TLDR
Tim Miller and Bill Kristol analyze the 2024 midterm election results, where Democrats achieved a historic 13-point national popular vote victory, flipping the House, Senate (56 seats), 11 state legislative chambers, and winning breakthrough races in Mississippi and Texas. They discuss Trump's post-election flailing — including his 60 Minutes interview where he refused to endorse JD Vance, admitted deportation policy was 'too tough,' and promoted Stephen Miller to Chief of Staff — plus the exploding Jensen Huang/Nvidia Chinese spy scandal involving compromised export controls and Rubio's questionable role as NSA. They also cover potential Hegseth impeachment and Democratic strategy for the lame duck session.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The 13-point national popular vote margin exceeded even the most bullish predictions (Kristol had predicted 8-9 points)
Trump admitted on 60 Minutes his deportation policy was 'too tough' and suggested legal status for hotel/landscape workers — then promoted arch-restrictionist Stephen Miller to Chief of Staff days later
Marco Rubio as NSA was briefed on the Huang Chinese spy compromise in spring but took no action; the intelligence community produced a report and 'just sat there' while Trump overrode them
The wave's depth (state legislative chambers) mattered more than breadth — Wisconsin flipped despite extreme gerrymandering, North Carolina and Georgia poised for redistricting reform
Jensen Huang received a 'you look great in a leather jacket' compliment from the Chinese operative — a tell that Kristol notes 'nerds don't look good in leather jackets'
Key takeaways
Democrats won a massive 13-point national popular vote wave — the largest in modern history — flipping House, Senate (56 seats), 11 state legislative chambers, and overcoming structural GOP advantages
Trump is refusing to relinquish the spotlight: won't endorse Vance for 2028, promoted Stephen Miller as 'enforcer' Chief of Staff, and continues half-hearted election denialism
The Jensen Huang scandal is potentially bigger than Iran-Contra: Nvidia CEO compromised by Chinese honeypot, Trump personally intervened to bring him on China trip despite intelligence warnings, export controls loosened
Pete Hegseth could face impeachment during the lame duck Republican House — several outgoing members may vote against him to retain dignity
Polling misses were as large as 2020 but driven by weighting decisions rather than 'shy Trump voters,' creating media asymmetry in coverage
Mississippi electing its first Black senator since Reconstruction (Scott Colom) and Texas Democratic victories were emotionally historic for long-time activists
Democrats should stay on offense: pass their agenda, don't pre-negotiate, demand hearings on Huang scandal, and push for ICE detention reform immediately
Notable quotes
“He can't stand being off center stage. So I don't think it's hard to imagine him giving a helpful convention speech in 2028. I'll tell you that much.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:00“The generic ending up at 13 there... which is massive. It's so much the largest in the... I was going through your highlight reel this morning and you were talking about eight or nine and even in like the bullish Bill Crystal.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:57“It was too big to rig. You know, that was your newsletter the day after the election. I think that's an important takeaway.”
▸ Notable quotes · 19:02“He's either he likes Jensen Wong... he's a little credulous. He likes, you know, and Trump says that himself last night, right, you know, in the into a gaggle at the airport... Well, I he's a good guy. I don't think he really I didn't do anything more wrong than anyone else did. This is ludicrous.”
▸ Notable quotes · 48:41“This is more serious than Iran-Contra. Just objectively, Iran-Contra was problematic... Still, that's nothing compared to this kind of thing. We're helping China's AI, you know, AI capabilities.”
▸ Notable quotes · 53:48“The Democrats should ask that. They shouldn't just ask it. They should pass it in my opinion and at least once or twice to make Trump veto it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 38:27Chapters
0:16 — Election Recap: The 13-Point Democratic Wave: Miller and Kristol analyze the historic midterm results: 13-point national popular vote, House and Senate flips (56 seats), 11 state legislative chambers, and the structural implications through 2032.
5:55 — Historic Victories in Mississippi and Texas: Discussion of Scott Colom's breakthrough in Mississippi (first Black senator since Reconstruction) and emotional Texas wins for Gina Hinojosa and James Talarico, moving long-time activists to tears.
11:58 — Polling Misses and Weighting Errors: Analysis of why 2024 polling errors matched 2020 magnitude but were driven by weighting decisions rather than shy voters, and the media asymmetry in coverage.
19:10 — Trump's 60 Minutes Interview: Vance, Immigration, Miller: Trump refuses to endorse JD Vance, admits deportation policy was 'too tough,' suggests legal status for hotel workers, and promotes Stephen Miller as Chief of Staff — analyzed as 'mob boss enforcer' move.
45:00 — Corruption and the Jensen Huang/Nvidia Scandal: Explosive Chinese honeypot operation compromising Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang; Trump personally overrode intelligence warnings to bring Huang on China trip; export controls loosened; Rubio's questionable role as NSA.
39:40 — Hegseth Impeachment and Lame Duck Strategy: Potential Pete Hegseth impeachment in Republican lame duck House; Democrats urged to act with urgency, pass agenda, and not pre-negotiate with themselves.
Speakers
Tim Miller — Host
Bill Kristol — Guest Co-host