She Filmed Her Brother Killing Him, All for SnapChat | The Murder of Paul Scott

Original Media · 34m · English · YouTube · Annie Elise

TLDR

In June 2025, a UK mother, son, and daughter trio — Joanne Maxwell, Liam Donlin, and Amy Clegg — murdered their relative Paul Scott, 37, stabbing him through the heart at his home after months of death threats stemming from a birthday party fight. The killers left a staggering evidence trail including surveillance footage, texts declaring intent to kill, dash cam audio of the plan, and a self-recorded video of the murder, leading to murder convictions and 20–26 year minimum sentences.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The murderers were the victim's own family members — a mother, son, and daughter trio — who called 999 after the killing, possibly to manufacture an alibi.

•

Liam Donlin recorded the murder on his own phone while committing it, capturing Amy knocking on the door and his own rush to stab Paul.

•

The killers brought their own knives from home (four of five from their knife block) rather than using a kitchen knife from the victim's house.

•

The victim had explicitly predicted his own murder months earlier, naming his killers and the timeline (Liam's release), yet the threats were not acted on by authorities.

•

Amy refused CPR on the 999 call saying it would make her sick, then coldly stated "he's dead, there's nothing else we can do" while the operator urged her to try.

•

Liam pretended to perform CPR but stood over the body; forensic analysis proved he never knelt down, with blood only on his hands — not his clothing — exposing the act as a charade.

Key takeaways

•

A family trio — mother Joanne Maxwell, son Liam Donlin, and daughter Amy Clegg — murdered their cousin Paul Scott over a perceived betrayal from a birthday party fight nine months earlier, escalating from threats to premeditated killing.

•

The killers created an extraordinary evidence trail: they took four knives from their own knife block, texted and sent voice notes declaring intent to stab Paul, were recorded on dash cam planning the murder, and Liam filmed the killing on his phone as Amy lured Paul to the door.

•

Paul Scott had predicted his own murder months in advance, telling his cousin Ellie, "They're going to get me. You wait," after enduring months of explicit death threats by phone from Amy and Joanne, who said Liam would kill him once released from prison.

•

The 999 call was likely an alibi attempt: Amy (calling herself "Emily") gave a false name, refused CPR claiming it would make her sick, stated "he's dead, there's nothing else we can do" before responders arrived, and lied about her relationship to Paul.

•

Liam Donlin was released from prison the very day of the murder and immediately joined his mother and sister in the planned attack, with surveillance showing them meeting at a pub, retrieving weapons, and traveling to Paul's house together.

•

All three brought knives from their home — four of five knives missing from their branded knife block — demonstrating premeditation and joint enterprise, not a spontaneous act by Liam alone.

•

The court rejected Joanne and Amy's defense that they only intended intimidation, convicting all three of murder based on joint enterprise; Joanne received 23 years minimum, Liam 26 years, and Amy 20 years.

•

The case illustrates how a minor family dispute — a drunken fight at a 21st birthday party that Paul tried to break up — spiraled into a brutal, premeditated murder through months of escalating threats and a "thick as thieves" family mentality.

Notable quotes

“I also have to apologize because it's probably going to mess you up mentally. It did for me. It took me like days after researching it to kind of recalibrate and recover myself, especially as a parent, but I think that it is one worth sharing.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:17

“Which that is deep, that is penetrating so many hard forces, which would take an incredible amount of pressure and an incredible amount of force.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:23

“I'm going to stab him to death, G.”

▸ Notable quotes · 24:51

“Listen, Aaron, I'm just going to go. I'm going to go chop this kid up, bro, and then I'm going to come and grab you. And bro, I'm going to absolutely chop this kid up now.”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:40

“If true CPR was being performed, you would need to be knelt down by the body. And if force was being applied to the chest, he would expect a large volume of blood to be transferred or deposited upon the person performing it, both on their top and their shorts. You had very little blood on your clothing. Your account that you did CPR whilst standing over Paul Scott is inherently improbable, and I am sure that you did not do so.”

▸ Notable quotes · 30:04

“Which I think that the most jarring part about Paul's case is how senseless all of it was, right? A pointless argument at a birthday party, an argument that he wasn't even a part of, one that he was trying to split up, and then it ended in his murder months later.”

▸ Notable quotes · 33:05

Chapters

•

2:08 — Introduction and 999 Call: Host introduces the bonus episode and plays the 999 call where a woman calling herself Emily reports a stabbing but refuses CPR, gives a false address initially, and coldly states the victim is dead before responders arrive.

•

7:15 — Victim Background and Autopsy: Paul Scott, 37, is described as a kind, family-oriented man; autopsy reveals a single 20-cm kitchen knife wound penetrating 8.6 cm through his chest wall, between ribs, and 5 cm into his heart, making survival impossible.

•

12:06 — Witnesses Revealed as Family: The three witnesses — Emily, Callum, and Joanne — are exposed as Amy Clegg, Liam Donlin, and Joanne Maxwell, a mother-son-daughter trio related to Paul; they lied about identities and their connection to him.

•

17:35 — Birthday Party Fight and Threats: A September 2024 fight at Amy's 21st birthday between her boyfriend and her mother's boyfriend led to months of explicit death threats by Amy and Joanne against Paul, his aunt Victoria, cousin Ellie, and the boyfriend Charlie, with warnings that Liam would kill Paul upon release.

•

23:20 — Murder Day Evidence Trail: Liam released from prison the morning of June 21, 2025; trio drinks at pubs, retrieves four knives from their home knife block, texts show murder intent, dash cam captures Liam's voice notes planning to "chop this kid up," and they taxi to Paul's house.

•

27:38 — The Killing and 999 Call: Liam records video as Amy knocks on Paul's door; when Paul opens it, Liam rushes in and delivers the fatal stab wound; trio calls 999 but Amy refuses CPR and Liam later pretends to attempt it while standing over the body.

•

29:52 — Fake CPR and Trial Outcome: Forensic evidence debunks Liam's CPR claim — blood only on hands, not clothing, and standing position makes CPR impossible; 13-day trial convicts all three of murder with minimum terms of 20–26 years.

•

33:05 — Reflection on Senseless Violence: Host reflects on the senselessness of a murder rooted in a minor party dispute that Paul tried to stop, the betrayal by family, and the haunting question of whether you can trust your own relatives.

Speakers

•

Host — Podcast host

⋮