TLDR
Alec Murdoch's defense team argues the murder indictment should be dismissed because lead investigator David Owen gave false testimony to the grand jury about blood spatter on Murdoch's shirt and how guns at the property were loaded. The defense claims SLED's own lab found no human blood on the shirt, and Owen admitted at trial he used "trickery" about gun loading during interrogation. Prosecutors counter that the evidence was not overtly false, an expert still supports the spatter opinion, and ample other evidence supports probable cause. Judge McCaslin will rule within a week. If dismissed, the state would re-present to a grand jury on December 10. Murdoch remains in prison for financial crimes.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The lead investigator admitted under cross-examination that he knowingly used a false claim about gun loading as an interrogation tactic — "I'm allowed to do trickery" — and then repeated that same false claim to two separate grand juries months later.
SLED's own laboratory twice confirmed no human blood on Murdoch's shirt, yet the agency later hired an outside expert to assert high-velocity spatter on that same shirt, and the lead investigator presented the outside opinion to the grand jury without disclosing the lab's negative findings.
The same lead investigator, David Owen, had a prior murder indictment dismissed because he withheld exculpatory evidence from the defense — the victim's mother's statement about suicidal ideation — which only surfaced after a mistrial.
Key takeaways
Defense attorney Jim Griffin asserts David Owen knowingly presented false testimony to the Colleton County grand jury: that high-velocity blood spatter from Paul Murdoch was found on Alec's shirt with DNA matching Paul, Maggie, and Alec, when SLED's lab had twice confirmed no human blood on the shirt via hematrace testing.
Griffin details a pattern: Owen was told in August and November 2021 that the shirt tested negative for blood, yet in February–March 2022 SLED sought an outside expert to declare high-velocity spatter on the same shirt, and Owen carried that claim to the grand jury in July 2022.
Owen admitted at trial that his grand jury testimony about the shirt was incorrect, and acknowledged he used "trickery" during an August 2021 interrogation by telling Murdoch that multiple guns at Moselle were loaded with the same buckshot/turkey load as the murder weapon — a claim trial evidence showed was false for every gun on the property.
The defense cites State v. Kawuchcci, where Judge Roger Young dismissed an indictment because Owen withheld the victim's mother's statement that her daughter had contemplated suicide by hanging; Griffin argues this shows a pattern of Owen misleading grand juries.
Prosecutor Creighton Waters distinguishes Kawuchcci, arguing all evidence here was litigated at trial, no discovery violation occurred, and the blood spatter opinion by expert Tom Bevel remains valid — the hematrace result goes to weight, not admissibility.
Waters contends that even without the two contested statements, the grand jury heard overwhelming probable cause: the kennel video placing Murdoch at the scene minutes before the murders, his lies about his whereabouts, GSR on a raincoat, matching Blackout rifle casings, a missing Benelli shotgun, and a compelling timeline.
Judge Deborah McCaslin questioned the forensic sequence: the shirt was sprayed with LCV (luminol), which can react with non-blood substances and destroys the ability to confirm blood, yet Owen presented the spatter claim to the grand jury without disclosing the lab's negative hematrace result.
McCaslin will issue a written ruling by the following Friday and asked whether the state could re-present to the grand jury by December 10, signaling she is seriously considering dismissal of the current indictment.
Notable quotes
“That puts him there. That puts his son's spattered blood when his brain ejects from his head on his shirt. And it's false. It's fabricated. It was made from whole cloth.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:14“So, so I ask him, "So, you didn't know at the time, but you know now that what you told the Colin County Grand Jury was not correct. Is that fair?" He says, "In reference to the shirt, correct?" So, he's admitted that what he told the grand jury was false as to the shirt.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:48“I said, "So you tricked him?" "I'm allowed to do trickery." I said, "Yeah, you're allowed to do trickery." So you tried to trick him, didn't you? Goes, "That's correct."”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:14“This was definitely still a ball in play. This was not overtly false. This was what the agent uh um understood at the time.”
▸ Notable quotes · 20:13“The blood from his murdered son spraying through the air as this raining back on him puts him there and it puts him there falsely.”
▸ Notable quotes · 27:07“I'll issue a written order. Um, and I'll have it done next week. I'll try to get it to you by Friday of next week. Um, let me ask if I if you had to go back to the grand jury, could you have it done and ready to go April 5th?”
▸ Notable quotes · 28:38Chapters
0:37 — Hearing overview and defense motion: Anette Levy introduces the hearing where Alec Murdoch's lawyers seek dismissal of the murder indictment, alleging lead investigator David Owen lied to the grand jury about blood spatter on Murdoch's shirt and how guns at Moselle were loaded.
2:30 — Kawuchcci precedent and Owen's history: Griffin references State v. Kawuchcci, where Judge Young dismissed an indictment because Owen withheld the victim's mother's statement about suicidal ideation; Griffin argues this shows a pattern of Owen misleading grand juries.
5:00 — Blood spatter claim dismantled: Griffin details how SLED's lab twice found no human blood on Murdoch's shirt via hematrace testing, yet Owen later presented an outside expert's opinion of high-velocity spatter with DNA matches to the grand jury without disclosing the negative lab results.
13:00 — Gun loading testimony and admitted trickery: Griffin shows Owen told the grand jury multiple guns at Moselle were loaded with the same buckshot/turkey load as the murder weapon; at trial, evidence showed no gun matched, and Owen admitted he used this false claim as "trickery" during interrogation.
17:00 — Prosecution response: not false, ample evidence: Creighton Waters argues the blood spatter opinion by expert Tom Bevel still stands, the mixed loads were "a ball in play," and even without the two statements, the grand jury heard overwhelming probable cause including the kennel video, timeline, GSR, casing matches, and Murdoch's lies.
24:00 — Judge's forensic questions and timeline: Judge McCaslin probes the forensic sequence: the shirt was sprayed with LCV/luminol, which can react with non-blood substances and destroys confirmatory testing, yet Owen presented the spatter claim without disclosing the negative hematrace result. She will rule by next Friday and asked if re-presentation by December 10 is feasible.
Speakers
Anette Levy — Host
Jim Griffin — Defense Attorney
Creighton Waters — Prosecutor
Deborah McCaslin — Judge