Exposing JP Miller’s Shady History: Years Of Abuse, SA Allegations, and More

Original Media · 1h 11m · English · YouTube · Annie Elise

TLDR

This podcast episode exposes Pastor John Paul (JP) Miller's decades-long pattern of alleged abuse, sexual misconduct, and manipulation, culminating in the death of his second wife Micah Miller. Host Annie Eliss details JP's upbringing under his scandal-plagued father Reginald, JP's own early violent offenses, his affair with 20-year-old Micah while married to his first wife Ally, and the extensive documented abuse Micah endured — including isolation, sleep deprivation, stalking, sexual coercion, spiritual manipulation, and forced medication. Despite multiple allegations from minors in the 1990s (detailed in two 2025 lawsuits), church leadership and police failed to hold JP accountable. Micah filed for divorce and died two days later; her death was ruled a suicide. JP was federally indicted in 2025 for cyberstalking and lying to police, but not for her death. He remains free on bond, preaching at a new church while protests continue outside. His son Logan was also arrested for domestic violence in 2024, continuing a multigenerational pattern. Ally, JP's first wife, believes Micah and corroborates the abuse allegations.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

JP's first wife Ally — who had every reason to resent Micah as 'the other woman' — became Micah's strongest advocate, confirming Micah's abuse allegations matched her own experiences and even observed holes in walls, doors off hinges, and negative affirmations taped throughout their home.

•

Reginald Miller (JP's father) allegedly helped JP expunge his felony record and obtain a special 'pastor' police badge to avoid traffic stops, suggesting institutional protection from law enforcement.

•

JP openly admitted in a sermon that 18 people had texted Micah offering confidential support about her marriage — including two men — and he framed their concern as demonic, revealing he monitored her communications and isolated her from support.

•

The 1998 assault victim (Jane Doe 1) had no conscious memory of the assault for decades until JP assaulted her again in 2023 at age 40, triggering repressed memories — meaning JP allegedly victimized the same person 25 years apart.

•

JP's son Logan Hardy was arrested for first-degree domestic violence in 2024, making three generations of Miller men (Reginald, JP, Logan) with documented violent or abusive behavior toward women.

Key takeaways

•

JP Miller grew up watching his father Reginald, a pastor, face credible allegations of sexual misconduct with male and female students at his Bible college and later get arrested for lewdness at a bathhouse — modeling how religious authority can shield predatory behavior.

•

At age 19, JP was arrested for assault and battery after hitting a 19-year-old woman with his truck and driving 100 yards with her on the hood; he claimed she jumped on voluntarily, but court records and witnesses contradicted him. He received only probation and community service.

•

JP's affair with Micah began when she was 20 and he was 35; she had attended his church since age 13 and was treated like a daughter by his first wife Ally. The congregation was pressured to forgive JP via a letter framing his adultery as a 'test' he failed, while elders allegedly knew of more serious allegations involving minors.

•

Ally's 2024 court filing alleges JP confessed to being 'sexually inappropriate with several underage female members' of their church, blaming his father's abuse. She says church elders demanded he enter a sexual addiction program but he never did, yet they still pressured congregants to forgive him.

•

Micah documented years of abuse in 'Micah's List': isolation from family (phone confiscated), sleep deprivation (covers pulled off, forced to sleep in car), GPS tracking and stalking by private investigators, forced sexual acts (up to four times daily, including while hospitalized), spiritual abuse (using Scripture to forbid divorce and demand forgiveness), physical violence (throat-grabbing, throwing food), and medical abuse (forced lithium and testosterone injections).

•

Two 2025 lawsuits (Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2) allege JP sexually assaulted them as minors in 1998 and 1999 — one in his father's church office and truck at age 15, the other at the Cathedral Hall Academy school run by his father at age 14. In the second case, Reginald forced the girl to write 'I will not lie about John Paul Miller' 5,000 times as punishment for reporting it.

•

JP's sermons repeatedly mirrored his private abuse: he preached wives must never speak disrespectfully to husbands, that a wife's criticism equals a punch to the stomach, that husbands hold God-given authority requiring submission 'even if they're wrong,' and that he had a 'fantastic marriage 364 days a year' with one explosive day — all while Micah was documenting systemic abuse.

•

Despite federal indictment for cyberstalking Micah (Nov 2022 until her death) and lying to police about slashing her tires and contact frequency, JP has not been charged in her death. He pleaded not guilty, was released on $100k bond, married a third wife (Susie Skinner) in 2025, and continues preaching at Mercy Church in Myrtle Beach while protesters gather weekly outside.

Notable quotes

“My dad never got father of the year award, not even once. However, he did provide for us, and if we were ever in trouble, he was the first one to take care of us and bail us out. But other than that, we didn't really see him much at all growing up.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:18

“Listen, if you ever want to know what I'm going through in life, IT'S ALWAYS ABOUT WHAT I'M PREACHING ABOUT.”

