Peter Van Sant investigates | “48 Hours" Full Episodes

Original Media · 3h 30m · English · YouTube · 48 Hours

TLDR

This 48 Hours special covers three distinct true crime cases. The first details the 1994 Rafay family murders in Bellevue, Washington, where teenagers Sebastian Burns and Atif Rafay were convicted after a sophisticated RCMP 'Mr. Big' undercover operation elicited confessions, despite a lack of forensic evidence and a credible alibi. The second examines the 2009 disappearance of celebrity dog trainer Mark Stover, whose ex-wife Linda Updyke and her boyfriend Michael Oakes became central figures; Oakes claimed self-defense but was convicted of premeditated murder after evidence showed he bought supplies to dispose of a body. The third segment profiles the early investigation into the 2007 murder of Meredith Kercher in Perugia, Italy, focusing on the arrest of her roommate Amanda Knox, allegations of a coerced confession, and a private investigator's claim that the real killer was Rudy Guede.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The RCMP 'Mr. Big' operation used a fake hair salon appointment to lure Sebastian Burns into a meeting with an undercover officer, beginning a months-long manipulation involving luxury hotels, cash payments, and a fabricated police memo to pressure a confession.

•

Atif Rafay did not attend his parents' funeral, instead taking a Greyhound bus to Canada with Sebastian Burns the same day; the Canadian consulate had informed Bellevue police in advance, who replied 'Sure.'

•

The murder weapon in the Rafay case was a baseball bat, mirroring a high school play ('The Rope') Sebastian Burns starred in where his character discussed committing the 'perfect murder' with a bat.

•

Michael Oakes wore Mark Stover's trademark hat and coat when leaving the crime scene, an employee mistook him for Stover loading items into Stover's own station wagon.

•

Oakes drove Stover's body to a dock and dumped it, then drove 160 miles to his ex-wife's house, kissed her on the cheek, and said 'I think I'm in trouble' and 'if police saw what's in my car, I'd go away for life.'

•

Amanda Knox's MySpace nickname 'Foxy Knoxy' and a creative writing assignment about rape were sensationalized by the British press as evidence of a depraved personality, fueling a media frenzy before trial.

•

Private investigator Paul Ciolino tested the key witness Nara Capezzali's claim of hearing footsteps with closed windows and found it impossible to hear running footsteps from her apartment, yet police never interviewed her.

Key takeaways

•

The Rafay case hinged on a controversial Canadian 'Mr. Big' sting where undercover officers posed as mobsters to extract confessions from Burns and Rafay, which were later admitted in a U.S. court despite being inadmissible in Washington state.

•

In the Rafay trial, the prosecution argued the boys' alibi (seeing The Lion King) had a 3-minute window to commit the murders, while the defense countered with neighbor testimony placing the murders before 10:00 PM when the boys were at the theater.

•

Jimmy Miyoshi, the boys' friend, initially protected them but later testified against them after being granted immunity, claiming they discussed killing the Rafay family for insurance money.

•

Mark Stover's murder investigation revealed a bizarre stalking dynamic: Stover feared his ex-wife Linda Updyke, while Updyke feared Stover; her boyfriend Michael Oakes shot Stover, claiming self-defense against a gun-wielding Stover, but prosecutors proved Stover was unarmed and Oakes bought weights, rope, and camouflage at Walmart hours before the killing.

•

Michael Oakes was convicted largely due to his ex-wife Jennifer Thompson's testimony that he called the killing a 'job gone bad,' and his failure to call police or reveal the body's location.

•

The Amanda Knox segment highlights concerns about Italian interrogation tactics: Knox was questioned for 14 hours without a lawyer, food, or sleep, and signed a statement implicating her boss Patrick Lumumba (who had an alibi) after police allegedly suggested the scenario.

•

Forensic evidence in the Kercher case pointed to Rudy Guede (DNA, fingerprints), but police maintained Knox and her boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito were involved, shifting theories from a sex game to a robbery gone wrong.

Notable quotes

“It was a plan. A well-rehearsed, well-thought-out plan.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:30

“They think that they are smarter than other people in the world. And I know that sounds just kind of a broad statement, but I really believe they believe that.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:12

“An immaculate murder. I have killed. I have killed for the sake of danger and for the sake of killing.”

