Blue Kansas! Is The Culture War DEAD? w Thomas Frank

Original Media · 11m · English · YouTube · Breaking Points

TLDR

Thomas Frank discusses his seminal book 'What's the Matter with Kansas' and analyzes how Kansas has shifted from a Republican stronghold to electing a Democrat, Adam Hamilton, due to the declining power of culture wars when economic pain is high and the perceived betrayal of Trump's populist promises.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The Wizard of Oz was originally an allegory for the Populist uprising in Kansas (Tin Man = industrial worker, Scarecrow = farmer, Cowardly Lion = William Jennings Bryan).

•

Kansas last elected a Democrat to the Senate in 1932, and that victory was by only one point.

•

Culture war strategy fails not just when the economy is bad, but when there is 'no daylight' between parties on economics — as during the Clinton era.

Key takeaways

•

Culture wars drove working-class Kansans to vote against their economic interests for decades.

•

The main political tension in Kansas was historically between moderate and conservative Republicans, not between parties.

•

Affluent, highly educated suburbs like Johnson County have flipped from deep red to blue, mirroring a national realignment.

•

Culture war politics loses potency when economic suffering is severe or when both parties converge on economic policy.

•

Republican senators like Roger Marshall are seen as out-of-touch absentee representatives who don't live in the state.

•

Trump's alignment with Silicon Valley elites and failure to 'drain the swamp' or end wars constitutes a historic betrayal of his base.

•

Democrats can win in red states by focusing on tangible economic issues and genuinely listening to constituents.

Notable quotes

“The culture wars were extremely powerful for the people that I studied and the people that I talked about.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:02

“The main tension was not between Republicans and Democrats. It was between these two factions of the Republican party, the so-called moderates and the conservatives.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:35

“When you got a guy like Bill Clinton who's deregulating Wall Street banks and the Democrats are signing off on these trade agreements and that sort of thing and they're effectively that everybody is agreeing on the economic issues, yeah, the culture wars are going to work.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:36

“Donald Trump has sort of gone to his voters and given them the biggest betrayal, I think, that we have ever seen in our lifetimes.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:49

“He was going to drain the swamp. I mean, this is the most, this guy, the corruption now is in your face. It's so extreme, so incredible.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:01

“Little hokey for my taste, Thomas, but clearly it works.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:36

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction and Thomas Frank's Background: Host Crystal welcomes Thomas Frank, author of 'What's the Matter with Kansas' and other books, noting he now lives in Bethesda, Maryland.

•

0:49 — Thesis of 'What's the Matter with Kansas': Frank explains the book's core argument: how conservatives used culture wars to appeal to ordinary Kansans whose economic interests they did not share, driving a rightward shift since the 1970s.

•

2:46 — Adam Hamilton's Wizard of Oz Speech and Analysis: The hosts play a clip of Senator-elect Adam Hamilton using the Wizard of Oz as an allegory for political courage, heart, and brain; Frank connects it to the original Populist allegory.

•

5:14 — Kansas Political Realignment: Moderates Becoming Democrats: Frank details how former Republican moderates in wealthy suburbs like Johnson County have become Democrats, flipping the county for Biden in 2020, reflecting a national trend.

•

7:05 — Culture Wars vs. Economic Pain and Trump's Betrayal: Frank argues culture wars work only when economic pain is low and parties agree on economics; he describes Trump's betrayal of his 2016 promises (drain the swamp, end wars, side with workers) as historic, enabling Democratic wins.

Speakers

•

Crystal — Host

•

Thomas Frank — Guest

⋮