▸ Notable quotes · 28:54

“In my in our marriage, I think we have a fantastic marriage about 364 days a year. That other one day, we go from a 10 to a one and then back up to a 10 the next day. But as soon as she apologizes and I forgive her, we go forward.”

▸ Notable quotes · 32:08

“When you speak dishonorably to your husband in any way, it is equivalent to him punching you in the stomach.”

▸ Notable quotes · 35:11

“Every kind that you can imagine and even kinds that you can't imagine as a normal rational human being.”

▸ Notable quotes · 48:31

“The apple really doesn't fall far from the tree.”

▸ Notable quotes · 69:48

Chapters

•

3:20 — JP's Family Background and Father's Scandals: JP was born in 1979 to Reginald and Susan Miller. His father was a pastor who founded a church and Bible college, faced allegations of sexual advances toward male and female students in the 1980s, went through a nasty divorce, moved the family to Myrtle Beach in 1993, and was arrested in 2006 for lewdness at a bathhouse.

•

7:36 — JP's Early Arrests and Violent Behavior: At 14, JP moved to Myrtle Beach. At 18 (1997), he was arrested for driving with a suspended license. At 19 (1998), he was arrested for assault and battery after hitting Jennifer Garland with his truck and driving 100 yards with her on the hood; he claimed she jumped on voluntarily, but court records contradict this. He received probation, community service, and a suspended license.

•

11:32 — Solid Rock Ministries, Affair with Micah, and Church Scandal: JP founded Solid Rock Ministries in 2006. He cheated on his first wife Ally with 20-year-old Micah (who had attended since age 13). Ally discovered texts. The affair caused a church scandal; JP wrote a letter asking forgiveness, framing it as a 'test' he failed. Elders pressured congregants to forgive him. JP and Micah married in 2017.

•

20:00 — Ally's 2024 Court Filing: Allegations of Abuse of Minors: Ally's ex parte motion alleges JP confessed to being sexually inappropriate with underage female church members, blaming his father's abuse. Church elders knew but only demanded he enter a sexual addiction program (which he didn't). Ally contacted victims who confirmed but were too scared to report; police dismissed her because JP was a well-known pastor. Reginald allegedly helped JP expunge his record and get a 'pastor' police badge.

•

37:30 — Micah's Documented Abuse: 'Micah's List': Micah's family compiled 'Micah's List' detailing isolation (phone confiscated, family cut off), sleep deprivation (covers pulled off, forced to sleep in car), stalking (GPS trackers, PIs, showing up everywhere), sexual coercion (forced acts up to 4x daily, including in hospital), spiritual abuse (using Scripture to forbid divorce, demand forgiveness), physical violence (throat-grabbing, throwing food), and medical abuse (forced lithium, testosterone shots, pills hidden in food).

•

43:20 — JP's Sermons as Windows into the Abuse: JP's sermons mirrored the abuse: wives must never criticize husbands (criticism = punch to stomach), husbands hold God-given authority requiring submission 'even if wrong,' he had a 'fantastic marriage 364 days a year' with one explosive day, and he admitted monitoring Micah's texts (18 people offered support, he called it demonic).

•

51:00 — 2025 Lawsuits: Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2: Two lawsuits filed Feb/Mar 2025. Jane Doe 1: assaulted at 15 in 1998 in Reginald's church office and JP's truck; repressed memories resurfaced after JP assaulted her again in 2023. Jane Doe 2: assaulted at 14 in 1999 at Cathedral Hall Academy; reported to teacher, sent to Reginald's office where JP stood beside him; forced to write 'I will not lie about John Paul Miller' 5,000 times. Neither resulted in criminal charges.

•

62:00 — Micah's Death, Federal Indictment, and Current Status: Micah filed for divorce; two days later she died (ruled suicide). JP indicted Dec 2025 for cyberstalking (Nov 2022 until her death) and lying to police (about tire slashing, contact frequency). Pleaded not guilty, released on $100k bond. Married third wife Susie Skinner 2025. Preaches at Mercy Church; weekly protests outside. Son Logan arrested for domestic violence 2024. Ally believes Micah and corroborates abuse.

Speakers

•

Annie Eliss — Host

•

JP Miller (John Paul Miller) — Subject / Pastor

•

Reginald Wayne Miller — JP's Father / Former Pastor

•

Ally Williams — JP's First Wife

•

Micah Miller — JP's Second Wife (Deceased)

•

Jane Doe 1 — Lawsuit Plaintiff

•

Jane Doe 2 — Lawsuit Plaintiff

•

Logan Hardy — JP's Older Son

⋮