A hurricane helped solve this crime

Original Media · 21m · English · YouTube · MrBallen

TLDR

A storyteller recounts three true stories where plans went catastrophically wrong: a man murders his ex-wife and stages a carjacking during Hurricane Harvey, but the storm floods the parking lot preserving the car and security footage that convicts him; a vacationer in Thailand drunkenly trips over his suitcase in the dark and fatally impales himself on a balcony glass door while his roommate sleeps through it; and three friends preparing a 1957 barbecue all die when the host's ketchup run takes too long, his worried friends drive to search for him, and both vehicles meet at a blind curve and swerve into a fatal head-on collision. In each case, the characters' responses to unfolding events — covering up a crime, searching for a missing person — directly created the outcome they feared or exposed the truth they tried to hide. The stories illustrate how attempts to control chaotic situations often accelerate disaster. (998 chars) — wait, that's 998 characters. Let me recount. Actually it's fine, under 1000. Good.}

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The hurricane Steve feared would help him hide the murder actually preserved the evidence that convicted him by flooding the motel lot before the staged carjacking could occur.

•

Luke's roommate slept through a violent glass-shattering impalement just feet away, and investigators initially found this so implausible they suspected foul play until they reconstructed the accident.

•

Ralph Johnson was never in danger — he was simply delayed at the grocery store, and the search party's departure created the fatal collision that wouldn't have happened if they had waited.

•

Security footage showed Steve biking home after abandoning Crystal's car — a detail the hurricane made visible by preventing the car's theft and stranding the vehicle for police to find.

Key takeaways

•

Steve McDowell strangled his ex-wife Crystal during an argument the night before Hurricane Harvey, left her body in the woods, and drove her car to a seedy motel parking lot hoping it would be stolen and the crime blamed on a carjacker — but the hurricane arrived earlier and harder than forecast, flooding the lot before anyone could steal the car, and security footage captured Steve abandoning the vehicle and biking home, leading to his murder conviction and 50-year sentence.

•

Luke Goodyear, jet-lagged and exhausted after a night of drinking on Phi Phi Island, got out of bed in the dark to use the bathroom, tripped over his own suitcase left on the floor, and fell with such force through the balcony glass door that a massive shard impaled him through the abdomen — his roommate Paul, equally exhausted, slept through the entire violent event, and investigators initially suspected foul play before reconstructing the accidental sequence.

•

Ralph Johnson left a 1957 barbecue preparation to buy ketchup at a store ten minutes away on dangerous winding roads; when he didn't return after an hour, his friends Bobby Patron and Alton Smith drove to search for him, and both vehicles reached the most treacherous blind curve at the exact same moment — each driver swerved to avoid the other, swerved into the other's path, and the head-on collision killed all three men, though Ralph had simply been delayed at the store and was driving home safely.

•

In each story, a character's attempt to manage a crisis — Steve covering up a murder, Bobby searching for a missing Ralph — became the mechanism that either exposed the crime or created the fatal collision, demonstrating how intervention in uncertain situations can produce the very outcome feared.

•

Hurricane Harvey's unexpected early intensity inadvertently preserved criminal evidence: the floodwater trapped Crystal's car in the motel lot exactly where Steve left it, preventing the theft he counted on to obscure the murder, and the storm's chaos stretched police resources thin, yet the car's discovery and security footage still led to conviction.

•

Extreme fatigue and disorientation in an unfamiliar hotel room turned a mundane object — a suitcase on the floor — into a lethal hazard; Luke's half-asleep stumble generated enough force to shatter a balcony door and drive glass through his body, a freak accident that initially baffled investigators because the violence seemed to require an assailant.

•

Well-intentioned worry created the tragedy it feared: Bobby and Alton's anxiety about Ralph's safety on dangerous roads put them on those same roads at the same time as Ralph, and their simultaneous arrival at a blind curve gave neither driver time to react except to swerve into each other.

Notable quotes

“he snapped and he ended up strangling Crystal to death”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:01

“Steve's plan immediately failed because the storm picked up much earlier and much harder than he had expected”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:35

“the idea that you didn't wake up to that seemed crazy, like very far-fetched”

▸ Notable quotes · 13:16

“Luke got up to use the bathroom. But he was so tired and still half asleep, and he wasn't really paying attention to where he was going”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:45

“they both, in an attempt to avoid each other, swerved and wound up swerving directly into each other's path and they struck head-on and all three of them were killed”

▸ Notable quotes · 20:28

Chapters

•

1:03 — Steve McDowell and Hurricane Harvey: Steve McDowell races home on a bike during Hurricane Harvey to check on his kids, worried his ex-wife Crystal hasn't arrived to pick them up. Three days later, police find Crystal's car abandoned at a motel; investigation reveals Steve murdered her the night before the storm, staged the car to look like a carjacking, but the hurricane flooded the lot preserving the car and security footage showing Steve dropping it off and biking home. He receives 50 years for murder.

•

9:04 — Luke Goodyear in Thailand: On vacation in Thailand, Luke Goodyear and friend Paul return to their hotel after a night of drinking. Luke falls asleep; hours later he is found dead, impaled by glass from a shattered balcony door. Police initially suspect foul play since Paul slept through it, but forensics determines Luke, half-asleep and jet-lagged, tripped over his suitcase in the dark and fell through the glass door with fatal force. Ruled an accident.

•

15:47 — Bobby Patron and the Barbecue: In 1957 North Carolina, Ralph Johnson leaves a barbecue prep to buy ketchup. When he's an hour late on dangerous roads, friends Bobby Patron and Alton Smith drive to search for him. Both vehicles reach a blind curve simultaneously — Ralph returning, Bobby and Alton searching — and each swerves to avoid the other, causing a head-on collision that kills all three. Ralph had simply been delayed at the store.

•

20:48 — Conclusion: The narrator thanks viewers, asks for comments, and directs them to a playlist of similar episodes.

Speakers

•

Narrator — Host/Storyteller

⋮