Hasan Defends China's War Against Gay People ft. Girl With a Microphone

Original Media · 47m · English · YouTube · H3 Podcast

TLDR

Queer writer Kate critiques streamer Hassan Piker's coverage of LGBTQ life in China during his state-sponsored tour. Hassan dismissed reports of a government crackdown, claiming "China's gay as hell" based on superficial observations. Kate presents evidence that since 2020, China has systematically removed gay dating apps, shut down LGBTQ organizations, banned "effeminate men" from TV, arrested queer fiction writers, and denied marriage equality and parental rights — while Hassan repeated false narratives about Grindr's ownership and refused to correct himself when confronted by a long-term resident. Kate recommends supporting True Self (China's PFLAG equivalent) and watching the documentary "The Last Year of Darkness."

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Homosexuality was decriminalized in China in the 1990s, but repression has intensified since 2020 under a government-led "traditional values" campaign.

•

Grindr was owned by a Chinese company for years before being banned — the ban came from China, not U.S. interference as Hassan claimed.

•

The Chinese government uses "tea meetings" (informal police pressure) to shut down Pride events rather than overt violence, making repression less visible to tourists.

•

Unmarried women in China (including lesbian mothers) are denied birth permits and prenatal care, showing anti-LGBTQ policies harm broader populations.

•

Hassan sang Mao's propaganda songs on stream during a government-supervised tour where officials monitored his broadcasts and detained him for showing Mao's image on his phone.

Key takeaways

•

Hassan Piker dismissed verified reports of China's LGBTQ crackdown during his state-sponsored tour, claiming "China's gay as hell" based on superficial observations while ignoring systemic rights violations.

•

Since 2020-2021, China has systematically removed gay dating apps (Blue, Finka, Grindr), shut down LGBTQ organizations (Beijing LGBT Center, Shanghai Pride), and banned "effeminate men" from TV under a government-led "morality clampdown."

•

Hassan falsely claimed the U.S. blocked Grindr's sale to a Chinese company to protect closeted politicians; in reality, a Chinese firm already owned Grindr, the U.S. forced its sale over data concerns, and China banned it in 2022 ahead of the Beijing Olympics.

•

LGBTQ people in China lack federal protections, marriage equality, and face barriers to inheritance, medical decision-making, IVF, prenatal care, and child registration — consequences Hassan ignored.

•

Chinese authorities arrested 50+ writers of queer erotic fiction in one province this year, demonstrating censorship extending beyond public activism into creative expression.

•

Hassan refused to correct his misinformation when confronted by a viewer who lived in China for seven years, instead doubling down and straw-manning critics as claiming "no gay people exist in China."

•

Kate recommends supporting True Self (Chinese PFLAG equivalent) and watching "The Last Year of Darkness" documentary to understand queer life in China, rather than relying on state-curated tours.

Notable quotes

“Why the fuck you lying? Hassan”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:47

“His his Hassan's knee-jerk reaction is to lie about shit he doesn't know about. Um, which he calls doing journalism.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:31

“The headline that he just read says to comply with government order.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:28

“I hope those heterosexual policy makers can understand that love is rare. It's not something shameful or unspeakable.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:08

“Grinder was supposed to be sold to a Chinese company, I'm pretty sure... And the American government literally blocked that deal from happening because they were like, 'No, too many of our dudes are are sucking penises on there.'”

▸ Notable quotes · 18:50

“50 arrests were made just this year in a single Chinese province of authors of writers of of Chinese queer um like erotic fiction.”

▸ Notable quotes · 40:39

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction & Kate's motivation: Kate, a queer writer and activist, explains she was motivated to research China's LGBTQ situation after Hassan Piker's tour dismissed crackdown reports and used queer Chinese people as props for his narrative.

•

2:30 — First clip: Hassan denies gay app removals: Hassan confidently denies China blocked gay dating apps, dismisses Twitter sources while reading Twitter, claims Apple acted independently, and says "just watch the stream" as proof China is gay-friendly.

•

8:00 — Fact-check: App removals & Grindr: Kate details how Blue and Finka were removed from Apple's Chinese store by government order, Grindr was banned from all stores in 2022, and 200 million Chinese iPhone users lost access — contradicting Hassan's claims.

•

15:00 — Hassan's Grindr ownership lie: Hassan falsely claims the U.S. blocked Grindr's sale to a Chinese company to protect closeted politicians; Kate explains a Chinese firm already owned Grindr, the U.S. forced divestment over data concerns, and China banned it in 2022.

•

22:00 — Second clip: Hassan vs. long-term resident: Hassan argues with a viewer who lived in China for seven years, straw-mans their critique as claiming "no homosexuality allowed," and doubles down that his tourist experience outweighs lived reality.

•

30:00 — Chengdu as "gay city" & crackdown details: Hassan treats Chengdu as a fun gay destination; Kate explains it's the final holdout against crackdowns, with clubs closing and the documentary "The Last Year of Darkness" documenting queer struggles there.

•

38:00 — Legal & social consequences for LGBTQ people: Kate outlines systemic barriers: no marriage equality, no inheritance or medical rights, lesbian mothers denied birth permits and prenatal care, children blocked from healthcare and school registration.

•

42:00 — Censorship of queer media & activism: Details on banned "effeminate men" on TV, 50+ arrests of queer fiction writers in one province, shutdown of Beijing LGBT Center, LGBT Rights Advocacy China, and Shanghai Pride since 2020.

Speakers

•

Ethan — Host

•

Zach — Co-host

•

Kate — Guest

•

Dan — Crew

•

Hassan Piker — Subject of critique

⋮