TLDR
Crime Weekly hosts Derek and Stephanie celebrate their 1-year podcast anniversary with a live stream, reflecting on their unlikely partnership, sharing behind-the-scenes stories, answering fan questions, and announcing future plans including a Patreon for ad-free early access and the Kaylee Anthony case as their next deep dive.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
They initially hated their theme music, comparing it to 'The Real Slim Shady' intro, but it grew on them.
The 'Undercover Pineapple' catchphrase unknowingly references a swinger symbol; they learned this only after putting it on merchandise.
Derek wrote a full script for the Jennifer Dulos episode (11 pages, 3,266 words) but Stephanie heavily rewrote it, saying he writes 'like a police report.'
Stephanie doesn't consume true crime in her free time; Derek wasn't a true crime fan before the podcast — they came from completely different lanes.
Casey Anthony reportedly monitors all content about herself using sock puppet accounts and has argued with people on Reddit.
Derek's 'day off' involves changing hot tub chemicals, fixing rental property electrical, and power washing his house — not relaxation.
Key takeaways
The podcast reached ~9 million downloads in its first year despite only being on YouTube for six months.
Stephanie writes nearly all scripts (51 of 52 episodes) while Derek handles business/administrative tasks — a division of labor they credit for their success.
They met when Derek (retired police officer, Big Brother alum) slid into Stephanie's DMs after researching true crime YouTubers; they clicked immediately despite different backgrounds.
They plan to launch a low-cost Patreon after the new year offering episodes one day early with no Google ads (live reads remain).
Their next multi-part case will be Kaylee Anthony, which Stephanie covered early in her YouTube career and wants to revisit with improved research.
The 'Undercover Pineapple' inside joke originated from a giveaway phrase and accidentally references swinger culture, which they embraced.
Derek admits to an unhealthy work addiction — even on 'days off' he does physical labor like power washing — while Stephanie only relaxes by leaving the house (e.g., hotel stays).
They aim to hit 100k YouTube subscribers before 2022 and encourage Apple Podcast reviews to boost chart rankings.
Notable quotes
“the only reason it works is because you guys will you know tune in every week and watch or listen so it justifies us doing it so we we really couldn't do it without you”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:13“you really have to be like completely vibing you have to be on the same page to work as a team you know always when you're working together every day when you have a business when like your content is dependent on youtube like meshing it's so important”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:49“we got lucky and we're very v we're actually scaring scarily similar”
▸ Notable quotes · 24:05“i have an unhealthy uh addiction to like just working constantly and even when i'm not working like i'll tell stephanie like today is a saturday it's like my day off so today on my day off i changed all the chemicals in the hot tub i went and changed the electrical uh at my real estate property”
▸ Notable quotes · 16:39“undercover pineapple... we were quickly informed that this is apparently like a sign of being like a swinger a sign of being a swinger it's like a subtle way of letting up people outside your circle know like you're open for business”
▸ Notable quotes · 70:15“she's naming names right now behind closed doors that we don't know about because she's saying all these names that nobody wants to hear what we want to hear but nobody wants us to hear them aka the government and they're going to let her go because she's already claiming to be a victim”
▸ Notable quotes · 77:47Chapters
0:00 — Live Stream Kickoff & Anniversary Celebration: Derek and Stephanie go live on YouTube to celebrate Crime Weekly's 1-year anniversary, thank fans, and share download stats (~9M in year one).
8:00 — Fan Q&A: Deserted Island, Dream Interviews & Big Brother: They answer fun questions: who survives a deserted island (Derek), dream interview subjects (JonBenét Ramsey, Madeleine McCann), and whether Stephanie could win Big Brother (Derek says yes).
12:00 — Work Habits, Unwinding & Episode Frequency: Both admit poor work-life balance: Derek does manual labor on 'days off'; Stephanie only relaxes by leaving the house. They explain why a second weekly episode isn't feasible yet but may launch a shorter-format show mid-2022.
18:00 — Origin Story: How They Met & Started the Podcast: Derek recounts sliding into Stephanie's DMs after googling 'true crime YouTubers,' impressed by her research depth. They clicked on a call, and he insisted she be his co-host despite producer suggestions.
24:00 — Apple Podcast Reviews Appeal & Script Writing Debate: They urge fans to leave Apple Podcast reviews to climb charts. A heated but playful debate erupts over whether Derek wrote the Jennifer Dulos script (he did, but Stephanie rewrote it heavily).
52:00 — Future Cases: Kaylee Anthony, Jodi Arias & Brian Laundrie Rumors: They confirm Kaylee Anthony as the next multi-part case. Stephanie wants to revisit Jodi Arias. They dismiss rumors linking Brian Laundrie to the Moab newlyweds' murders, citing MO mismatch (strangulation vs. shooting).
76:00 — Daybell & Ghislaine Maxwell Predictions: Derek predicts Lori Vallow Daybell will go to prison but Chad may not; both believe Ghislaine Maxwell will be released after naming powerful names behind closed doors.
69:00 — Undercover Pineapple Origin, Giveaways & Sign-Off: They explain the 'Undercover Pineapple' inside joke (accidental swinger reference). Give away a signed book (to Enza) and tote bag (to Kaylee Ulmer). Announce Wednesday episode (Taylor Wright finale) and Patreon plans post-New Year.
Speakers
Derek — Co-host, retired police officer, former Big Brother contestant, author
Stephanie — Co-host, true crime YouTuber, researcher, scriptwriter