TLDR
After Democrats' historic 2026 midterm landslide, election attorney Mark Elias warns that election denialism hasn't disappeared — it's evolving. Trump has shifted from claiming late-ballot fraud to alleging voting machines are rigged, a narrative Elias predicts will dominate the 2028 cycle. The movement persists because Trump needs it for ego and to keep Republican officials loyal through fear, not because evidence supports it. Elias argues the media's "everything's fine" narrative after the Democratic win dangerously ignores how denialism percolated after 2020 and returned stronger.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A landslide defeat fuels election denialism more than a close loss because Trump uses the margin itself as 'proof' of fraud.
Trump's new 'machines over voters' theory completely reverses his 2020 argument about late-night ballot dumps — now early voting is the conspiracy.
Republican election officials in red states, not Democratic ones, would be the primary targets of Trump's 2028 fraud claims.
Trump would have to claim his own Republican voters committed fraud when they crossed over to vote for Democrats in states like Texas and Iowa.
Key takeaways
Democrats' 2026 midterm landslide (260 House seats, 55-56 Senate seats) has led media to declare election denialism dead, but Mark Elias warns this mirrors the false confidence after 2020 when denialism later roared back stronger.
Trump's fraud narratives mutate to fit outcomes: he now claims early voting dumps and voting machines — not late ballots — are the problem, reversing his 2020 timing argument entirely.
The larger Trump's margins of defeat, the more he treats those margins as proof of fraud; in his 'perverted logic,' losing by a lot becomes evidence the system is rigged.
Trump promotes denialism for two reasons: personal psychology (he cannot accept responsibility for any loss) and political control (he needs Republican officials to fear crossing him, as seen when House Republicans broke on the Epstein files).
Unlike 2020 when Trump targeted Democratic-run states, his 2026/2028 claims would require attacking Republican election officials in red states who administered the elections he's disputing.
Republican voters themselves undermine Trump's fraud claims: in states like Texas, Kansas, and Iowa, 10-12% of Republicans voted for Democratic candidates, making it impossible to credibly claim those wins were fraudulent.
Republicans face a 'horrible runway into 2028' with an unpopular Trump, JD Vance as a 'calamity' frontrunner, and ownership of economic pain from tariffs and wars — making election denialism a distraction from unsolvable voter problems.
Ignoring denialism because it 'seems crazy' failed after 2020; Elias argues the only effective response is proactive, loud debunking and sharing accurate information before the narrative hardens.
Notable quotes
“Does anybody really believe this election was honest? How could the polls be so wrong? Some early voting dumps were so large that it was impossible to win no matter how many people went to vote. It's all about the machines, which are far more important than the voters.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:01“the more Donald Trump loses, the more the margins of those defeats, the more they become proof points in his perverted logic that something must be wrong”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:46“I think it's both. I think I think Donald Trump number one is still searching for the the excuse, you know, the person, the thing, the event, the you know, he's still trying to wrap his arms around what that what that um right because he can't take responsibility for anything that he did himself”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:35“Republicans are setting up setting themselves up for a pretty horrible uh, you know, runway into 2028. I mean, they're going to have this guy who's very unpopular. JD Vance is is just a calamity of a candidate and he looks like he's going to be the front runner.”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:05“we tried that all after 2020. Everyone was like, 'Oh, under the Biden era, like let's not give oxygen to this. It'll all die out.' And instead, it came roaring back.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:30“he would have to attack his own voters, which again is different than it was in 2020. I think that on the voter thing, that's just the price of of doing business for Donald Trump.”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:44Chapters
0:00 — Post-midterm denialism persists despite landslide: Democrats won a historic 2026 midterm landslide (260 House seats, 55-56 Senate seats), but Mark Elias warns election denialism hasn't disappeared — it percolated after 2020 and returned stronger, and he predicts another crisis by 2028.
2:06 — Landslides don't stop conspiracy theories: The 2020 election was also a multi-state landslide, yet Trump's fraud claims took hold; larger defeats become 'proof points' in his logic that the system is rigged, making landslides ineffective deterrents.
3:59 — Trump shifts to voting machine conspiracy: Trump has abandoned late-ballot and non-citizen voting theories for a new claim: voting machines are rigged and 'more important than voters,' reversing his 2020 timing argument — now early votes are suspicious.
7:22 — Why Trump promotes election denialism: Dual motivation: Trump's ego (he cannot accept personal responsibility for any loss) and political control (he needs Republican officials to fear him, as shown when House Republicans broke on the Epstein files and he never recovered).
9:55 — Risks for Trump's 2028 denialism strategy: Unlike 2020, Trump would have to attack Republican election officials in red states and his own voters (10-12% of Republicans crossed over in Texas, Kansas, Iowa). Meanwhile, GOP faces unsolvable 2028 problems: unpopular Trump, 'calamity' candidate Vance, and ownership of economic pain.
Speakers
Brian Taylor Cohen — Host
Mark Elias — Election attorney