TLDR
The Creepcast hosts record from the allegedly haunted Sally House basement in Atchison, Kansas, where they read four horror pieces: the classic creepypasta "The Portraits" (a hunter finds portraits that turn out to be windows), the Japanese ritual "The Bath Game" (summoning a one-eyed bathtub ghost), "Empty Prison" by M59 Gar (a prisoner witnesses a supernatural entity rising floor by floor through a haunted prison), and Gretlecat's "My student submitted the most disturbing living history project" (a teacher watches a student's interview with her great-uncle, revealing his delusional survival in a war-torn school where the radio never stopped playing).
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The Sally House's scariest moment was a DoorDash driver refusing to approach the door, not paranormal activity.
The Bath Game's "Daruma San" refers to a Japanese Zen Buddhist doll, not an Islamic ritual as one host jokingly guessed.
In "Empty Prison," the supernatural entity's schedule aligns with seasonal changes and corporate bankruptcy proceedings, merging haunting with bureaucratic collapse.
The janitor in the final story maintained his delusion for decades, and the radio continuing to work was the only thing that broke his psychosis — not the sight of corpses.
Key takeaways
The Sally House basement setting amplifies the horror reading experience, with the hosts genuinely unnerved by environmental sounds and visual illusions in the dark.
"The Portraits" demonstrates how a micro-fiction twist — portraits revealed as windows — can deliver more dread than elaborate lore.
The Bath Game ritual illustrates how creepypasta transforms folklore into performative instructions that blur the line between story and dangerous game.
"Empty Prison" uses a rising-floor structure to manifest institutional neglect as supernatural horror, where bureaucracy (the extra day making it a prison sentence) enables the haunting.
The story's climax reveals the guard Kellen may have been a shared delusion, underscoring that no institution or individual truly cared for the prisoners.
Gretlecat's living history story weaponizes the classroom assignment format to layer a teacher's voyeurism, a family's trauma, and a janitor's psychosis where a radio's continuity masks a school full of corpses.
The final reveal — "the radio was still on" — reframes the janitor's letter as a psychotic break where he maintained a clean school over dead bodies, sustained by a radio that never died.
Across all stories, the episode highlights how horror thrives on the gap between official records (insurance filings, school assignments, prison transfers) and the lived reality of the supernatural.
Notable quotes
“Without exception, they appeared to be staring down at him. Their features twisted into looks of hatred.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:26“The bath game, formerly known as Daruma San, is an old game surrounding a ghost from a bathtub that follows you all day.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:01“A single day added onto my sentence met the difference between a normal jail and unending nightmare.”
▸ Notable quotes · 27:02“It's red.”
▸ Notable quotes · 47:33“When you've spent 6 hours staring into the blind crimson eyes of a rotting demon, unable to blink your eyes for fear that it will hear the air your lashes move.”
▸ Notable quotes · 55:25“It was there all right and it was still on.”
▸ Notable quotes · 77:11Chapters
0:24 — Sally House Introduction: The hosts introduce the episode from the basement of the Sally House in Atchison, Kansas, recounting the legend of Sally, a girl who died during an appendectomy in the 1800s when the basement served as a makeshift hospital.
5:25 — The Portraits: Hunter reads the classic creepypasta "The Portraits" (aka "Cabin in the Woods"), in which a hunter spends a night in a cabin lined with hateful portraits that are revealed at dawn to be windows.
10:32 — The Bath Game Ritual: Isaiah reads the Japanese ritual "Daruma San" (The Bath Game), a step-by-step summoning of a one-eyed ghost woman who stalks the player until they end the game with a chopping motion and the word "Keta!".
24:06 — Empty Prison Part 1: Hunter begins reading M59 Gar's "Empty Prison," where a prisoner's 365-day sentence lands him in a privately run prison where guards vanish and something rises from the first floor each night.
47:34 — Empty Prison Climax: The entity reaches the fifth floor; the narrator and his cellmate Dante endure 11 days locked in with the creature after the corporation abandons the prison, ending with the revelation that their only ally, guard Kellen, may never have existed.
60:44 — Living History Project: Hunter reads Gretlecat's story about a teacher reviewing a student's interview with her great-uncle, a janitor in a war-torn Balkan school whose letter reveals he hallucinated a functioning school over corpses, sustained by a radio that never stopped playing.
77:16 — Discussion and Wrap-Up: The hosts dissect the final story's twist — the radio still working — and praise the episode's two standout narratives before thanking patrons and signing off from the haunted basement.
Speakers
Hunter — Host
Isaiah — Co-host
Nick — Co-host