TLDR
Ezra Klein interviews departing New York Times columnist Ross Douthat about his career from early blogging to opinion journalism, the evolution of media and political discourse, the rise of the post-religious right, shifting religious influences on both right and left, and Douthat's move to 60 Minutes to pursue investigative interviewing in an era of deep uncertainty.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The early blogosphere was more respectful and intellectually rigorous than today's social media because bloggers engaged directly with opponents' arguments via blockquotes and expected a response.
Trump fulfilled the populist realignment Douthat predicted but stripped it of the policy seriousness that motivated the original argument, creating a coalition of Catholic traditionalists and pot-smoking libertarians united only by anti-woke backlash.
The 'theocracy panic' of 2005 feared an evangelical takeover; the post-religious right that followed is less Christian and in some ways more bigoted, with figures like Andrew Tate explicitly rejecting Christianity.
Jordan Peterson is a 'post-Christian' figure wrestling with Christian texts without commitment, while Andrew Tate represents a formally anti-Christian right-wing politics of strength and dominance.
The left's 'great awakening' (anti-racism) functioned as a religious revival without metaphysical hope, leading to a politics of guilt without redemption that has left a spiritual void.
Douthat finds interviewing harder than writing but essential for navigating a world where the boundaries of reality seem less certain, and he sees UFOs/UAPs as a concrete journalistic puzzle with potential answers.
Key takeaways
Early blogging fostered a conversational, good-faith debate culture (blockquoting, line-by-line responses) that has been replaced by performative dunking on algorithmic social media.
Douthat's 'Grand New Party' vision of a working-class GOP was realized by Trump but in a more fiscally unsustainable and culturally combative form, lacking the policy seriousness (family policy, wage subsidies) that motivated the original argument.
The 'post-religious right' encompasses both amoral libertinism (Andrew Tate) and a search for pagan vitality (Jordan Peterson), distinct from traditional Christian conservatism and often more bigoted.
Catholicism has become the dominant intellectual framework for the elite right, while evangelicalism remains stronger at the mass level, creating a split between elite and popular religious expression.
The post-Christian left is experiencing a spiritual vacuum, leading to renewed interest in religious language (e.g., James Talarico, Pope Leo's encyclical) as a source of moral grounding after a 'great awakening' that offered guilt without redemption.
Media has shifted from a 'view from nowhere' to acknowledged partisan brands, but trust crises and AI demand a return to descriptive, uncertainty-embracing journalism rather than persuasion.
Douthat's move to 60 Minutes reflects a desire to do more open-ended interviewing to capture a messy, opaque reality where he feels less certain about 'who the good guys and bad guys are.'
The rise of video and audio formats reflects an AI-driven premium on live human performance and conversational forms that tolerate ambiguity better than authoritative columns.
Notable quotes
“I think of myself as someone who was sort of present for both the end of an old dispensation and the beginning of a new one.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:46“Early blogging was all about this kind of ongoing rolling debate where you'd write 4,000 words and someone else would come along and block quote... you were putting the other side's words on your site. Like even if you were doing it just to show what a total idiot they were, you were still sort of like all right here's 200 words I'm quoting and I'm going to go line by line and I'm going to respond to every single line.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:05“Instead of talking to the people you're talking about, you talk about them... you quote tweet and dunk on them and then you look for the hearts and the retweets.”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:02“To argue effectively, you need to understand why people you disagree with hold the views that they do. And you need to start from a version of their argument that is high-minded rather than low-minded.”
▸ Notable quotes · 18:19“If you dislike the religious right, wait till you meet the post-religious right.”
▸ Notable quotes · 29:56“As a culture gets less formally Christian, it's not surprising that its leadership would get less formally Christian.”
▸ Notable quotes · 35:47“Journalism needs people and institutions that sort of refocus on just saying, 'We're trying to figure out what's happening here.'”
▸ Notable quotes · 60:51“I'm interested in zones of uncertainty and questions that sort of don't have immediate and obvious answers... As a journalist, I'm only interested in them in so far as you can figure out what the hell is going on.”
▸ Notable quotes · 71:00Chapters
0:00 — Origins: From Atlantic Junior Editor to Blogger: Douthat describes his dual early career at The Atlantic (pre-internet magazine workflow) and as a side-hustle blogger, and how institutions co-opted bloggers after 9/11 created demand for real-time political commentary.
9:00 — The Blogosphere's Conversational Culture: Contrasts early blogging's good-faith, blockquote-driven debates with today's algorithmic dunking; notes the blogosphere was a relational ecosystem where linking and arguing with opponents built audience.
16:00 — Conservative Voice in Liberal Institutions: Douthat reflects on 15 years as a conservative columnist at The Atlantic and NYT, arguing that persuasion requires engaging the best version of opponents' arguments, and that sustained good-faith interaction yields reasonable responses even in polarized times.
23:00 — Grand New Party, Trump, and the Populist Turn: Discusses the 2008 book 'Grand New Party' predicting a working-class GOP realignment; Trump fulfilled the demographic shift but via trade protectionism and entitlement defense rather than family policy, creating a fiscally unsustainable coalition.
29:00 — The Post-Religious Right: From Theocracy Panic to Pagan Energy: Analyzes Douthat's 2016 tweet: the 2005 'theocracy panic' feared evangelical dominance; the post-religious right includes both amoral libertinism (Andrew Tate) and a search for pre-Christian vitality (Jordan Peterson), with a desire for strength over Christian virtue.
46:00 — Catholicism vs. Evangelicalism on the Right: Catholicism's stronger intellectual tradition attracts elite converts, while evangelicalism thrives at the mass level; digital conditions favor 'strong brands' (liturgical Catholicism, seeker-sensitive megachurches) over loose denominational loyalties.
50:00 — The Left's Spiritual Vacuum and Religious Re-engagement: The post-Christian left's 'great awakening' offered moralism without metaphysical hope (guilt without redemption); recent figures like James Talarico and Pope Leo's AI encyclical signal a groping for religious language to ground progressive politics.
60:00 — Media Trust Crisis and the Move to 60 Minutes: Douthat explains leaving NYT Opinion for 60 Minutes: the 'view from nowhere' is dead, partisan brands dominate, but AI and uncertainty demand descriptive journalism that captures messy reality through open-ended interviewing.
65:00 — Video, Orality, and the AI Premium on Liveness: The shift to video/podcasts reflects AI increasing the premium on live human performance; conversational forms tolerate ambiguity and show the person underneath the writing, which audiences crave when reality feels opaque.
69:00 — UFOs, Uncertainty, and Journalistic Puzzles: Douthat defends covering UFOs/UAPs as concrete claims (Navy sightings, secret programs) that journalists can investigate, unlike purely subjective religious experiences; he seeks zones of uncertainty where answers may eventually emerge.
Speakers
Ezra Klein — Host
Ross Douthat — Guest