Preble Penny Press Conference

Original Media · 58m · English · YouTube · Crime Weekly

TLDR

A press conference announces the identification of Preble County Jane Doe (found in 1968) as Albert Allen Frost through investigative genetic genealogy. Originally believed to be a female possibly connected to another missing person case (Mary Jane Croft), DNA analysis revealed the remains were male. After years of failed DNA attempts, the Shelby Police Department partnered with Moxie Forensic Investigations and Intermountain Forensics, funded by Criminal Coffee, to successfully identify Albert Frost, born 1935 in Hamilton, Ohio, who disappeared around 1963-1964. His sister Clara is also missing since the early 1950s.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The remains were believed to be female for over 50 years; the forensic anthropologist's initial assessment was wrong due to Albert's small build (5'2", ~100 lbs) and missing skeletal elements from water exposure.

•

Albert's sister Clara is also a missing person (since 1950-1952) but was never reported missing; family suspects foul play but no investigation occurred.

•

The family "collectively accepted" Albert's disappearance without filing a missing person report, treating discussion of him and Clara as taboo.

•

A potential relative identified through genetic genealogy turned out not to be a biological relative — and didn't know they weren't related — forcing the team to restart the search.

•

Intermountain Forensics had to separate human DNA from overwhelming bacterial contamination in the bone sample, requiring a second full sequencing run — a rare technical achievement.

•

Criminal Coffee funded the $5,000 sequencing cost entirely through coffee sales, representing a novel crowdfunded model for cold case DNA testing.

Key takeaways

•

Preble County Jane Doe ("Preble Penny") found in 1968 has been identified as Albert Allen Frost, a male born January 25, 1935, through investigative genetic genealogy (IGG).

•

The case was originally pursued as a potential match for missing woman Mary Jane Croft; forensic anthropologists initially assessed the remains as female due to Albert's small stature and incomplete skeletal recovery.

•

Multiple DNA extraction attempts failed due to degradation and bacterial contamination; Intermountain Forensics succeeded after two rounds of whole genome sequencing costing ~$5,000.

•

Funding was provided by Criminal Coffee (owned by Derek Levasseur and Stephanie Harlow), demonstrating a community-funded model for cold case resolution.

•

Albert Frost had a troubled life: arrested for larceny multiple times, married briefly in 1959, suffered from tuberculosis, walked with a limp, wore a dental plate, and was last seen by family in 1963-1964.

•

Albert was never reported missing; family assumed he had died and "accepted it." His sister Clara also disappeared between 1950-1952 and was never reported missing.

•

Family rumors consistently stated Albert was murdered (possibly beaten to death outside a bar, or rolled in carpet and left on a porch), though cause of death remains undetermined.

•

The identification brings closure to Albert's surviving nieces and nephews, who provided reference DNA; Albert can now be buried with his name on a headstone.

Notable quotes

“I'm not disappointed this turned out to be not Mary Jane Croft and Goad. Of course. However, I knew from the beginning that even if this was not her, that we would identify somebody and return their name. And that alone justified everything we did here.”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:11

“It is a shame that you are more renowned in death than in life. But I take solace in the fact that wherever you are, outside the stars and beyond the firmament, you're with your family.”

▸ Notable quotes · 27:03

“The unknown individual was a child of Eva Catherine Berry... and Martin Van Buren Frost. Both of them lived in Ohio. Together they had eight children.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:40

“She stated that the family rumor on Albert was that he was murdered and rolled up in a piece of carpet. She stated that he was then left on someone's porch or in someone's yard.”

▸ Notable quotes · 13:20

“We were looking for a female connected to us which is why they never solved it. It wasn't until they did the DNA that they actually learned who it was.”

▸ Notable quotes · 30:42

“There is a real strong possibility that you pay the five grand and you get nothing out of it. That's just like it's a big risk, but I think that's like the barrier to entry for a lot of people.”

▸ Notable quotes · 44:25

Chapters

•

0:01 — Exhumation and Initial DNA Attempts: Details the August 2019 exhumation of Preble County Jane Doe, recovery of remains from a vault, and initial DNA testing by Ohio BCI that failed to yield a usable profile due to degradation and age of remains.

•

1:30 — Mitochondrial DNA Excludes Mary Jane Croft: January 2021 mitochondrial DNA testing revealed male DNA in the remains and excluded Mary Jane Croft as a match, though contamination was initially considered possible.

•

3:20 — Partnership with Moxie Forensics and Intermountain Forensics: June 2022 partnership with Moxie Forensic Investigations; remains sent to Intermountain Forensics in Utah for advanced extraction and whole genome sequencing, funded by Criminal Coffee.

•

6:12 — Genealogical Identification as Albert Allen Frost: Investigative genetic genealogy traced the remains to the Frost family; Albert Allen Frost (born 1935) was the only male sibling without a confirmed death record, identified March 29, 2023.

•

6:34 — Albert Frost's Life and Disappearance: Albert's background: born in Hamilton, Ohio; troubled youth with larceny arrests; brief marriage; tuberculosis; last seen by family 1963-1964; never reported missing; family rumors of murder.

•

12:48 — Family Interviews and Corroboration: Interviews with nieces/nephews confirm Albert's physical traits (dental plate, limp, runny nose, left-handed), transient lifestyle, and family's acceptance of his disappearance; sister Clara also missing since 1950s.

•

19:30 — DNA Confirmation and Case Closure: August 2023 DNA test from niece Danette Russell confirmed Albert's identity; press conference acknowledges all contributors and emphasizes importance of never giving up on cold cases.

•

27:23 — Commentary and Recap by Crime Weekly Hosts: Stephanie Harlow and Derek Levasseur discuss the emotional impact, the surprise male identification, funding model via Criminal Coffee, technical challenges (bacterial contamination), and plans for future cases.

Speakers

•

Detective Turner — Lead Investigator / Presenter

•

Stephanie Harlow — Co-host, Crime Weekly Podcast / Co-owner, Criminal Coffee

•

Derek Levasseur — Co-host, Crime Weekly Podcast / Co-owner, Criminal Coffee

•

Kim Thomas, Casey Colmey, Olivia Pardoe — Owners, Moxie Forensic Investigations

•

Danny Hellwig — Owner, Intermountain Forensics

⋮