Cornell 7: Male #1 Says HE Was Assaulted & Cornell Ignored Him ft. Megyn Kelly

Original Media · 1h 10m · English · YouTube · Ashleigh Banfield x Drop Dead Serious

TLDR

Ashley Banfield analyzes new developments in the Cornell University Kai Phi fraternity sexual assault case, where a female student (Jane Doe) alleges gang rape by seven fraternity brothers. Key revelations include: one accused male (Male #1) emailed Cornell in 2025 claiming he was sodomized while incapacitated; Jane Doe's 2024 sworn statement to police described detailed, consensual sexual encounters, contradicting her 2026 lawsuit claims; the DA declined prosecution in 2024; two accused tested negative for ketamine via hair follicle tests; and Cornell has hired former Deputy AG Sally Yates to review its handling. Megyn Kelly joins to discuss evidentiary inconsistencies, Title IX process flaws, and media bias.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

One of the accused men contemporaneously reported being sexually assaulted (sodomized while incapacitated) by Jane Doe, and claims Cornell had evidence but failed to notify him of his rights.

•

Jane Doe's own 2024 statement describes her checking on her passed-out partner, waking him repeatedly, and stopping sexual activity to ensure his safety — behavior inconsistent with her later claim of being too incapacitated to consent.

•

The DA's 9-page declination memo received little media attention; Megyn Kelly suggests this is because it contradicted the preferred narrative.

•

Hair follicle tests for two accused were negative for ketamine within the detection window, directly undermining the allegation that they snorted ketamine off Jane Doe's body.

•

Male #1 has reportedly fled to Dubai (no extradition treaty with US), and Megyn Kelly advises him not to return, calling the process a 'political witch hunt.'

•

Cornell's 100-page Title IX report is so heavily redacted it resembles a 'Rorschach test,' making independent assessment nearly impossible.

Key takeaways

•

Male #1 (Jane Doe's date) sent a contemporaneous email to Cornell in Feb 2025 alleging he was sodomized while incapacitated, claiming the university had evidence but never informed him of his rights as a sexual assault survivor.

•

Jane Doe's 2024 sworn statement to campus police provided a detailed, play-by-play account of consensual sexual activity — including initiating acts, accepting drugs, and managing her intoxicated partner — which the DA determined did not meet New York's statutory definition of rape.

•

Two accused fraternity members submitted hair follicle tests within 6-8 weeks of the incident; both tested negative for ketamine, contradicting allegations that they snorted ketamine off Jane Doe's body.

•

The Cornell Title IX investigation was extensive: 5 months, 12.5-day hearing, 32 witnesses, 100-page report — yet Male #1 claims the university ignored evidence of his assault.

•

Megyn Kelly argues the narrative shifted after Jane Doe was disinvited from a Halloween party, and that her detailed 2024 account is legally damning to her current claims.

•

Student protests have included property damage (smashed windows, graffiti) and a 7-hour sit-in; Banfield urges reviewing primary documents before taking sides.

•

Cornell has appointed former Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates to lead an independent review of its sexual misconduct policies and handling of this case.

•

Jane Doe is also suing Moonies Bar (alleging underage service) and her sorority Tri Delta (for failing to warn about risks of drugs/alcohol/sex).

Notable quotes

“I am not weighing in on this case based on any personal morals or opinions. That is not what this is about. I'm looking at this like a lawyer. And I'm looking at this like a DA, and I'm looking at this like a defense attorney, and I'm looking at this like an Attorney General of New York should.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:36

“You received information that I was sodomized by her while I was incapacitated back in November. And you never once thought to alert me of my rights under these procedures as a survivor of this assault?”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:15

“At the start of the threesome, Jane Doe described her intoxication level as five or six out of 10, and that she was, quote, 'pretty okay with having this threesome.'”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:35

“The evolution from it was consensual to it was rape is mildly interesting. I mean, you want to know how how did that happen? Why why did she change her mind? The answer really is that her roommates were in her ear saying, 'You were raped. You were raped.' And the rest of the campus was saying, 'You're a slut.' And she chose a narrative that I think she preferred.”

▸ Notable quotes · 37:02

“She told them when she was just too too close in time to the the period in which she was still telling the truth. That's my view of it because the the recitation is just so detailed and damning for her that she stuck with it now.”

▸ Notable quotes · 34:44

“If you reverse the roles and that's a woman saying, I was sodomized while under the influence and you never told me that I have rights as a sexual assault survivor, people would be breaking windows everywhere, right?”

▸ Notable quotes · 12:03

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction and Host's Framework: Ashley Banfield opens the episode, emphasizing her 38 years of legal reporting experience and commitment to analyzing the Cornell case based solely on facts, documents, and law — not opinion, morality, or social media narratives. She acknowledges the sensitivity and states she believes survivors, but insists each case must be judged on its own merits.

•

3:00 — Male #1's Contemporaneous Email to Cornell: One of the seven accused (Male #1, Jane Doe's date) emailed Cornell's Title IX office in February 2025 — months after the incident, before any lawsuit — alleging the university had evidence he was sodomized while incapacitated but never informed him of his rights as a sexual assault survivor, suggesting gender discrimination.

•

6:00 — Jane Doe's 2024 Statement vs. 2026 Lawsuit: Jane Doe's sworn 2024 statement to campus police detailed consensual sexual activity: she described her intoxication level, accepted drugs voluntarily, initiated and managed encounters, stopped sex to check on her passed-out partner, and gave a play-by-play of each act. The DA concluded this did not meet New York's legal standard for rape. Her 2026 civil lawsuit claims she was too intoxicated to consent and was gang-raped.

•

19:00 — Physical Evidence and Title IX Findings: Two accused submitted hair follicle tests within 6-8 weeks; both negative for ketamine, contradicting allegations they snorted it off Jane Doe. The Title IX report (101 pages, heavily redacted) includes witness accounts of Jane Doe getting up and flexing muscles during the encounter. One accused stated he went to the alumni room after seeing a 'free pussy' Snapchat message because he was worried for his intoxicated brother.

•

24:00 — Megyn Kelly Interview: Legal Analysis and Media Critique: Megyn Kelly joins to discuss the DA's ignored declination memo, media bias ('man hatred'), Jane Doe's anonymity vs. named defendants, and the legal standard of 'physical helplessness' in New York. She argues Jane Doe's 2024 account shows active decision-making, not physical helplessness, and that Male #1's contemporaneous claim of assault is stronger than hers. Kelly suggests defamation and sexual assault counter-suits are warranted.

•

66:00 — Protests, Institutional Response, and Sally Yates Appointment: Student protests include property damage, a 7-hour sit-in, and demands to end Greek life. Cornell has appointed former Deputy AG Sally Yates to lead an independent review of its sexual misconduct policies and handling of this case. Jane Doe also sues Moonies Bar (underage service) and her sorority Tri Delta (failure to warn). Banfield urges reviewing primary documents before forming opinions, citing the Duke lacrosse case as cautionary.

Speakers

•

Ashley Banfield — Host

•

Megyn Kelly — Guest

•

Aaron Katersky — ABC News Correspondent

•

Campus Police Investigator — Interviewer in ABC video clips

•

Fraternity Witnesses — Interviewees in ABC video clips

⋮