TLDR
The hosts analyze the final New York Times/Siena poll showing Democrats leading in key Senate races, discussing why the numbers may be credible despite seeming too good to be true. They examine Trump's low approval ratings, the poll's methodology, late-deciding voters, and the Kansas race where Roger Marshall's defensive ad signals trouble. They compare 2026 conditions to the 2018 blue wave and argue a larger Democratic wave is plausible.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The poll's Republican-leaning sample (Trump won 67% of these states, five by double digits) makes Trump's 38% approval and poor performance with white non-college voters even more striking.
Nate Cohn's more conservative 2026 methodology produces larger Democratic leads than the 2024 methodology, implying that aggressive weighting for Trump voters may be overshooting the actual electorate.
Roger Marshall's campaign put zero dollars behind his defensive ad; he simply borrowed a camera crew to make a personal statement, which the hosts read as 'loser energy.'
Key takeaways
The NYT/Siena poll shows Democrats leading in seven Senate races, including +11 in Michigan and +7 in Texas, with Trump at 38% approval and 40 points underwater with independents in a heavily Republican sample.
Nate Cohn's methodology has become more conservative since 2024, yet still shows large Democratic leads; using the 2024 methodology would increase Abdul El-Sayed's lead to 16 points, suggesting other polls may be underestimating Democrats by overcorrecting for Trump voters.
Late-deciding voters currently favor Republicans by 9 points, but this likely reflects disenchanted Trump voters dropping out of the likely voter screen rather than a genuine late shift; most undecideds are Trump voters who may stay home.
Roger Marshall's self-funded ad defending his medical billing practices — admitting to sending patients to collections for as little as $50 — signals he believes he is losing and is trying to salvage his reputation.
Conditions in 2026 are far worse for Republicans than in 2018: Trump's approval is lower, the economy is disliked, gas prices are higher, the U.S. is involved in a war in Iran, and Trump's strong approval among Republicans is under 50%, making a larger blue wave plausible.
Even if late breakers go heavily Republican, Democratic candidates are above 50% in Michigan, Texas, Maine, and Ohio, meaning they would still win most of these races.
Notable quotes
“Trump's approval rating in this poll is 38%. He's 40 points underwater with independents. He is under 50 with white voters who didn't go to college.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:20“Nate Cohn wrote an accompanying piece to this where he said, "We've actually made our our methodology even more conservative since 2024 to try to jam even more Trump voters in there."”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:10“This is what can't losing candidates do at the end. This is a sign that he believes he is losing, and he wants to make a final statement for the record to make it very clear to everyone that he is definitely not the guy who arrested people who owed him money.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:21“Voters aren't totally honest about when they decided. They usually will say they decided if no one likes to say they decided 5 years ago or decided the moment they came out of the womb, which is true of most voters.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:36“When you compare what happened in 2018 with if you had a big blue wave in 2018 under those circumstances, it is at least plausible that you could have a much bigger blue wave and maybe even a blue tsunami in 2026 under these circumstances.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:07“Let's go make them right.”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:03Chapters
0:00 — NYT/Siena poll release and initial reaction: The final New York Times/Siena poll shows Democrats leading in seven Senate races, sparking both enthusiasm and disbelief among Democrats.
1:17 — Trump's approval and the Republican sample: Trump's approval is 38% in a sample where he won 67% of states; he is 40 points underwater with independents and under 50% with white non-college voters, acting as an anvil for Republican candidates.
2:22 — Michigan race and Nate Cohn's methodology: Abdul El-Sayed leads by 11 points; Nate Cohn's more conservative 2026 methodology would show a 16-point lead, suggesting other polls may be underestimating Democrats by over-weighting Trump voters.
7:07 — Late deciders and likely voter screens: Late-deciding voters favor Republicans by 9 points, but this likely reflects disenchanted Trump voters dropping out of the likely voter pool rather than a genuine shift; most undecideds are Trump voters who may not vote.
10:11 — Kansas race and Roger Marshall's defensive ad: Roger Marshall is heckled over sending patients to collections; his self-funded ad admitting to collections for $50 debts signals he believes he is losing.
12:47 — 2018 vs 2026 comparison and final call to action: Conditions in 2026 are far worse for Republicans than in 2018, making a larger blue wave plausible; hosts urge listeners to vote and act as if the polls are right.
Speakers
Jon Favreau — Co-host
Dan Pfeiffer — Co-host