TLDR
This episode examines the Netflix documentary 'The Crash' about the 2022 Mackenzie Shirilla case, where 17-year-old Mackenzie crashed her car at nearly 100 mph, killing her boyfriend Dom and friend Davion. The host analyzes the documentary's portrayal, social media backlash against Mackenzie's friend Rosie (who appeared in the doc but initially refused police interviews), and shares findings from a two-hour interview with Rosie and her boyfriend Bubba — the last people to see Dom and Davion alive. The episode also reveals disturbing text messages between Mackenzie and Dom suggesting an emotionally abusive relationship, and Mackenzie's bizarre post-crash behavior including messaging victims' families for sympathy while posting on social media.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Mackenzie was the only one wearing a seatbelt during the crash, which prosecutors argue suggests Dom and Davion were trying to save themselves by grabbing the wheel/gear shift.
Bubba told police he used a pendulum board (like a Ouija board) to 'communicate' with deceased Davion, who allegedly confirmed Mackenzie passed out. Mackenzie also got Dom's father to use a pendulum.
Mackenzie texted Rosie suggesting she make a TikTok vlog of herself tripping on shrooms — despite Mackenzie constantly complaining about TikTok banning her for minor violations, which the host interprets as potential sabotage.
Dom's mother Christine Russo is a criminal defense attorney who worked in the prosecutor's office; she told police she knew Mackenzie's defense attorney and 'he's not a problem,' raising questions about professional connections influencing the case.
Rosie and Bubba dressed as Playboi Carti for Halloween 2022 (months after the crash) with Mackenzie, which victims' families found deeply insensitive. Rosie admits it was irresponsible but says they intended to celebrate Dom and Davion's lives.
Key takeaways
Mackenzie Shirilla was arrested for aggravated murder four months after the crash; body cam footage shows her distressed about removing sentimental bracelets linked to Dom, while her father Steve aggressively confronted police.
The Netflix documentary 'The Crash' sparked viral outrage, particularly over Mackenzie's courtroom demeanor (full makeup, 'smirking' in prison uniform) and her statement 'I'm big on the no intent,' as well as Rosie's refusal to speak to police but willingness to film for Netflix.
Rosie and Bubba claim they avoided police because they believed the investigation focused on drug trafficking (a DEA agent appeared in interviews, and police asked about guns/drugs), not the crash itself. They say Paul's police interview frightened the group.
Text messages reveal Mackenzie's relationship with Dom was highly volatile: she threatened to key his car, break into his house, and crash the car with him in it. Dom recorded her threats. His mother, a criminal defense attorney, documented Mackenzie's harassing post-crash texts asking to sleep in Dom's bed and access his phone.
Mackenzie's post-crash behavior included attending a Kid Cudi concert in a wheelchair weeks after the crash, posting rainbow photos claiming signs from Dom, and messaging Dom's cousin that 'I didn't kill anyone. It was an accident.'
Rosie and Bubba insist they witnessed no fighting at Paul's house that night; Mackenzie fell asleep by 3 a.m., Dom caressed her hair, and they left at 5:30 a.m. for Dom's house. Bubba says Mackenzie wasn't his friend and he doesn't care about her sentence — he just wants the truth about Davion's death.
The host, after reviewing 30,000 pages of texts, believes Mackenzie's messages to Dom reflect emotional abuse and coercive control, which Rosie and Bubba may not have witnessed due to the private nature of domestic violence dynamics.
Mackenzie's parents (Natalie and Steve) are portrayed as enablers: Natalie told friends not to talk to police; Steve demanded access to Dom's house for Mackenzie's belongings; both complained about police 'pageantry' in the documentary.
Notable quotes
“I'm big on the no intent. There was no intent whatsoever there. I have excessive amounts of remorse for Dom, Davion, both of their families.”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:06“The car was the weapon, and it was just exactly like she took a gun and shot Dominic and Davion.”
▸ Notable quotes · 32:39“I didn't kill anyone. It was an accident.”
▸ Notable quotes · 56:40“You have no idea how hard I tried to get Rosie Graham to talk to me, to cooperate with me.”
▸ Notable quotes · 94:11“McKenzie was not my friend. And I know this might sound harsh... if she would have lost her life in that accident... it would not affect me in any way. I would not care.”
▸ Notable quotes · 146:56“Those messages felt more akin to a domestic violence situation... the sheer oppressive nature of McKenzie's text messages to specifically Dom and only Dom and how she speaks to him to me felt abusive.”
▸ Notable quotes · 154:10Chapters
5:44 — Arrest and Body Cam Footage: Mackenzie arrested during traffic stop; body cam shows her distress over bracelets linked to Dom, father Steve's aggressive confrontation with police, and officer eating Doritos while Steve yells.
12:05 — Netflix Documentary 'The Crash' Analysis: Breakdown of Mackenzie's interview (prison uniform, 'smirk,' 'no intent' line), victims' families' composure vs. Shirilla parents' entitlement, and friends' questionable defenses (McChicken litmus test).
18:18 — Night of July 30-31, 2022: Paul's House Gathering: Timeline of graduation parties, Paul's house sleepover (7 people), drug discussions (shrooms/weed), Mackenzie asleep by 3 a.m., departure at 5:30 a.m., crash 5 minutes later.
32:59 — Mackenzie's Post-Crash Behavior & Texts to Victims' Families: Mackenzie messages Dom's cousin and mother: apologizes but demands sympathy, claims sobriety, asks to sleep in Dom's bed/access his phone, posts concert/rainbow photos, attends Kid Cudi concert in wheelchair.
64:28 — Dom's Recorded Evidence of Mackenzie's Threats: Dom recorded Mackenzie threatening to key his car, break into his house, and crash the car; Dom's mother reveals he called her week before crash saying Mackenzie threatened to crash on highway.
76:41 — Rosie & Bubba: Police Hesitancy & Netflix Interview: Why they avoided police (believed drug investigation, DEA agent, Paul's frightening interview), their 8/15-hour Netflix interviews heavily edited, claims they witnessed no fighting that night.
138:01 — Rosie & Bubba Interview: Crash Morning & Conspiracy Theories: Rosie drove home via main road (Pearl), passed Progress entrance but didn't turn onto crash street; cried at sunrise reflecting on friend group separating for college; Bubba learned of crash from coach while prepping truck for Davion.
154:00 — Host's Analysis: Domestic Violence Dynamics & Parental Enabling: After reviewing 30k pages of texts, host sees emotional abuse pattern in Mackenzie-Dom messages; Rosie/Bubba may not have witnessed private abuse; Mackenzie's parents enabled behavior (license/car despite medical condition, interfering with investigation).
Speakers
Host — Podcast host and investigator
Co-host/Producer — Conversational partner