Mom Shocked After Learning Teen Sons Are Wanted Killers

Original Media · 54m · English · YouTube · Dr Insanity

TLDR

In rural New Mexico, brothers Tyler and Eli Chaffen murder William Johnson at the behest of Sierra Collins, William's ex-girlfriend. Sierra lures the brothers to William's home under false pretenses, resulting in an execution-style shooting. Police arrest all three after a SWAT standoff; interrogations reveal Sierra orchestrated the killing while the brothers claim self-defense. Sierra dies in custody before trial; Eli pleads to voluntary manslaughter (6 years), Tyler to second-degree murder (15 years). Their mother Tiffany struggles to accept her sons' culpability.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The mother of the suspects was permitted to sit in on her adult son's murder interrogation, which is highly atypical and risked the case.

•

Eli Chaffen admitted he learned all his firearms knowledge from YouTube and TikTok, not from any certified training.

•

Sierra Collins asked the brothers 'would you kill for me?' as a supposed joke days before the murder, then led them to the victim's house.

•

The brothers were watching gun YouTubers and playing video games in their parents' living room just hours before the killing.

•

Sierra Collins died in custody from a medical emergency before she could stand trial, taking her full account to the grave.

Key takeaways

•

Sierra Collins manipulated the Chaffen brothers into killing her ex-boyfriend William Johnson by exploiting their protective instincts and feeding them false narratives about his abuse.

•

The shooting was not self-defense but a calculated execution: William was shot in the back while face down, and the brothers arrived armed with an AR-15 and other firearms.

•

Detective Decker separated the brothers and used their own statements against each other — Tyler's early confession implicated Eli, and Eli's later interview contradicted Tyler's claim about the gun.

•

Eli Chaffen, 19, had no formal firearms training; he learned gun handling from YouTube and TikTok, yet owned multiple weapons including an AR-15 purchased by his parents.

•

Tiffany Chaffen was allowed in the interrogation room with her adult son Eli, an unusual move that risked contaminating the interview but ultimately did not prevent his confession.

•

Sierra Collins died of a medical emergency in detention before trial, leaving her full role unresolved; her phone contained incriminating messages planning the confrontation.

•

Both brothers accepted plea deals: Eli to voluntary manslaughter (6 years), Tyler to second-degree murder and felon in possession (15 years), acknowledging the killing was not justified self-defense.

Notable quotes

“I felt I had to shoot wheels to make sure my brother didn't get hurt. This police are always trying to protect the children.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:16

“The the chain of events that took place, if I can access that phone, that will help me huge.”

▸ Notable quotes · 13:04

“I know that it was that was her plan. And I don't know if she was cuz she was outside whenever we pulled up cuz she had asked Eli, 'If you'd shoot him before all this happened, jokingly like, uh-uh, that's a nice gun. Would you shoot my ex-boyfriend? Was all a joke until today.”

▸ Notable quotes · 28:26

“Do you know what the hole in the back in his back tells me? You know what's not in in looking at the way that that that bullet hit his back is that he was already laying face down when that round was fired.”

▸ Notable quotes · 25:48

“I didn't want Will to kill my brother. I didn't want Will to get the gun. So, I shot Will.”

▸ Notable quotes · 41:50

“Your biggest your biggest fear right now is that you have you've made things pretty rough for your brother. I know I know what brother love is, man. I' I've got them.”

▸ Notable quotes · 51:19

Chapters

•

1:57 — 911 calls and initial response: Neighbors report gunshots and a fleeing white SUV; officers arrive to find William Johnson dead with multiple gunshot wounds.

•

2:55 — Crime scene analysis: Officers examine the body and wound patterns, concluding the shooting was an execution rather than a chaotic confrontation.

•

6:52 — Neighbor canvass and victim ID: Police identify the victim as William Johnson and learn about his volatile relationship with ex-girlfriend Sierra Collins.

•

10:22 — Sierra's first interview: Detective Decker questions Sierra; she refuses to unlock William's phone, admits knowing the killers, but claims she was manipulated.

•

16:26 — SWAT raid and arrest of brothers: SWAT surrounds the Chaffen home, breaches it, then arrests Tyler and Eli in a white SUV matching the suspect vehicle; an AR-15 is found in the car.

•

19:02 — Brothers' recorded car conversation: In the patrol car, Tyler coaches Eli to stick to their story, revealing their coordination and awareness of guilt.

•

22:12 — Tyler's interrogation: Tyler confesses to the shooting but frames it as self-defense, implicating Eli as the shooter and Sierra as the mastermind.

•

30:17 — Sierra's second interview and arrest: Confronted with phone evidence, Sierra breaks down; Detective Decker arrests her for murder based on her orchestration.

Speakers

•

Tiffany Chaffen — Mother of Tyler and Eli

•

Tyler Chaffen — Older brother, suspect

•

Eli Chaffen — Younger brother, shooter

•

Sierra Collins — Ex-girlfriend of victim, orchestrator

•

Detective Decker — Lead investigator

•

William Johnson — Victim

⋮