Does Anybody REALLY Know How The College Football Playoff Selection Process Works?!

Original Media · 17m · English · YouTube · The Pat McAfee Show

TLDR

ESPN analysts preview the first College Football Playoff rankings reveal of the season, debating how the committee will weigh Ohio State's shaky win without Julian Sayin, BYU's head-to-head win over Notre Dame versus its loss to UCF, the impact of the SEC's nine-game schedule on two- and three-loss teams, and the treatment of undefeated teams with weak schedules (Utah, UCLA, Miami). They also discuss Group of Five contenders, committee composition, and Notre Dame's must-win game against Miami. The episode highlights the unpredictability of the initial rankings and the criteria that will shape the 12-team playoff field.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Rece Davis reveals he has never seen the CFP rankings before they air in the show's history; this year he will get an early peek for production purposes.

•

Purdue dropped Notre Dame from its future schedule to play West Virginia, a scheduling move that surprised the analysts.

•

Utah's athletic director Mark Harlan sits on the selection committee but will recuse himself when Utah is discussed.

•

Only two three-loss teams have ever made the College Football Playoff (Alabama and Clemson in 2023), yet analysts believe a three-loss SEC team could make it this year without even playing in the conference championship game.

•

The first round of the 12-team playoff was largely blowouts, and the byes for conference champions did not prove advantageous.

Key takeaways

•

The first CFP rankings reveal is considered the most difficult and unpredictable of the season because the committee has limited data and many teams with similar records.

•

Ohio State's ranking will signal how much margin for error the Buckeyes have after a sloppy 11-penalty, 30-points-allowed win over USC without starting quarterback Julian Sayin.

•

The committee's handling of BYU (win over Notre Dame, loss to UCF) versus Notre Dame (loss to BYU, strong resume otherwise) will reveal how much weight they give to head-to-head results versus overall body of work.

•

The SEC's move to nine conference games increases the likelihood of multiple two- and three-loss SEC teams making the playoff, a scenario that could squeeze out teams like two-loss Notre Dame.

•

Undefeated teams with poor strength of schedule (Utah 83rd, UCLA 79th, Miami 44th) test whether the committee prioritizes win-loss record or schedule strength.

•

Notre Dame's playoff hopes likely hinge on beating Miami this weekend; a loss could eliminate them in favor of two-loss SEC teams with better wins.

•

Group of Five representation is contentious: Boise State is generally accepted, but UTSA's inclusion is debated, and most expect only one G5 team in the top 12.

•

The 13-member committee includes four former Division I head coaches and two former college/NFL players, meaning nearly half have deep on-field evaluation experience.

Notable quotes

“For the entire history of the college football playoff, I've never seen the rankings one time before they go to air.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:00

“I think the SEC will wind up having the most teams in the playoff tonight and ultimately.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:47

“There's only been two three loss teams in the college football playoff. Last year, Alabama got in as SEC runner-up. Clemson got in with three losses by winning the ACC. This year, I think there's a better chance than ever to see a three loss SEC team in the college football playoff that doesn't play in the conference championship game.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:14

“What I'm looking for is where's Ohio State? Let's start there because this is one game of information that the selection committee had to watch the Buckeyes without Julian Sayin in the lineup.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:19

“Tonight can't tell us a lot. I think the thing we'll be looking for is how do they judge wins and how they judge losses.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:37

“I don't want to see UTSA in the in the playoff.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:59

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction and Committee Overview: Hosts introduce the CFP rankings reveal show, list the 13 committee members (including ADs, former coaches, and former players), and note the committee has begun deliberations.

•

1:53 — Ranking Reveal Process and Timing: Rece Davis explains he has never seen the rankings before air; this year he'll get an early look to help production. The timing of when rankings arrive varies, but week one may be earlier.

•

4:01 — Key Storylines: Ohio State, BYU/Notre Dame, Undefeated Teams: Analysts preview the biggest questions: Ohio State's ranking after a flawed win without Julian Sayin; whether BYU's head-to-head win over Notre Dame outweighs its loss to UCF; and how the committee will rank undefeated Utah, UCLA, and Miami given their weak schedules.

•

7:27 — SEC vs. Big Ten and Conference Representation: Heather argues the SEC will have the most teams due to its nine-game schedule creating more two/three-loss teams with strong resumes. Big Ten may only get two or three teams. Debate over ACC, Big 12, and Group of Five spots ensues.

•

11:00 — Group of Five and Notre Dame's Path: Analysts argue over UTSA's worthiness, predict only one G5 team (likely Boise State) makes the top 12, and discuss Notre Dame's must-win game against Miami, noting weather could favor the Irish.

Speakers

•

Pat — Host

•

Rece Davis — ESPN Host/Analyst

•

Heather — Analyst

•

Tone — Analyst

•

AJ — Analyst

•

Gumpy — Producer/Off-camera

⋮