TLDR
This episode covers day four of the Matthew Farwell/Sandra Birchmore federal trial, summarizing testimony from Officer Dunn (cross-examination), crime lab analyst Zimmerman, Officer Robert Kuhn, and Sandra's close friend Leslie Davis. The host analyzes the defense's strategy to normalize seated hanging and highlight Sandra's 2017 suicidal ideation, while the prosecution exposes investigative failures: no neighbor canvass, unrecorded parking-lot interviews with Farwell, missing notes, and a fellow officer's damning admission that he wanted to "crush" Farwell despite a decade-long friendship. Key evidence includes Sandra's journal listing "rope" as a method but also many reasons to live, Farwell wearing a mask he despised, and confirmation he was not the baby's father. The episode ends as Chief Donna McNamara begins testimony before a morning recess. The host argues the initial investigation was "unbelievably lazy" and potentially intentional misconduct, and that transparency via courtroom cameras is crucial for public confidence. He invites listeners to weigh both sides' strengths as the trial progresses. The host is Peter Trelgos, attorney and creator of 'The Lawyer You Know.'
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A fellow officer who worked with Farwell for a decade and considered him a friend testified under oath that he "can't wait to crush this [expletive]," suggesting even insiders believe Farwell is guilty.
The defense's "COVID excuse" for conducting unrecorded outdoor interviews collapses because the interviewing officer already testified the real reason was to keep Farwell comfortable and avoid him lawyering up.
The initial investigators did not canvass neighbors or take notes during interviews with the prime suspect — standard procedures the host says are so basic their absence looks like intentional misconduct, not mere incompetence.
Sandra's 2017 suicide journal listed "rope" as a method, yet she also wrote a long list of reasons to live (career, cat, tutoring kids) and did not act — the prosecution argues this makes a 2021 suicide without a note highly inconsistent with her past behavior.
Key takeaways
Officer Dunn's initial investigation concluded Sandra Birchmore's death was self-inflicted, but he conducted no neighbor canvass, took no notes during critical interviews, and missed key evidence like Sandra's computer, phone, and journals — failures the host calls "unbelievably lazy work" and a potential sign of intentional misconduct.
The defense introduced evidence that seated hanging is not unprecedented: Officer Dunn had responded to similar self-inflicted deaths, and Sandra's 2017 journal listed "rope" as a possible method. However, the prosecution counters that she wrote a detailed suicide note then but left none in 2021, and past behavior predicts future behavior.
Fellow Stoughton officer Robert Kuhn, who knew Farwell for 10 years and was friendly with him, testified that Farwell was drinking excessively and highly stressed in late 2020, and that Farwell wearing a mask was highly suspicious because Farwell "despised masks." On cross, Kuhn admitted telling a government lawyer, "I can't wait to crush this [expletive]," which the prosecution used to argue even Farwell's colleagues believe he's guilty.
Farwell was interviewed in a parking lot without recording or notes. The lead investigator admitted this was a purposeful decision to "keep the temperature down" and give Farwell a "better chance of him talking and not getting a lawyer" — not due to COVID, as the defense later suggested.
DNA testing confirmed Matthew Farwell was not the father of Sandra's unborn child. The host emphasizes the legally critical question is not paternity itself, but when Farwell learned he wasn't the father, as that bears on motive.
Sandra's close friend Leslie Davis testified their sexual relationship began when Sandra was 14–15 in the Police Explorers program, including encounters in Farwell's cruiser and truck involving choking. Davis said Sandra was excited about the pregnancy, bought a stroller days before death, and sounded completely normal on their last call hours before she died. Davis immediately went to police implicating Farwell, but officers took no notes.
The prosecution highlighted the Stoughton Police Department's systemic boundary failures: officers exchanging numbers with Explorers, riding alone with them, texting and DMing — conduct the host calls far below the "bare minimum" of appropriate behavior with children in a law-enforcement youth program.
Chief Donna McNamara, Stoughton's police chief in 2021, was called to testify but the feed cut out at the morning recess. The host notes the government is making exhibits publicly available faster than typical in federal court, which he views as a positive transparency measure, though he insists cameras in the courtroom remain the only true substitute for accurate public understanding.
Notable quotes
“Unbelievably lazy work.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:26“Some may call it a sign of intentional misconduct.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:28“I can work real hard moving dirt from one side of my yard to the other side of my yard, and then work really hard taking that dirt and moving it back, and guess what? I got nothing accomplished.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:17“You don't need to force entry if you have a key. Ding ding ding.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:00“Fanning made the purposeful decision to interview Farwell outside, no recordings, no notes, to keep the temperature down, bro. Better chance of him talking and not getting a lawyer.”
▸ Notable quotes · 31:22“You've worked with Matthew Farwell for about 10 years, right? So, this guy who's known Matthew Farwell, friends with him, cordial with him, worked with him for 10 years, wants to bury him, wants to crush him. Why do you think that is?”
▸ Notable quotes · 28:27Chapters
0:01 — Introduction and Trial Overview: Host Peter Trelgos previews part four of the Farwell/Birchmore trial coverage, noting today's lineup includes law enforcement witnesses who may not be friendly to the prosecution, and frames the central question: whether the jury will accept the initial suicide ruling or the prosecution's murder theory.
3:00 — Cross-Examination of Officer Dunn: Dunn, the first responder who ruled the death self-inflicted, is cross-examined about his experience with seated hangings, his failure to canvass neighbors or take notes during key interviews, and the defense's effort to normalize the scene. The host criticizes the investigation as lazy and potentially intentional misconduct.
17:00 — Exhibits: Sandra's 2017 Journal and Ligature Photo: The host reviews Sandra's 2017 suicide journal — which includes a note, a list of methods (including rope), and reasons to live — and a photo of the ligature. He argues the journal helps the prosecution because Sandra wrote a note then but left none in 2021, and past behavior predicts future behavior.
20:30 — Crime Lab Witness Zimmerman: Toxicology shows no alcohol or drugs in Sandra's system, only therapeutic Zoloft. The witness confirms Zoloft overdose is possible but not alleged here; the defense may explore whether Sandra attempted a pill overdose before the hanging.
21:00 — Officer Robert Kuhn Testimony: Kuhn, a 21-year Stoughton officer and Farwell's friend, describes Sandra as impressionable and says Farwell was stressed, drinking heavily, and wearing a mask he hated. On cross, Kuhn admits telling a prosecutor "I can't wait to crush this [expletive]," which the prosecution uses to show even colleagues believe Farwell is guilty.
32:30 — Friend Leslie Davis Testimony: Davis, Sandra's close friend, testifies their sexual relationship began when Sandra was 14–15, included rough sex and choking, and that Sandra was excited about the pregnancy, bought a stroller, and sounded normal on their last call. Davis immediately implicated Farwell to police, who took no notes.
37:36 — Chief Donna McNamara / Technical Issues: Chief McNamara begins testimony but the feed cuts out at the morning recess. The host notes the government's unusual transparency in releasing exhibits quickly and reiterates that cameras in the courtroom are the only true substitute for accurate public understanding.
40:00 — Closing Thoughts and Preview: Trelgos invites listeners to argue the opposing side's best points, previews upcoming witnesses (Guarino, Fanning), discusses the defense's "it only takes one" jury argument, and emphasizes the importance of witness demeanor — which transcripts and tweets cannot capture.
Speakers
Peter Trelgos — Host / Legal Commentator