fan-run GM rotations.

•

4:00 — Jonathan Taylor uncertainty: Taylor's future with the Colts is doubtful; his social-media farewell was a pre-written contingency, and the hosts' priority is simply keeping him healthy for a potential trade.

•

4:56 — Chiefs' receiver needs and Downs' fit: Kansas City needed slot depth due to injuries; Downs helps immediately against man coverage but does not solve the lack of a true downfield X receiver.

•

5:48 — Mahomes' adapted offense: The Chiefs' offense has shifted to screens, catch-and-run, and pipe plays; they rarely attempt deep passes, and Kenneth Walker's emergence drives the scheme.

Speakers

•

Host 1 — Primary host / season-ticket holder

•

Host 2 — Co-host / analyst

•

Host 3 — Occasional third voice

⋮