Kornacki: How Republicans’ redistricting gamble ended up ‘firing up’ Democrats in North Carolina

Original Media · 5m · English · YouTube · NBC News

TLDR

NBC News chief data analyst Steve Kornacki analyzes how Republican mid-decade redistricting in North Carolina backfired in the 2024 midterms. Despite drawing districts that Trump carried by double digits, Democrats won or nearly won multiple seats, including defeating Republican leadership member Richard Hudson. The aggressive gerrymandering appears to have mobilized Black voters and the Democratic base statewide. Republicans lost seats they expected to protect, with incumbents trailing or barely surviving in districts Trump won by 13-17 points. The redistricting effort intended to pad the GOP majority instead triggered a backlash that made deeply red districts competitive. Kornacki presents North Carolina as the most dramatic example of redistricting backfire in the country. The segment uses live map visualizations to show district-by-district results and Trump margins. The analysis suggests the 2024 turnout patterns, particularly among rural African American voters, fundamentally altered the expected partisan lean of these newly drawn districts. Several races remained uncalled at the time of analysis, with margins of just hundreds of votes in Trump +13 to +17 districts.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The chair of the House Republican campaign committee (Richard Hudson) lost his own race in a district Trump won by 16 points.

•

Democrats won or nearly won in multiple districts Trump carried by 13-17 points with candidates who had very little campaign money or national attention.

•

The Republican redistricting effort appears to have directly caused the Democratic turnout surge that defeated them — the map itself became a mobilizing tool for the opposition.

•

Virginia Foxx, a long-serving Republican fixture in Congress, trailed in a Trump +17 district by only about 100 votes, potentially heading to a recount.

Key takeaways

•

Republican legislators in North Carolina redrew congressional districts before the 2024 midterms to create safer Republican seats, but the strategy backfired as Democrats won or nearly won in multiple districts Trump carried by double digits.

•

Don Davis (Democrat) won North Carolina's 1st District by about three points despite the new lines making it a Trump +11 district, powered by strong turnout from the district's large rural African American population that had underperformed in 2024.

•

Richard Hudson, a member of Republican congressional leadership who ran the NRCC (House GOP campaign arm), lost his own race in the 9th District — a Trump +16 seat — to Democrat Richard Ojeda, marking one of the cycle's most stunning upsets.

•

Multiple other Republican incumbents faced near-defeat or trailed in heavily Trump-favored districts: Greg Murphy in NC-3 (Trump +13), Virginia Foxx in NC-5 (Trump +17), Addison McDowell in NC-6 (Trump +17), and Tim Moore in NC-14 (Trump +15), with several races separated by only hundreds of votes.

•

Even where Republicans held on, such as the 7th District (Trump +13), the incumbent led by only about 2,000 votes — far closer than the district's presidential lean would predict.

•

Kornacki argues the aggressive redistricting fired up the Democratic base, particularly Black voters across North Carolina, who turned out in numbers Democrats hadn't seen in previous cycles, creating a statewide backlash that overwhelmed the GOP's map-drawing advantage.

•

The North Carolina results represent the most dramatic example nationwide of mid-decade redistricting producing the opposite of its intended effect, with Republicans losing seats they specifically drew to protect.

•

Several races remained uncalled at the time of analysis, meaning the final Democratic pickup in North Carolina could be even larger once recounts and final tallies are complete in districts like NC-3 and NC-5.

Notable quotes

“THE REDRAW WAS SUPPOSED TO GIVE REPUBLICANS MORE SEATS. THE EFFECT OF THE REDRAW IN NORTH CAROLINA SEEMS TO HAVE BEEN IN PART TO FIRE UP A DEMOCRATIC BASE IN THAT STATE THAT MAYBE HADN'T TURNED OUT IN NUMBERS DEMOCRATS HAD USUALLY WANT IN THE PAST TURNED OUT FOR THIS ELECTION.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:29

“RICHARD HUDSON IS A MEMBER OF CONGRESSIONAL REPUBLICAN LEADERSHIP. HE WAS RUNNING THE CAMPAIGN ARM OF CONGRESSIONAL REPUBLICANS, THE NRCC, AND HE LOST HIS OWN DISTRICT IN NORTH CAROLINA, A DISTRICT, AGAIN, THAT TRUMP HAD CARRIED BY 16 POINTS.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:15

“THIS WAS A SHOCKING RESULT. AGAIN, LOOK AT THE DISTRICT, A 17 POINT TRUMP DISTRICT. WE'RE SEEING THIS ALL ACROSS NORTH CAROLINA.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:43

“ONE OF THE REASONS THAT DAVIS DID SO WELL HERE IS THERE IS A LARGE AFRICAN AMERICAN POPULATION, RURAL AFRICAN AMERICAN POPULATION IN THIS DISTRICT.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:09

“REPUBLICANS REALLY TOOK IT ON THE CHIN IN NORTH CAROLINA, PERHAPS MORE THAN ANY OTHER STATE.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:50

Chapters

•

0:04 — NC redistricting overview: Kornacki introduces the theme of mid-decade redistricting in the 2024 midterms, focusing on North Carolina where Republicans redrew lines to protect their majority ahead of 2026.

•

0:24 — NC-1: Don Davis wins Trump +11 district: Democrat Don Davis wins the 1st District by about three points despite new lines making it a Trump +11 seat, driven by strong rural African American turnout that had lagged in 2024.

•

1:30 — Statewide backlash emerges: Kornacki argues the redistricting fired up the Democratic base statewide, particularly Black voters, and shows Republicans took heavier losses in North Carolina than any other state.

•

1:57 — NC-9: Richard Hudson upset: Republican leadership member and NRCC chair Richard Hudson loses his own race in the 9th District (Trump +16) to Democrat Richard Ojeda, the cycle's most dramatic upset.

•

2:32 — Multiple GOP incumbents imperiled: Greg Murphy (NC-3, Trump +13), Virginia Foxx (NC-5, Trump +17), Addison McDowell (NC-6, Trump +17), and Tim Moore (NC-14, Trump +15) all trail or barely lead in deep-red districts.

•

4:17 — NC-7: Close survival in Trump +13 seat: Even the Republican incumbent in the 7th District leads by only ~2,000 votes in a Trump +13 district, illustrating the statewide pattern of dramatic underperformance.

•

4:31 — Conclusion: Redistricting backfired: Kornacki concludes the Republican redraw intended to add seats instead mobilized Democratic voters, particularly Black voters, turning double-digit Trump districts into competitive or Democratic wins.

Speakers

•

Steve Kornacki — Chief Data Analyst

⋮