Rattner: Voters who 'STAYED HOME' decided the midterms

Original Media · 7m · English · YouTube · MS NOW

TLDR

Steve Ratner presents data showing the 2024 election was decided by turnout differentials rather than persuasion: 25 million Trump voters stayed home versus 17 million Harris voters. Republicans outspent Democrats roughly 2-to-1 on super PACs ($1.3 billion vs $650 million) but lost nearly every targeted race. Down-ballot Democrats in Texas and Mississippi dramatically outperformed the top of the ticket by winning Hispanic and Black areas while making inroads in educated white suburbs.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Republicans burned $1.3 billion in super PAC money and won virtually none of the targeted races, contradicting the assumption that spending advantages translate to electoral success.

•

The presidential race was decided not by voters switching sides but by which side's voters stayed home — with Trump's coalition abstaining at a significantly higher rate than Harris's.

•

A Democratic candidate in Mississippi won majority-white, highly educated counties, a result that defies the state's deep-red presidential lean and conventional wisdom about racial polarization.

Key takeaways

•

The 2024 House popular vote margin of 13.6% for Republicans ties the post-Watergate 1974 high, but masks a longer Republican structural advantage since the 1994 Gingrich revolution interrupted only by Bush-era midterms and 2018.

•

The election was decided by asymmetric abstention: a much larger share of Trump's 2022 coalition (25 million) stayed home compared to Harris voters (17 million), with minimal cross-party defection on either side.

•

Republican super PAC spending of $1.3 billion — roughly double Democratic outside spending — produced almost zero victories; the only GOP wins came in a handful of races despite massive investment including Elon Musk's hundreds of millions in Texas.

•

In Texas, the Democratic Senate candidate (Tallarico) flipped heavily Hispanic counties across education levels, moving the partisan dividing line dramatically compared to Harris's near-total wipeout.

•

In Mississippi, the Democratic candidate (Colum) not only consolidated Black-majority counties but won majority-white, highly educated counties — a pattern suggesting down-ballot Democrats can rebuild multiracial coalitions that the presidential ticket could not.

•

Historical context: Democrats held the House continuously from 1948-1994 despite Republican presidential wins, but the post-1994 era has been defined by Republican structural advantage with only brief Democratic midterm exceptions.

Notable quotes

“this election was decided by the voters who stayed home as opposed to the voters who actually voted”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:40

“Twenty five million stayed home, 17 million stayed home. And so that's really what decided these elections.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:22

“money isn't everything in politics. And I think this election proves it as much as any I've seen.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:51

“all this money, as you say, was burned because they didn't win any races for all that money”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:39

“Essentially, Tallarico moved that blue line all the way over here.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:56

“Even in counties that were almost completely white among people who were highly educated, he actually got a majority.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:09

Chapters

•

0:00 — Historical House majority context: Ratner shows House control from 1948-1994 (Democratic) and 1994-present (mostly Republican), noting the 2024 13.6% GOP margin ties the post-Watergate high.

•

2:07 — Turnout differential decided the election: Charts reveal 25M Trump voters and 17M Harris voters from 2022 stayed home in 2024, with minimal cross-party switching; the abstention gap determined outcomes.

•

2:50 — Republican money advantage failed to produce wins: GOP super PACs raised $1.3B vs ~$650M for Democrats, but lost nearly every targeted race; Elon Musk's spending in Texas yielded no victories.

•

4:04 — Texas down-ballot Democrat overperformed Harris: Heat maps show Tallarico won Hispanic areas across education levels that Harris lost by 50+ points, dramatically shifting the partisan map.

•

5:17 — Mississippi Democrat won educated white counties: Colum consolidated Black-majority areas and pushed into white counties, even winning majority-white, highly educated counties — a striking deviation from presidential results.

Speakers

•

Steve Ratner — Analyst

•

Joe — Host

•

Rachel — Host

⋮