WATCH LIVE: White House’s Scharf joins Federalist Society chat after sending warning to Democrats

Original Media · 31m · English · YouTube · PBS NewsHour

TLDR

White House Staff Secretary Will Scharf discusses how founding-era history informs his daily work, sharing vivid stories that humanize figures like Washington, Gouverneur Morris, and Aaron Burr. He emphasizes that historical actors never knew how their stories would end, draws parallels to modern decision-making under uncertainty, and advocates for young lawyers to pursue impactful careers in states like Missouri rather than defaulting to coastal elite paths. He identifies Seila Law v. CFPB as the Supreme Court case that most meaningfully corrected a constitutional error by restoring presidential control over executive power. The conversation blends personal mentorship history, historical anecdotes, and constitutional theory.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Aaron Burr, not Jefferson or Madison, was the architect of the first modern American political machine that seeded Jacksonian democracy.

•

Gouverneur Morris, the Constitution's penman, was so known for womanizing that he let a false story circulate that he lost his leg jumping from a lover's window rather than admit it was a carriage accident.

•

Luther Martin, an Anti-Federalist on the 'wrong side of everything,' was considered one of the early republic's greatest advocates and defended both Aaron Burr and Samuel Chase in landmark trials.

•

The auto-pen controversy led White House lawyers to an 1819 William Wirt opinion about mechanical signature reproduction by the Treasury Secretary, showing how founding-era administrative questions persist unchanged.

Key takeaways

•

Founding-era history is not abstract decoration but a practical tool for White House lawyers; Scharf's team researched OLC opinions by Scalia and Rehnquist and an 1819 William Wirt attorney general opinion to resolve the auto-pen signature issue.

•

The founders were flawed, petty, and uncertain — Washington speculated in western lands after his presidency, Gouverneur Morris was a notorious womanizer who joked about his peg leg, and Luther Martin gave an eight-hour speech Madison dismissed in a paragraph — yet their human messiness makes their achievements more instructive.

•

Historical outcomes were never inevitable; Washington's Delaware crossing and Morgan's Cowpens tactic were desperate gambles that could have failed, a reality Scharf carries into daily White House decisions made with imperfect information.

•

Aaron Burr, often caricatured as a villain, was a war hero who secured Jefferson's election, built the first great American political machine that later produced Van Buren and Jacksonian democracy, and presided over the Chase impeachment trial in a way that protected judicial independence.

•

Scharf urges law students to reject the default elite-law-firm track and instead serve in state government or smaller communities; he credits Ted Cruz's advice to 'get the heck off the coast' and his own Missouri clerkship for revealing a richer civic life rooted in local attachment.

•

Federalism's beauty lies in distinct state and local cultures that the founders themselves valued; Scharf notes the 'Missouri Mafia' in the current administration as evidence that state-level networks still shape national governance.

•

Seila Law v. CFPB (referred to as 'slaughter' in the transcript) is the case Scharf is proudest of because it corrected Morrison v. Olson and restored the Article II vesting clause's promise of a president who can control those exercising executive power.

Notable quotes

“In my youth, I once heard a speech by Alger Hiss, you know, the famous communist spy and State Department official. Alger Hiss served as a law clerk to Oliver Wendell Holmes. Oliver Wendell Holmes famously served alongside President Abraham Lincoln during the Civil War. I believe he was at the Battle of Fort Stewart. And a very young Abraham Lincoln, in his only term in the House of Representatives, served alongside John Quincy Adams, who was in his last term in the U.S. House of Representatives shortly before his death. And Quincy was an eyewitness to the founding of our country and was an eyewitness to every one of the subjects of the biographies that I've written. And he sort of holds up his hands and he goes, you know, me, Alger Hiss, Oliver Wendell Holmes, Abraham Lincoln, John Quincy Adams. That's less than six degrees of separation between us and the generation that founded this country.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:27

“We must all assuredly hang together, or we will hang separately.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:38

“Washington crossing the Delaware, by all conventional metrics, by the way that they thought about, you know, operational arts at that time, was utter madness.”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:09

“History is written by elites. And typically throughout American history, the same is the case in other countries as well, really going back to classical antiquity, populist movements tend to get written out of conventional histories.”

▸ Notable quotes · 13:27

“The vesting clause of Article II, in my view, is pretty clear. And the president who, you know, can't control who's exercising the executive power that is vested in him, that's a cabined presidency.”

▸ Notable quotes · 28:24

“It's very easy to take sort of the well-trod course from elite law school to big law firm. You know, you go to the big cities because that's where the, you know, oftentimes, frankly, the best legal work is. But I'd encourage you to look elsewhere.”

▸ Notable quotes · 24:31

Chapters

•

0:26 — Origins and mentorship: Scharf recounts how O.H. Skinner recruited him to the Federalist Society as a 1L at Harvard Law School and insisted he attend the national convention, a decision that shaped his career.

•

2:48 — Founding history in daily White House work: Scharf explains how the physical and documentary history of the White House — OLC opinions by Scalia and Rehnquist, an 1819 Wirt opinion — directly informed the auto-pen signature memo he wrote as Staff Secretary.

•

7:54 — Humanizing the founders: Through stories about Washington's land speculation, Gouverneur Morris's womanizing, and Luther Martin's pettiness, Scharf argues the founders were brilliant but deeply human, making their political fights relatable to today's.

•

13:10 — Aaron Burr and populism: Scharf rehabilitates Burr as a war hero, Jefferson's electoral kingmaker, defender of judicial independence at the Chase impeachment trial, and architect of the populist machine that later produced Van Buren and Jacksonian democracy.

•

17:12 — Decision-making under uncertainty: Washington's Delaware crossing and Daniel Morgan's Cowpens feigned retreat are presented as desperate gambles that could have failed; Scharf connects this to his own experience making high-stakes White House decisions with imperfect information.

•

21:58 — Missouri and the case for state-level careers: Scharf describes how a clerkship in St. Louis converted him to Midwestern life, credits Ted Cruz's advice to 'get off the coast,' and urges young lawyers to build careers in state government and smaller communities where civic bonds are stronger.

•

27:41 — Seila Law as generational win: Scharf identifies Seila Law v. CFPB as the Supreme Court case that most corrected a constitutional error by overturning Morrison v. Olson and restoring presidential removal power under the Article II vesting clause.

Speakers

•

O.H. Skinner — Moderator

•

Will Scharf — White House Staff Secretary

⋮