▸ Notable quotes · 20:04

“I know I'm smarter. I'm smarter. I'm one of the most intelligent people in the world.”

▸ Notable quotes · 30:31

“What if you called your couple of neighbors and say, 'Let's go off your family and get all their money?' Basically. That's what I mean.”

▸ Notable quotes · 33:10

“I believe that if I'd cross them, that they would have me killed.”

▸ Notable quotes · 34:51

“He went on to describe what my daughters were wearing that morning. And I was very much afraid.”

▸ Notable quotes · 135:03

“I was driving there to be there at a prearranged time. The time demanded by Mark Stover himself.”

▸ Notable quotes · 137:01

“This is a case of cold-blooded murder.”

▸ Notable quotes · 137:05

“She was confused. She was scared. She's a beautiful young woman who is incredibly bright, incredibly kind.”

▸ Notable quotes · 169:24

“Amanda, you know what happened and I know what happened and you better sign this statement because if you don't, young lady, you're never going to see your mama again.”

▸ Notable quotes · 200:59

“How does the knight win the hand of the princess? He goes out and he slays the dragon that's chasing the princess.”

▸ Notable quotes · 164:23

Chapters

•

0:00 — The Rafay Family Murders & The Mr. Big Sting: Covers the 1994 bludgeoning deaths of the Rafay family in Bellevue, the suspicion on son Atif and friend Sebastian Burns, their flight to Canada, and the RCMP's elaborate undercover operation (Mr. Big) that secured video confessions. Details the extradition battle over the death penalty, the 2003 trial, the testimony of friend Jimmy Miyoshi, and the eventual conviction and life sentences.

•

86:00 — The Disappearance of Mark Stover: Details the 2009 disappearance of dog trainer Mark Stover after a contentious divorce from heiress Linda Updyke. Explores the stalking allegations, the anonymous drug tip, and the focus on Updyke's boyfriend Michael Oakes. Describes Oakes' Walmart shopping for body disposal supplies, the shooting at Stover's home, the missing body, and Oakes' claim of self-defense versus the prosecution's murder-for-hire theory.

•

150:00 — The Trial of Michael Oakes: Covers the 2010 trial of Michael Oakes for the murder of Mark Stover. Highlights the prosecution's evidence (Walmart video, shell casings, Jennifer Thompson's 'job gone bad' testimony), the defense's self-defense argument and Kevlar vest demonstration, the judge's exclusion of a defense witness, Linda Updyke's testimony, and the guilty verdict with a 26-year sentence.

•

167:00 — The Amanda Knox Case: A Railroad Job?: Profiles the 2007 murder of Meredith Kercher in Perugia, Italy, and the arrest of roommate Amanda Knox. Examines the 14-hour interrogation without a lawyer, the false accusation of Patrick Lumumba, the media demonization ('Foxy Knoxy'), the forensic evidence pointing to Rudy Guede, and private investigator Paul Ciolino's assertion that Knox is innocent and being railroaded by a desperate prosecution.

Speakers

•

Narrator (48 Hours) — Narrator

•

James Jude Konat — Prosecutor

•

Bob Thompson — Detective

•

Sebastian Burns — Defendant / Convicted Murderer

•

Atif Rafay — Defendant / Convicted Murderer

•

Jimmy Miyoshi — Witness / Friend

•

Jeff Robinson — Defense Attorney

•

Song Richardson — Defense Attorney

•

Roger David Heiser — Prosecutor

•

Mark Stover — Victim

•

Linda Updyke — Ex-Wife of Victim

•

Michael Oakes — Defendant / Convicted Murderer

•

Dan Luvera — Detective

•

Lee Herron — Private Investigator

•

Jennifer Thompson — Ex-Wife of Michael Oakes / Witness

•

Vicki Simmons — Sister of Mark Stover

•

Julia Simmons — Niece of Mark Stover

•

Amanda Knox — Suspect / Defendant

•

Meredith Kercher — Victim

•

Raffaele Sollecito — Co-Defendant

•

Rudy Guede — Convicted Killer

•

Patrick Lumumba — Falsely Accused

•

Paul Ciolino — Private Investigator

•

Edda Mellas — Mother of Amanda Knox

•

Curt Knox — Father of Amanda Knox

•

Nick Pisa — Journalist

•

Edgardo Giobbi — Lead Investigator (Italy)

⋮