Burden of Proof: November 12, 2026

Original Media · 22m · English · YouTube · ABC News

TLDR

The episode covers three criminal cases: a father charged with attempted murder for burying his 11-month-old son alive in a dog crate (the baby survived); a Russian couple who free-climbed the Empire State Building facing felony burglary charges and possible deportation after plea talks stalled; and a 61-year-old driver in North Hollywood who killed three pedestrians while allegedly DUI, with bail set at $6 million and potential second-degree murder charges. Defense attorneys Brian Buckmire and Bernardo Valona debate prosecution strategies, mental health defenses, recklessness standards for professional climbers, and whether the justice system can rehabilitate offenders.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

A towel creating an air pocket in the crate does not help the defense unless the defendant had specialized knowledge of how to engineer a survivable air pocket for 24 hours.

•

Professional climbers can argue their expertise negates recklessness, potentially reducing felony charges to disorderly conduct, because recklessness is judged against the actor's skill level.

•

The Empire State Building climbers had transmission equipment turned off to facilitate their rescue, disrupting city infrastructure beyond just the emergency response.

•

A $6 million bail for a non-intentional DUI homicide is exceptionally high and rarely seen, reflecting the three fatalities and the driver's apparent resources.

Key takeaways

•

Prosecutors charged the father with attempted murder rather than child abuse by using the circumstances — the baby's age, confinement in a crate, and burial under dirt — to show the father came dangerously close to causing death, and would have faced murder charges had the baby died.

•

The defense attorneys agreed a mental health defense (schizophrenia, bipolar, depression) would be difficult because the planning involved — kidnapping the child, burying him, and not cooperating with police — doesn't align with typical symptoms of those disorders.

•

For the Empire State Building climbers, the felony burglary charge doesn't require theft; prosecutors can argue the intent to commit reckless endangerment or property damage inside the building satisfies the 'intent to commit a crime therein' element.

•

Brian Buckmire argued the climbers' professional expertise makes their actions not reckless, comparing it to a college soccer player juggling a ball indoors safely, while Bernardo Valona countered that endangering first responders who must rescue them constitutes recklessness regardless of skill.

•

Valona said he would not offer a plea deal below the top felony count for the climbers because prior lenient outcomes in other cities didn't deter them, and only jail time might stop repeat stunts; Buckmire argued jail doesn't deter recidivism and better building security is the real solution.

•

In the DUI crash killing three, the $6 million bail signals the case's severity; Valona noted such high bail for non-intentional homicide is rare and reflects the three deaths and alcohol involvement, while Buckmire said the only realistic defense win would be concurrent rather than consecutive sentences.

•

Both attorneys acknowledged the criminal justice system struggles with rehabilitation in extreme cases: Buckmire said it 'falls short' of turning someone who buried his infant into a functioning father, while Valona said incarceration serves deterrence and accountability when probation already failed.

Notable quotes

“The problem that I have with that and generally knowing those symptoms, how do you connect those to putting your child in a crate, burying them, and not say anything? That's not what you typically see from bipolar. It's not what you typically see from schizophrenia.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:20

“When when my wife is is watching my son and I kick a soccer ball in the living room and she says, 'This is reckless. Don't do that. My son kicking a soccer ball is reckless. He's going to break the TV.' But right now, as a as a college soccer player, I could juggle a soccer ball right here and not break anything. I have the skills and the ability to do it in a safe way. It does not make it reckless anymore again.”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:25

“My bias as a public defender is always going to shine in things like this. And I think that the the criminal justice system is horrible with cases like this. ... At some point in time, we bring this man to a place where he can be a father. But that might be difficult. How do we do that? How do we take a man who buried his child when the child wasn't even a year old and potentially seeing this child when they graduate from college and be a functioning member of society and be the father that this child deserves? The criminal justice system, unfortunately, doesn't do a good job of that.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:19

“If I were the prosecutor, I'm not making a non-jail offer on this case. No.”

▸ Notable quotes · 18:15

“This one I wouldn't make an offer on this case.”

▸ Notable quotes · 21:52

Chapters

•

0:03 — Intro and case overview: Host Byron Pittz introduces the episode and two criminal defense attorneys, Brian Buckmire and Bernardo Valona, previewing three cases: a father who buried his infant alive, Empire State Building climbers, and a fatal DUI crash.

•

1:03 — Father buries 11-month-old alive: Reporter Alex Perez details the case of Michael Comr, who kidnapped his 11-month-old son Koa, buried him in a dog crate, and was found 24 hours later alive; Comr faces attempted murder and other charges, bond denied.

•

3:19 — Legal analysis: attempted murder vs. child abuse: Valona explains how prosecutors prove attempted murder using circumstances — the baby's age, crate confinement, burial — showing the father came close to causing death; Buckmire says a mental health defense is unlikely to succeed given the planning involved.

•

11:22 — Empire State Building climbers plea dispute: Russian couple who free-climbed the Empire State Building face felony burglary and reckless endangerment charges; DA allegedly extended then rescinded a misdemeanor plea deal; if no deal, they risk felony convictions and deportation.

•

14:00 — Debate: recklessness and professional climbers: Buckmire argues the climbers' expertise negates recklessness, comparing it to a skilled soccer player juggling indoors; Valona counters that endangering first responders constitutes recklessness regardless of skill, and prior leniency didn't deter them.

•

18:42 — Fatal DUI crash in North Hollywood: A 61-year-old driver killed three women and injured two at a metro station; facing DUI charges with $6 million bail; prosecutors may pursue second-degree murder (depraved heart) with potential consecutive sentences for each death.

•

20:50 — Defense strategy and system limitations: Buckmire says the DUI case has little defense wiggle room; best outcome is concurrent sentencing; both attorneys reflect on justice system's failure to rehabilitate extreme offenders, with Buckmire calling it a 'church question, not a court question.'

Speakers

•

Byron Pittz — Host

•

Brian Buckmire — Criminal defense attorney

•

Bernardo Valona — Criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor

•

Alex Perez — Reporter

⋮