TLDR
Keith Edwards and his co-host discuss the backlash against Jennifer Welch's 'I've Had It' podcast after she and her co-host laughed at a joke about Charlie Kirk's death. Right-wing figures including Erica Kirk and Turning Point USA launched a cancellation campaign, pressuring sponsors to drop the show, but the hosts argue this is hypocritical given Charlie Kirk's own history of offensive jokes about Palestinians, George Floyd, and others. The controversy has backfired, with 'I've Had It' gaining millions of followers while Turning Point's electoral influence collapses. The hosts refuse to apologize, arguing that public apologies are weaponized by the right to destroy careers, not to seek accountability. They frame the moment as evidence of the right's declining cultural power. The episode includes clips of Charlie Kirk's past rhetoric, Dave Chappelle's comedy bit on Kirk's death, and Turning Point's poor youth election results. The hosts vow to continue their 'MAGA bashing' content without backing down. They promote Jennifer Welch's book 'Not Today Fascist' and their own platforms. The core argument: laughing at an edgy joke is not political violence, and the right's outrage is performative hypocrisy from figures who routinely celebrate their enemies' deaths.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Charlie Kirk joked 'Now they don't have any tall buildings left' about Gaza after Israel's destruction, implying Palestinians deserved it — a clip the hosts replay to show his own 'edgy' humor.
Dave Chappelle's bit on Charlie Kirk's death ('I feel better') was met with right-wing outrage, despite them previously championing Chappelle's anti-trans comedy.
Riley Gaines and Charlie Kirk discussed 'taking care of things the way we used to in the 1950s or 60s' regarding trans athletes — a coded lynching reference the hosts highlight.
Turning Point's own election data shows total failure with voters under 30, undermining their claim to represent youth culture.
The hosts argue that public apologies are now purely tactical weapons: 'The right doesn't want you to apologize. The right wants you to go away.'
Jennifer Welch's podcast gained millions of followers *because* of the cancellation attempt, not despite it — a clear Streisand effect.
Key takeaways
Jennifer Welch and her 'I've Had It' co-host faced a right-wing cancellation campaign after laughing at a joke tweet about Charlie Kirk's death, resulting in 23 companies reportedly cutting ties.
The hosts expose hypocrisy: Erica Kirk condemned 'celebrating political violence' while her husband Charlie Kirk made jokes about throwing gay people off buildings in Gaza, mocked George Floyd's death, and Donald Trump celebrated Robert Mueller's death.
Dave Chappelle performed a comedy bit expressing relief at Charlie Kirk's death, which the right also attacked — despite embracing Chappelle when he mocked trans people.
Turning Point USA's electoral influence is collapsing: their under-30 voter map shows a 'total wipeout' (all blue), suggesting their cultural power is waning.
The 'I've Had It' podcast has gained millions of followers since the controversy began, demonstrating the Streisand effect of right-wing cancellation attempts.
The hosts refuse to apologize publicly, arguing that internet apologies are not sought in good faith but as admissions of guilt to justify further destruction.
Keith Edwards met Jennifer Welch at Crooked Con and plans a collaboration; he praises her defiance and resilience under pressure.
The episode frames the controversy as a turning point: the right 'choking at the bottom of the pool' while progressive media grows stronger.
Notable quotes
“All they did was laugh. That's it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:58“They lost like I think they've lost like 12 sponsors from this. By the way, I I wish we had one thing about us. You can't cancel us. We don't have 12 sponsors to lose at the moment.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:05“Political violence must never be something this country tolerates, excuses, or celebrates.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:14“Robert Mueller just died. Good. I'm glad he's dead.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:50“Now they don't have any tall buildings left. So I don't”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:08“I feel better.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:29“We are not going anywhere.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:23“The right doesn't want you to apologize. The right wants you to go away. The right wants you to apologize to show that they have power over you and that they want to use that power to try to crush you.”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:46“Apologies are pointless on the internet. I don't do it at all.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:40Chapters
0:00 — The controversy: laughing at a joke about Charlie Kirk: Keith Edwards introduces the backlash against Jennifer Welch's 'I've Had It' podcast after she and her co-host laughed at a joke tweet about Charlie Kirk's death. He notes the right's cancellation attempt is backfiring, similar to their failed campaign against Hasan Piker.
1:50 — Reading the 'offensive' tweets they laughed at: The hosts read the actual tweets that sparked outrage: absurd jokes about invented pronouns, newborn septum piercings, Chick-fil-A opening Sundays, and digging up Charlie Kirk. They emphasize the tweets were clearly satirical and the hosts only laughed.
3:00 — Erica Kirk's statement and right-wing hypocrisy: Erica Kirk condemned 'laughing about political assassination' while invoking her husband's death. The hosts counter with examples of right-wing figures celebrating deaths: Trump on Robert Mueller, Laura Loomer on Rob Reiner, and Charlie Kirk's own jokes about Palestinians and George Floyd.
5:00 — Charlie Kirk's own rhetoric: Gaza, Muslims, and 'the 1950s': Clips show Charlie Kirk joking that Gaza has 'no tall buildings left' to throw gay people off, saying 'maybe you shouldn't kill Jews, stupid Muslims,' and Riley Gaines/Kirk referencing 'taking care of things the way we used to in the 1950s or 60s' — a lynching dog whistle.
6:20 — Dave Chappelle's bit and the right's selective outrage: Dave Chappelle joked about feeling better after Charlie Kirk's death. The right attacked him despite previously embracing his anti-trans comedy. Benny Johnson called it 'the most sickening thing you can say about a Christian assassinated for his beliefs.'
8:00 — 'I've Had It' responds: defiance and growth: Jennifer Welch and her co-host refuse to back down: 'We are not going anywhere.' They've gained millions of followers since the controversy. Keith Edwards urges viewers to subscribe and support them, noting their book 'Not Today Fascist'.
10:00 — Turning Point's electoral collapse: The hosts show Turning Point's under-30 election map: a 'total wipeout' (all blue). They argue the cancellation campaign stems from declining political power: 'They are just choking at the bottom of the pool trying to swim up.'
11:00 — Why they won't apologize: apologies as weapons: Keith Edwards articulates a core philosophy: public apologies are not sought in good faith but as admissions of guilt to justify destruction. 'The right doesn't want you to apologize. The right wants you to go away.' He vows never to offer public apologies for internet outrage.
Speakers
Keith Edwards — Host
Co-host — Co-host/Producer