Prime Crime: Young Dad Executed After Meeting 18-Year-Old on Dating App

Original Media · 45m · English · YouTube · Law&Crime Network

TLDR

Adam Hilaire, 27, was murdered execution-style in his Florida home after a Plenty of Fish date. Haley Bustos, pressured by an acquaintance, lured him to scope his apartment for a robbery. Andre Warner and others entered, stole belongings, and Warner shot Adam in the back of the head while he begged for his life for his daughter. All four were charged with first-degree murder under felony murder rule; Warner was convicted but the judge overrode the jury's death penalty recommendation, sentencing him to life. Adam's family attended every proceeding; his mother forgave the killers. The case highlights dating app dangers.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The judge overrode the jury's unanimous death penalty recommendation and sentenced Andre Warner to life in prison instead.

•

The robbers damaged the stolen televisions while loading them into the car and had to throw them away, so no one profited from the TVs.

•

Josh Ellington, the getaway driver, received nothing from the robbery despite participating in the planning and execution.

•

Adam's mother forgave the killers, stating that her son would have forgiven them too, despite the execution-style murder of her son.

Key takeaways

•

Adam Hilaire was lured via Plenty of Fish by 18-year-old Haley Bustos, who was pressured by Evelyn Beaumont to use dating apps to scope out men for robbery.

•

A group including Andre Warner, Gary Gray, Josh Ellington, and Haley Bustos planned the robbery; Warner and Gray entered Adam's apartment while Haley and Josh waited in the car.

•

Andre Warner executed Adam with a single gunshot to the back of the head while Adam was on his knees begging for his life, because Warner didn't cover his face and Adam could identify him.

•

All four participants were charged with first-degree murder under Florida's felony murder rule, which holds accomplices liable for a death during a felony even if they didn't pull the trigger.

•

Haley Bustos confessed and testified; her account was corroborated by Adam's DNA on hats found in Warner's car, cell tower data placing all suspects at the scene, and recovery of stolen items including a 'Daddy's Little Girl' necklace.

•

The jury unanimously recommended the death penalty for Andre Warner, but the judge overrode it and sentenced him to life in prison, citing mitigating circumstances.

•

Adam's mother attended every court proceeding and ultimately forgave the killers, saying her son would have done the same; his daughter, who was five at the time, grew up without her father.

•

The case illustrates the risks of meeting strangers from dating apps; investigators and family advise meeting in public, not revealing your address, and telling someone your plans.

Notable quotes

“When you shoot and murder somebody execution style, you have a depraved heart.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:33

“You're either A, a cold-hearted killer, or you're wrapped up in something that's a lot bigger than you.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:41

“They were laughing about that it was funny and it was making mad cuz he was begging for his life.”

▸ Notable quotes · 22:54

“I really don't care if I spend the rest of my life in prison, as long as he's behind bars, too.”

▸ Notable quotes · 33:23

“You cannot have a murder in hell with angels as your witnesses.”

▸ Notable quotes · 36:23

“Boobie's a hero.”

▸ Notable quotes · 44:37

Chapters

•

0:00 — Discovery of the body: Adam's friend John Hun finds the front door open, TV and Xbox missing, and Adam dead on the kitchen floor with blood everywhere; he calls 911.

•

2:19 — Family notification and grief: Adam's family learns of his murder; his mother receives over 100 calls at work and rushes to the scene, hoping it's a prank. The family waits hours before telling her.

•

3:18 — Crime scene and autopsy details: Adam was found face down with a single gunshot wound to the back of the head, downward trajectory indicating execution style. No forced entry; items stolen include TV, Xbox, hat collection, cash, and a 'Daddy's Little Girl' necklace.

•

9:57 — Investigation begins: dating app connection: Detectives learn Adam used Plenty of Fish; friends saw him with a young Hispanic female named Haley the night before. Chris Rogers confirms Adam wore the same clothes when found.

•

11:00 — Finding Haley Bustos: Winter Haven PD tips off Auburndale detectives about Haley Bustos fleeing in a white Kia; her cousin says she's driving the dead boy's car. Detectives locate her at the drop-off area.

•

12:31 — Andre Warner arrested with stolen property: Police stop the white Kia driven by Andre Warner; hats matching Adam's collection are visible in the car. Warner claims he lent the car to Haley and knew nothing.

•

19:51 — Haley's confession: After initial minimization, Haley confesses: Evelyn Beaumont pressured her to use Plenty of Fish to scope victims; she met Adam, reported he had cash and an Xbox; Warner, Gray, and Ellington went to rob him.

•

21:25 — Details of the robbery and murder: Haley describes Warner and Gray entering, Adam opening the door, Gray returning to move the car, then hearing Adam beg 'no, no, please' before Warner shot him. They stole TVs, Xbox, hats, jewelry; TVs damaged and discarded.

Speakers

•

Narrator — Narrator

•

John Hun — Friend of victim

•

Adam's mother — Victim's mother

•

Adam's brother — Victim's brother

•

Detective — Investigator

•

Haley Bustos — Co-defendant / witness

•

Andre Warner — Defendant / shooter

•

Prosecutor — Prosecutor

•

Defense attorney — Defense attorney

•

Judge — Judge

⋮