TLDR
Democrat Scott Colom leads incumbent Republican Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith by over 4,400 votes in Mississippi's U.S. Senate race, with MSNBC changing the race rating to "Lean Democrat." A Colom victory would make him the first Black senator elected by Mississippi voters since Reconstruction, marking a dramatic shift in a state that backed Donald Trump by 24 points just two years ago. The race reflects a convergence of sustained Black organizing infrastructure, a strong candidate running on affordability and cross-aisle appeal, and a national environment unfavorable to Republicans. Certification deadline is Friday the 13th, though Hyde-Smith would need 65% of remaining votes — margins she isn't achieving in her strongholds. Both campaigns are prepared for possible litigation.}
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Mississippi — a state that voted for Trump by 24 points in 2024 — is on the verge of electing a Black Democrat to the U.S. Senate, which would be the first Black senator chosen by Mississippi voters since Reconstruction (previous Black senators were appointed by the state legislature).
Scott Colom explicitly broke with national Democrats on border security and praised Trump's tax policies, yet still consolidated overwhelming Black support and attracted cross-racial appeal — defying the assumption that such positions would alienate the Democratic base.
Raphael Warnock was laughed out of the room at Mississippi fundraisers in April but became the campaign's largest Senate fundraiser (~$750,000), showing how quickly the race shifted from dismissed to competitive.
Cindy Hyde-Smith dropped from 54% in 2020 to below 49% in 2024 despite Trump winning the state by a similar margin both times — a rare case of an incumbent senator dramatically underperforming the top of the ticket in a safe-red state.
Young organizers at Tougaloo and Jackson State cured rejected ballots on Election Day itself, working across campuses to validate votes by the 5 p.m. deadline — a level of same-day ballot-chasing infrastructure rarely seen in deep-red states.
Key takeaways
Sustained Black organizing infrastructure built over a decade — including the Mississippi NAACP's 2022 lawsuit that forced redistricting and groups like Mississippi Votes — flipped two state Senate seats in 2025 and broke the Republican supermajority, laying the groundwork for Colom's competitive Senate run.
Scott Colom ran as a sitting district attorney who unseated a 37-year incumbent, campaigned on affordability and bipartisan cooperation rather than identity, broke with national Democrats on border security, praised Trump's no-tax-on-tips policy, and conducted an aggressive retail campaign with over 60 town halls, food trucks, and DJ events at HBCUs and public housing projects.
Cindy Hyde-Smith was not noted for legislative achievements and ran a far less active campaign, while Roger Wicker outperformed Trump by nearly two points in 2024 — showing Hyde-Smith's underperformance was candidate-specific, not just environmental.
Black voter turnout surged in urban centers: Jackson 80-18, Oxford 60-38, Starkville and Hattiesburg similarly strong, while Colom lost rural areas by smaller margins than previous Democrats — a pattern of Democrats winning by more where they win and losing by less where they lose.
The Shelby County v. Holder decision enabled district carving, polling place closures, and other voter suppression tactics that organizers treated as a direct attack on Black political power, fueling a generational sense of responsibility to vote that cut across the South.
National Democrats underestimated Colom for months; major figures like Raphael Warnock (who raised ~$750,000), Pete Buttigieg, Kamala Harris, and Warnock only engaged late, while Colom had already built momentum across the state.
Mississippi's decentralized election system — 82 counties operating independently with no uniform recount process — delayed the call; the Secretary of State's certification deadline is Friday the 13th, and Hyde-Smith would need 65% of all remaining votes, a mathematical near-impossibility given her current margins in outstanding counties.
The race mirrors broader Southern shifts: Latino-majority counties in South Texas swung back toward Democrats, Florida Republicans failed to flip any of four targeted seats via redistricting, and North Carolina's GOP gerrymander may backfire — suggesting a regional realignment driven by candidate quality, organizing, and anti-chaos sentiment.
Notable quotes
“he will be the first black senator that Mississippi voters ever elected. That Mississippi voters themselves said we want you to represent us.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:46“This is a government that has tried to crush the will of the people. This is a government that has literally tried to tell us, the federal government, take it or leave it. This is what we're giving you. And all across the South, right here in Mississippi, all across this country, people have said not on my watch.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:01“He wasn't running on being the first Black anything or in this case the second Black senator since Reconstruction. He was running on affordability and the things that have to happen.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:58“The remaining votes might not be enough to overcome the lead that he's now only that's not only grown over the last couple of days.”
▸ Notable quotes · 18:05“She's not winning by those margins in those places already. So that's that's number one. That's why this is people are feeling confident about this.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:52“These students, the ballot box on Tuesday had the potential to make history, yes. But they said that Mississippi has been making moves and it's about time that America woke up and saw what they knew to be true right here in their own state.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:10Chapters
0:02 — Race Overview and Historic Significance: MSNBC changes Mississippi Senate race rating to Lean Democrat as Scott Colom leads Cindy Hyde-Smith by 4,400+ votes; a Colom win would make him the first Black senator elected by Mississippi voters since Reconstruction, a dramatic shift from Trump's 24-point win in 2024.
1:44 — Vote Breakdown and County-Level Analysis: Ali Velshi details Colom's dominance in urban areas and HBCU centers (Jackson 80-18, Oxford 60-38) while losing rural areas by smaller margins; Roger Wicker outperformed Trump in 2024, highlighting Hyde-Smith's candidate-specific underperformance.
3:26 — Organizing Infrastructure and Candidate Quality: Simone Sanders-Townsend identifies three factors: 2025 state Senate flips from NAACP-led redistricting lawsuit, Colom's proven track record unseating a 37-year incumbent DA, and decade-long nonpartisan organizing by Mississippi Votes and HBCU students.
9:02 — Colom's Retail Campaign and Cross-Appeal Strategy: Namdi Iguanwu describes Colom's 60+ town halls, food truck events at HBCUs and public housing, viral Trump rally interviews, and policy positions breaking with national Democrats on border security while praising Trump's tax proposals.
10:18 — National Democratic Investment and Late Surge: Major Democratic figures (Warnock, Buttigieg, Harris) engaged late; Warnock raised ~$750,000 after being laughed at in April; Colom built momentum independently before national support arrived.
11:36 — Generational Responsibility and Voter Suppression Backlash: Sanders-Townsend connects Shelby decision, district carving, polling place closures to a generational sense of duty; students at Tougaloo and Jackson State cured ballots on Election Day; frame the election as resistance to government overreach.
14:42 — Regional Parallels and Mathematical Reality: Velshi shows South Texas Latino counties swinging blue, Florida GOP redistricting failures, North Carolina gerrymander backfiring; Hyde-Smith needs 65% of remaining votes — mathematically implausible given her current margins.
18:00 — Certification Timeline and Litigation Readiness: Mississippi's decentralized 82-county system delays call; Secretary of State certification deadline Friday the 13th; both campaigns prepared for litigation but Colom campaign confident remaining votes will secure victory.
Speakers
Alicia Menendez — Host
Ali Velshi — Correspondent
Namdi Iguanwu — Reporter
Simone Sanders-Townsend — Political Analyst