HALLOWEEN H20 REACTION – The Best Ending in the Entire Franchise?! - FIRST TIME WATCHING

Original Media · 1h 31m · English · YouTube · Reel Rejects

TLDR

Jackie and John watch and react to Halloween H2O (1998), the 20th-anniversary sequel that ignores films 4-6 and follows Laurie Strode (Jamie Lee Curtis) living under a new identity as a California headmistress while Michael Myers returns after 20 years. They praise the film's direction, writing, Laurie's grounded PTSD portrayal, and the decisive decapitation ending, calling it a franchise high point that redeems the previous sequels.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The car Norma (Janet Leigh) drives is the same one from Psycho (1960) — a subtle homage to Jamie Lee Curtis's mother.

•

Chris Durand (Michael Myers) chose not to watch any previous Halloween films and 'did his own thing,' resulting in a clumsier, weirdly walking Michael that some viewers read as an imposter.

•

PJ Soles (Lynda from Halloween 1978) was offered the nurse role but it went to Janet Leigh instead — a missed full-circle casting opportunity.

•

The film was intended to end the franchise, but its box office success led to Halloween: Resurrection (2002).

•

Joseph Gordon-Levitt's opening kill mirrors Drew Barrymore's Scream opening — a deliberate nod given Williamson's involvement.

Key takeaways

•

Halloween H2O retcons the 'Thorn trilogy' (4-6) and serves as a direct sequel to Halloween 1-2, with Laurie Strode now Keri Tate, a headmistress at a private school in Northern California.

•

The film leans into Laurie's PTSD and trauma realistically — she's a functioning alcoholic, overprotective mother, and therapy-goer, making her final girl evolution feel grounded rather than caricatured.

•

Michael Myers is faster, more aggressive, and visibly human (eyes visible through mask), reinforcing the original's theme that 'evil can be anyone, anywhere.'

•

The ending features a definitive decapitation — the first time Laurie truly kills Michael — which the hosts found cathartic and earned after the franchise's previous fake-outs.

•

The movie shares DNA with Scream (1996): Kevin Williamson worked on it, Marco Beltrami scored both, and it uses Scream's stock music, giving it a late-'90s meta-horror vibe.

•

Jamie Lee Curtis pitched this as a 20th-anniversary celebration; John Carpenter and Debra Hill declined to return, so Friday the 13th Part 2/3 director Steve Miner helmed it.

•

Four different masks were used in filming (H6 mask, K&B Productions, Stan Winston Studios close-up mask, and a CGI mask), leading to inconsistent Michael Myers appearances.

•

The hosts rank this above the 2018 trilogy for its balance of fun, scares, character work, and respectful franchise callbacks without heavy-handedness.

Notable quotes

“The fact that we can see him so much through the mask in this one, I think it really goes back to what made the original Halloween work so well, which is it's the idea that evil can be anyone and anywhere and that's what's really scary.”

▸ Notable quotes · 71:32

“This feels like a masterpiece in terms of this was fun. Scary movie genre, the horror thriller genre. I think that's what it has that reputation for sure.”

▸ Notable quotes · 75:27

“Decapitate. Incinerate. Separate the ashes. Or if we cut off his hand so that way he doesn't hold the knife. A submarine. Yes. Release the ashes at the bottom of the ocean. Right. Launch the ashes into space.”

▸ Notable quotes · 60:36

“I would watch this over and over. I don't know. I just I just want It's like clever writing and like John is not in it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 45:18

“Evil dies tonight.”

▸ Notable quotes · 56:48

“This is my favorite one. I think I said it during the review. I think that the direction I really loved the direction of it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 70:08

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction & Setup: Jackie and John introduce the episode, dressed for Halloween, and discuss their disappointment with Halloween 4-6 and optimism for H2O as a new timeline ignoring those films.

•

2:00 — Opening Scene & First Kills: They react to the cold open: a nurse (Marion Chambers) and Joseph Gordon-Levitt's character are killed by Michael, establishing a Scream-like tone and confirming the 20-year gap.

•

10:00 — Laurie's New Life & School Setting: Laurie (now Keri Tate) is revealed as a headmistress at a private California school with a teenage son (Josh Hartnett). Her PTSD, alcoholism, and overprotectiveness are explored.

•

31:00 — Sponsor Break: Huel sponsorship segment inserted mid-episode.

•

33:00 — Michael's Return & Escalation: Michael stalks the campus, kills supporting characters (LL Cool J's character, students), and Laurie realizes he's found her. The phone lines are cut; tension escalates.

•

55:00 — Climax & Final Confrontation: Laurie arms herself, faces Michael in a brutal knife fight, and ultimately decapitates him with an axe — a definitive kill the hosts found cathartic.

•

66:00 — Post-Movie Review: The hosts discuss why H2O works: grounded Laurie, smart direction, effective scares, clever writing, and a satisfying ending. They compare it favorably to the 2018 trilogy.

•

73:00 — Patreon Q&A & Trivia: They answer viewer questions on timeline preferences, favorite Laurie children, mask variations, behind-the-scenes trivia (four masks, Steve Miner directing, Kevin Williamson's involvement), and confirm the next watch: Friday the 13th Part 7.

Speakers

•

Jackie — Co-host

•

John — Co-host

⋮