TLDR
This Veterans Day segment examines the growing divide between the U.S. military and civilian society. Through the Villanueva family — a Marine father and Navy officer son — and historians Greg Daddis and Katherine Kuzminski, it traces how the shift from a draft to an all-volunteer force has made military service a "family business" (over 75% of new Army recruits have a relative who served), while fewer than 1% of Americans now serve. Experts warn this insularity makes wars "invisible" to the public, leading to "forever wars" because citizens don't question them, even as military families bear repeated deployments and a declining willingness to recommend service (down from 55% to 37% since 2016). Daddis urges civilians to reflect on their responsibility to be "an American worth fighting for."
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The all-volunteer force was adopted not just for military effectiveness but because the draft became politically untenable — Americans resisted sending only their sons to war without broader public say in the use of force.
The military's shift to a smaller professional force was enabled by relying on other instruments of national power — economy, diplomacy, alliances — not just military might alone.
The "family business" dynamic means military service is increasingly inherited: at West Point, cadets often have both parents who are graduates, creating a multi-generational officer corps distinct from the broader population.
Key takeaways
The U.S. military has shifted from a broad-based draft force to a small, professional all-volunteer force where service is increasingly concentrated in military families — over three-quarters of new Army recruits have a relative who served, creating a self-perpetuating warrior caste.
The civilian-military gap has widened to the point where fewer than 1% of Americans serve, and most civilians' engagement ends at saying "thank you for your service" without understanding the sacrifices or questioning the wars being fought.
This disconnect allows "invisible wars" to become "forever wars" because when the public doesn't see or feel the cost of conflict, there is little political pressure to end or scrutinize military engagements.
Military families bear disproportionate and repeated costs: Jeremy Villanueva missed his son's birth and first six months during his first deployment, then deployed to Iraq seven months after returning; his son Daniel now misses holidays and milestones on his own deployments.
The tradition of family service is weakening — a Blue Star Families survey found only 37% of active-duty family respondents would recommend service to a young relative in 2025, down from 55% in 2016, as parents who know the sacrifice firsthand hesitate to encourage their children to follow.
Veterans like Jeremy Villanueva continue serving after leaving uniform through organizations like Paralyzed Veterans of America, emphasizing that for many, "the war never leaves them" long after headlines fade and the country moves on.
Historian Greg Daddis argues Veterans Day should prompt civilians to reflect on their relationship with those who serve, recognizing that citizenship carries the responsibility to be "an American worth fighting for" and to resist politicization that frays national bonds.
Notable quotes
“I THINK MANY AMERICANS, UNFORTUNATELY, WILL JUST SAY THANK YOU FOR YOUR SERVICE, AND THAT'S WHERE THE CONVERSATION ENDS.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:00“AND INVISIBLE WARS THEN HAVE A TENDENCY TO TURN INTO FOREVER WARS, IN MY ESTIMATION.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:30“THE LESS THAT WAR IS SEEN BY AMERICAN CITIZENS, THE LESS LIKELY THEY ARE TO ASK QUESTIONS ABOUT IT.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:37“UNLESS YOU'VE LIVED THROUGH IT, YOU CAN'T FULLY APPRECIATE WHAT THAT SACRIFICE ACTUALLY IS.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:32“IT'S A MOMENT TO REFLECT ON YOUR RELATIONSHIP WITH THOSE WHO ARE SERVING AND THAT RELATIONSHIP COMES WITH THE RESPONSIBILITY TO BE AN AMERICAN WORTH FIGHTING FOR”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:30“FOR SO MANY, THE WAR NEVER LEAVES THEM.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:55Chapters
0:06 — Introduction and the Villanueva Family: Judy Woodruff introduces the Veterans Day segment and the Villanueva family — Marine Jeremy Villanueva, who deployed shortly after 9/11 and missed his son's birth, and his son Daniel, now a Navy officer serving on the same type of ship that carried his father to war.
2:02 — Historical Shift: From Draft to All-Volunteer Force: Historians Greg Daddis and Katherine Kuzminski trace the evolution from localized state militias and mixed conscript-volunteer forces through the world wars' mass drafts to the post-Vietnam all-volunteer force, driven by political opposition to sending only men to war without public consent.
4:09 — Military Service as a Family Business: Pentagon data shows over 75% of new Army recruits have a family member who served; the Villanuevas exemplify this multi-generational tradition, with Jeremy enlisting so his son could later commission, and Daniel growing up with service encouraged by father, uncles, and cousins.
5:12 — Weakening Tradition and the Civilian-Military Gap: A Blue Star Families survey shows willingness to recommend service plummeting from 55% to 37%; Jeremy explains that knowing the sacrifice firsthand makes it harder to watch your child make the same choice, while Greg Daddis warns most Americans' engagement ends at a superficial 'thank you.'
5:52 — Family Costs of Repeated Deployments: Jeremy deployed to Iraq seven months after returning home; his wife Michelle describes the unrecognized sacrifices of military spouses — lost time, solo parenting. Their son Daniel now experiences the same separations, missing Thanksgiving, Christmas, and months of family life.
6:50 — Consequences: Invisible Wars Become Forever Wars: With fewer than 1% serving, wars become invisible to most citizens. Daddis argues this insulation makes the public less likely to question national security decisions, allowing conflicts to persist without scrutiny — 'invisible wars then have a tendency to turn into forever wars.'
7:47 — Veterans' Ongoing Service and a Call to Civilians: Jeremy Villanueva works with Paralyzed Veterans of America, noting 'the war never leaves them' long after headlines fade. Daddis closes with a challenge: Veterans Day should prompt civilians to reflect on their responsibility to be 'an American worth fighting for' and to resist politicization that frays national bonds.
Speakers
Judy Woodruff — Host/Journalist
Jeremy Villanueva — Marine Veteran / Father
Daniel Villanueva — Navy Officer / Son
Michelle Villanueva — Military Spouse / Mother
Greg Daddis — Military Historian / Retired Army Colonel
Katherine Kuzminski — Defense Policy Analyst