Tragedy in Pennsylvania, Justice in Rhode Island | Two Shocking Cases

Original Media · 42m · English · YouTube · Crime Weekly

TLDR

The episode covers two cases: a recent mass shooting in Erie, Pennsylvania where a father killed eight family members including two children and a pregnant woman before taking his own life, and a 1985 cold case murder in Newport, Rhode Island where DNA genealogy and a discarded water bottle led to the arrest of Billy Morton, who had committed a nearly identical assault a month after the murder but served only seven years.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The Erie gunman actively lured Good Samaritans outside to kill them rather than staying inside the house.

•

Billy Morton committed a nearly identical assault one month after Hillary's murder in the same neighborhood but was not investigated for her death at the time.

•

Morton served only seven years for sexually assaulting and choking a 15-year-old girl unconscious.

•

A retired investigator carried the unknown killer's DNA sequence in his wallet for decades as a personal commitment to the case.

Key takeaways

•

In the Erie shooting, the gunman Matthew Stone lured two women who came to help outside the house and shot them, a tactic the hosts had rarely seen before.

•

The Erie County Coroner ruled no autopsies necessary because cause of death was obvious, a common practice when evidence is clear and to respect victims' families.

•

Derek Levasseur argues for a vetting process that removes firearms from people experiencing suicidal ideation or mental health deterioration, similar to domestic violence firearm seizures.

•

Hillary Hallowell's 1985 murder was solved 41 years later when investigators used DNA genealogy to identify a family, then surveilled suspect Billy Morton until he discarded a water bottle at a concert.

•

Billy Morton had been convicted in 1987 of sexually assaulting and choking a 15-year-old girl in a park one block from where Hillary's body was found, just one month after her murder, but served only seven years.

•

The same investigators who worked Hillary's case in 1985 apparently never connected Morton to it despite the identical MO and proximity, a failure the hosts find inexcusable.

•

Retired Newport investigator James Evan Hazel carried the unidentified DNA sequence from Hillary's case in his wallet for decades, illustrating how deeply cold cases affect detectives.

•

Proper evidence preservation by Newport Police in 1985 allowed the degraded DNA to be tested successfully with modern technology, highlighting the importance of correct storage protocols.

Notable quotes

“Like the coward's way out.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:37

“the gunman luring people who were trying to help to come closer so he could take them out as well instead of just staying inside the house, you know?”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:49

“if you are someone who's experiencing mental health issues, there has to be a vetting process to ensure that not only at the time of purchase, but after the fact, there is a continuation of that vetting to ensure that if your health deteriorates, you are not in possession of a firearm.”

▸ Notable quotes · 15:55

“give me a pistol and two mags and I can do as much damage as someone with an assault rifle.”

▸ Notable quotes · 18:49

“He choked her unconscious and assaulted her. Yeah, sound familiar?”

▸ Notable quotes · 31:42

“Hazel pulled out his wallet, and inside he was still carrying the unidentified DNA sequence associated with Hillary's case.”

▸ Notable quotes · 38:47

Chapters

•

0:14 — Introduction and Case Overview: Hosts Derek Levasseur and Stephanie Harlow introduce two cases: a recent mass shooting in Erie, Pennsylvania and a 1985 cold case murder in Newport, Rhode Island solved via DNA.

•

5:32 — Erie Mass Shooting Details: Eight victims including two children and a pregnant woman killed by suspected gunman Matthew Stone, who then died by suicide; ShotSpotter technology alerted police; gunman lured two helpers outside and shot them.

•

8:25 — Victims and Investigation Status: Victims identified as three generations of Stone family plus two relatives who came to help; coroner ruled deaths homicides and shooter's death suicide; no autopsies performed; motive unknown but mental health suggested as factor.

•

14:43 — Discussion on Prevention and Gun Policy: Hosts debate mental health vetting for gun ownership, firearm removal processes for those with suicidal ideation, and the lethality of handguns versus assault rifles.

•

27:12 — Hillary Hallowell 1985 Murder: 22-year-old Hillary Hallowell sexually assaulted and strangled in Newport; evidence preserved but technology insufficient in 1985; case went cold despite investigation.

•

29:58 — DNA Breakthrough and Arrest: 2023 re-investigation used DNA genealogy to identify suspect family; surveillance led to Billy Morton; discarded water bottle at concert provided DNA match; arrested October 2024.

•

31:30 — Prior Conviction and Missed Connection: Morton convicted in 1987 for nearly identical assault on 15-year-old girl one month after Hillary's murder, one block away; served only seven years; investigators failed to connect cases at the time.

•

38:25 — Resolution and Closing: Case moving to court; retired investigator carried DNA sequence in wallet for decades; hosts emphasize importance of evidence preservation and DNA funding for cold cases.

Speakers

•

Derek Levasseur — Host

•

Stephanie Harlow — Host

⋮