TOP 5 Bingeable SCARY STORIES • Sick Minds Edition Vol. 2

Original Media · 57m · English · YouTube · MrBallen

TLDR

This compilation presents five disturbing true crime cases: a medical student's near-miss with John Wayne Gacy; a widow with schizophrenia murdered by her protégé who smuggled the body out in a suitcase; a neighbor who hid her boyfriend's severed head in a gift box labeled as sex toys; a son-in-law who staged a two-year harassment campaign before murdering his mother-in-law; and a Brazilian cult that murdered women, baked them into empadas, and raised a victim's daughter as an unwitting cannibal.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The medical student who escaped Gacy did not report it to police because the threat felt ambiguous and he lacked a license plate.

•

CCTV footage showed Gemma Mitchell wheeling a suitcase containing Deborah's body, but police initially missed it because the two women walking together looked like a single person.

•

Carmen Merino's signature croquettes served to neighbors may have contained the rest of her boyfriend's body, though this remains an unproven theory.

•

Jeff Pleskovic served as a pallbearer at Melinda's funeral before police found the murder weapon and bloody clothes in his car.

•

Maria, the cult's 'daughter,' was fed her own mother's remains at age one and a half and lived for years as an unwitting cannibal.

Key takeaways

•

A medical student escaped John Wayne Gacy by jumping from a moving car, unknowingly forcing Gacy to remove interior door handles for future victims.

•

Gemma Mitchell murdered her benefactor Deborah Chong after antipsychotic medication clarified Deborah's mind and she withdrew a £200,000 renovation offer, then wheeled the body out in a suitcase past CCTV cameras.

•

Carmen Merino concealed her boyfriend's severed head in a wrapped gift box labeled as sex toys, relying on the recipient's embarrassment to prevent inspection until decomposition revealed the crime.

•

Jeff Pleskovic orchestrated a two-year campaign of fake break-ins and harassment against his own family to build an alibi before stabbing and shooting his mother-in-law Melinda 35 times while his infant daughter and nonverbal brother-in-law were nearby.

•

The Cartel Sect cult in Brazil murdered at least three women deemed 'unclean,' baked their flesh into empadas sold to the public, and raised the first victim's toddler daughter as their own while feeding her pieces of her mother.

Notable quotes

“Oh, no. You're coming with me.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:36

“It would turn out her entire life was one big horrific lie.”

▸ Notable quotes · 53:36

“The literal purpose of the Cartel Sect was to eliminate women they deemed unclean in order to reduce and purify the world's population.”

▸ Notable quotes · 54:30

“They literally were feeding people in the city human meat.”

▸ Notable quotes · 55:17

“She was actually the daughter of the very first victim of the Cartel Sect.”

▸ Notable quotes · 55:31

“After her mother was killed, they cooked her mother and fed pieces of the mother to Maria.”

▸ Notable quotes · 55:47

Chapters

•

1:31 — John Wayne Gacy near-miss: A Chicago medical student hitchhikes and accepts a ride from a friendly middle-aged man who suddenly turns threatening; the student jumps from the moving car and escapes. Years later, he recognizes the driver on TV as John Wayne Gacy, who had removed interior door handles after this failed abduction.

•

5:01 — Deborah Chong murder: Widow Deborah Chong takes in boarders rent-free; during COVID her YouTube consumption worsens her schizophrenia. She befriends Gemma Mitchell and offers £200k for renovations, but after antipsychotic medication clears her mind, she withdraws the offer. Gemma kills Deborah, hides the body in a suitcase, wheels it past CCTV, stores it for two weeks, then dumps it 250 miles away.

•

21:43 — Head in a gift box: In northern Spain, Carmen Merino gives neighbor Mary a wrapped box claiming it contains sex toys. Months later, a foul smell leads Mary to open it, discovering the tin-foil-wrapped severed head of Carmen's missing boyfriend Jesus Baronda. Carmen is convicted; a theory suggests she served the rest of his body in croquettes to neighbors.

•

28:31 — Staged harassment and murder: In Strongsville, Ohio, the Pleskovic family endures two years of prowlers, break-in attempts, and car tampering. Police find no evidence. Jeff Pleskovic, the son-in-law, is revealed to have staged every incident to build an alibi before murdering his mother-in-law Melinda with 35 stab wounds and three gunshots while his daughter and her nonverbal brother Kyle were in the house.

•

49:42 — Cartel Sect cannibal cult: A Brazilian family known for empadas is exposed as the Cartel Sect, a cult that murdered 'unclean' women and baked them into pastries sold to the public. Their five-year-old 'daughter' Maria was actually the child of their first victim, forced to eat her own mother's remains at age one and a half before being raised as a cult member.

Speakers

•

Narrator — Host

⋮