Richard Allen's Appellate Argument May Change The Odds

Original Media · 1h 39m · English · YouTube · Lawyer You Know

TLDR

This episode analyzes the oral arguments in Richard Allen's appeal of his conviction for the 2017 Delphi murders of Abby Williams and Libby German. The host, attorney Peter Tragos, breaks down the three-judge appellate panel's questioning of both defense and state attorneys, focusing on whether Allen's confessions — made after 13 months in solitary confinement during which he descended into psychosis — were voluntary, whether the trial court improperly excluded third-party culprit evidence and defense expert testimony, and whether the cumulative errors deprived Allen of a fair trial. The host concludes the defense has a better chance than expected but still faces long odds, with the judges appearing split along gender lines.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The state argued Richard Allen was treated *better* than other inmates in restrictive housing — receiving a free replacement iPad, a television, in-person visits with his wife, and a repaired window — despite being a pre-trial detainee held in solitary for 13 months.

•

A state mental health doctor (Dr. Martin) found Allen covered in feces, eating feces, and 'basically almost a vegetable' on April 14, 2023, yet the trial court denied an emergency motion to transfer him to a medical unit the same day.

•

The state's appellate attorney admitted she had not read the Virginia appellate decision that found reversible error for excluding the same defense expert (Tobin) on ballistics reliability grounds.

•

The male appellate judge actively assisted the state's attorney during questioning, including supplying the argument that Allen would not have survived in general population because 'other prisoners do not care for people that kill children.'

•

The host reveals that the search warrant for Allen's home — the foundation of the state's physical evidence — was based on an affidavit the defense alleges contained false statements and material omissions, yet the state argues any defects were immaterial because Allen's own 2017 statement alone established probable cause.

Key takeaways

•

The defense argues Richard Allen was held in solitary confinement for 13 months — far exceeding the 30-day policy limit — and that the state exploited his resulting psychotic break to obtain confessions, which should be suppressed as involuntary under the totality of circumstances.

•

The appellate judges pressed both sides on whether a confession can be involuntary without formal interrogation, with the defense citing a 'feedback loop' where the state broke Allen's mind through coercive conditions then benefited from his unprompted statements.

•

The state conceded Allen became psychotic by mid-April 2023 but argued his confessions before and after that period were voluntary, and that any error in admitting the psychotic-period confessions was harmless given the volume of other confessions.

•

The trial court excluded the defense's proffered ballistics expert (Tobin) who would have called the firearms identification methodology 'junk science,' though the defense was allowed to cross-examine the state's expert and present a different defense expert (Dr. Warren).

•

The defense sought to introduce evidence implicating Brad Holder as a third-party culprit, including a bind rune tattoo matching sticks arranged on a victim, but the state argued Holder had a confirmed work alibi 25 miles away at the time of the murders.

•

The host identifies a clear split among the three appellate judges: the male judge appeared aligned with the state, while the two female judges asked questions suggesting concern about the fairness of Allen's pre-trial treatment and the trial court's evidentiary rulings.

•

The host emphasizes that the confessions are the state's entire case — no eyewitness identified Allen as 'Bridge Guy,' no DNA links him to the scene, and his initial 2017 statement to police was misfiled for five years — making the voluntariness issue dispositive.

•

The host criticizes both attorneys for making excessive factual arguments suited for a jury rather than focusing on legal errors by the trial judge, and argues the fundamental unfairness of holding a presumed-innocent man in conditions that induced psychosis should be the central appellate issue.

Notable quotes

“From the beginning to end, the proceedings against Richard Allen were unprecedented, unfair, and unconstitutional.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:39

“They broke his mind and his will through their coercive tactics. And then when they saw it start to happen, they actively resisted.”

▸ Notable quotes · 22:18

“You protected him into psychosis.”

▸ Notable quotes · 80:35

“The man who came forward to volunteer to help the police is not the man who killed these girls. It's the man who didn't come forward to volunteer and help the police.”

▸ Notable quotes · 84:46

“We want to know that you got the right guy. We can't live in a world where the real killer goes free.”

▸ Notable quotes · 92:19

“I personally thought the oral arguments were just okay. I actually thought the judges' questions were better than the lawyers' arguments.”

▸ Notable quotes · 96:58

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction and Case Overview: Host Peter Tragos introduces the Richard Allen appeal oral argument breakdown, summarizing the Delphi murders case, Allen's confessions after 13 months in solitary confinement, and the core appellate issues: voluntariness of confessions, exclusion of third-party culprit and expert evidence, and trial court fairness.

•

3:40 — Defense Opening Argument: Defense counsel argues the proceedings were unprecedented and unconstitutional: Allen was held in solitary far beyond policy limits, descended into psychosis, and the state exploited his decompensation to obtain confessions. Counsel identifies three strong issues — suppression, unfair trial, and third-party culprit — and argues the trial court applied the wrong burden of proof and legal standard on voluntariness.

•

7:39 — Judicial Questioning on Confessions and Psychosis: The judges probe the standard of review for voluntariness, the jury's role, whether confessions without interrogation can be involuntary, and the timeline of Allen's psychosis and confessions. The male judge appears skeptical of the coercion argument; the female judges press the state on burden-shifting and the conditions of confinement.

•

33:47 — Third-Party Culprit and Ballistics Evidence: Defense argues the trial court erred in excluding evidence implicating Brad Holder (bind rune tattoo, social media posts, knowledge of victim) and in barring defense ballistics expert Tobin. Judges question the strength of Holder's alibi and the admissibility of the composite sketch. The state maintains Holder was confirmed at work 25 miles away.

•

46:19 — State's Argument: The state opens with the horrific facts of the murders and Allen's detailed confessions identifying himself as Bridge Guy. They argue no coercive state action occurred — solitary confinement was for safekeeping, conditions were ordinary, and Allen confessed before and after psychosis. They claim any evidentiary errors were harmless given the overwhelming evidence.

•

51:52 — Judicial Pushback on State's Position: Judges challenge the state on the 13-month solitary confinement, the trial court's burden-shifting, the exclusion of video audio, and the Virginia precedent on Tobin. The female judges express skepticism that Allen was treated normally; the male judge assists the state on general population safety.

•

84:46 — Defense Rebuttal and Closing: Defense rebuttal focuses on Betsy Blair's identification of a different man, the composite sketch, and the videos showing Allen's psychosis. A judge interrupts, stating this is not a jury argument. Defense closes by framing two worlds: either a pharmacy tech committed a bizarre ritual murder, or police confirmation bias led to the wrong man.

•

97:00 — Host Analysis and Prediction: Tragos critiques both sides for excessive factual argument, praises the judges' questions, and predicts a split panel with the male judge voting to affirm. He believes the defense has a better chance than expected due to fundamental fairness concerns but still faces long odds given the high affirmance rate on appeal.

Speakers

•

Peter Tragos — Host/Attorney Commentator

•

Defense Counsel (Mr. Lehman) — Appellate Attorney for Richard Allen

•

State Counsel (Ms. Mylander) — Appellate Attorney for the State of Indiana

•

Male Appellate Judge — Appellate Judge

•

Middle Female Appellate Judge — Appellate Judge

•

Blonde-Haired Female Appellate Judge — Appellate Judge

⋮