CLAYFACE REVIEW | State of DC Studios | NR Podcast

Original Media · 1h 08m · English · YouTube · New Rockstars

TLDR

Eric Voss and Jessica Clements review DC Studios' Clayface film, praising Tom Reese Harris's performance and the Gotham world-building but criticizing the movie's excessive gore over body horror, muddled themes, and delayed Clayface reveal. They discuss the broader state of DC Studios under James Gunn and Peter Safran, the Skydance merger's implications, the future of Batman (with Steven Soderbergh finishing The Batman Part 2), and why Lanterns season 2 hasn't been greenlit yet.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Clayface was not part of the original 'Gods and Monsters' slate announced in 2022 — it replaced projects like Swamp Thing and The Authority.

•

James Gunn has explicitly said in interviews that Clayface 'has nothing to do with me' and that he gave the script to the studio but it's now James Watkins's film.

•

The Clayface movie cost only $44 million — remarkably low for a superhero film — with no major stars and a tiny cast.

•

Steven Soderbergh texted Matt Reeves offering to help finish The Batman Part 2, and Reeves accepted; Soderbergh insists he's only carrying out Reeves's vision, not adding his own spin.

•

The hosts reveal that Warner Bros. Discovery considered re-releasing all eight Harry Potter movies theatrically to pad Skydance's 30-movie-a-year quota.

Key takeaways

•

Clayface delivers a compelling Gotham setting and a standout lead performance by Tom Reese Harris, but fails as a Clayface movie because it withholds the titular character until the final act and substitutes body horror with gratuitous surgical gore.

•

The film feels like a Mike Flanagan script that was chopped and screwed in production; James Gunn has publicly distanced himself from it, saying it's James Watkins's movie, not his.

•

James Gunn's mantra of 'only greenlighting good scripts' is flawed because a good script doesn't guarantee a good movie — the film is rewritten in directing, casting, and editing, and Clayface shows the seams where that process broke down.

•

DC Studios' most valuable asset is the Gotham world established in Clayface and The Batman; the hosts argue the next priority must be a live-action Batman vs. Clayface movie, not more villain origin stories.

•

The Skydance merger likely means fewer B/C-tier DC films like Clayface ($44M budget) and more focus on tentpole Batman/Superman/Justice League movies, with villain projects pushed to HBO Max limited series.

•

Lanterns season 2's delayed greenlight is almost certainly a financial/bureaucratic decision (quarterly write-offs, budget allocation for House of the Dragon's final season), not a creative one.

•

Steven Soderbergh stepping in to finish The Batman Part 2 after Matt Reeves's personal departure signals the film will stay on track for February 2028, and the DCU Batman (different actor) will likely be announced by late 2027 for a 2029 release.

•

The hosts compare Clayface unfavorably to Venom (which has more 'fuck yeah' moments) and The Substance (which commits to its vanity theme), arguing Clayface zigged when it should have zagged by avoiding the Feet of Clay tragic-vanity core.

Notable quotes

“I think it's honestly better than Supergirl. I like when he becomes Clayface and I love the final shot of the movie. I thought that final shot was really cool.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:06

“I really am a body horror fan, not actually a gore fan. And so when I walked into this movie assuming that it was going to be Clayface molding his body... but then there's gore. I think he relied on that as horror and that's not the horror that I was looking for.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:19

“Stop doing this. Like, stop like In the movie's called Clayface. Let's see Clayface in the first half hour. Come on.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:37

“If it's not a story about vanity, then what is the story about? And after watching this movie, I can't tell you what it is about.”

▸ Notable quotes · 11:49

“This movie did not need to be a DC movie. It's a body horror story or trying to be a body horror story in a crime-ridden world that is literally just a Mike Flanagan script that James Gunn skinned in a DC setting.”

▸ Notable quotes · 18:20

“A good script is not always equal a good movie. A script is not the movie fully ready to go. The script is just a blueprint for what the movie could be.”

▸ Notable quotes · 25:43

Chapters

•

0:00 — Clayface Review & Initial Reactions: Eric and Jessica open with raw reactions to Clayface: Jessica gives it a C (5/10), praises Tom Reese Harris's performance, but criticizes the excessive gore and lack of rewatchability.

•

4:14 — Body Horror vs. Gore Debate: Jessica distinguishes body horror (The Substance, The Fly, The Thing) from gore, arguing Clayface relies on surgical gore rather than transformative body horror, which disappoints her expectations from the teasers.

•

7:27 — Thematic Confusion & Missed Opportunities: The hosts dissect the film's muddled themes — vanity, AI, mother-son, love — and argue it should have adapted the 'Feet of Clay' tragic-vanity core from Batman: The Animated Series instead of zagging for difference's sake.

•

13:02 — Gotham World-Building Praise: Despite Clayface's flaws, both hosts love the Gotham setting — its geography, lighting, corruption, and potential for future Batman stories — calling it a 'matte canvas' they're eager to revisit.

•

18:17 — DC Studios Leadership & James Gunn Critique: Eric critiques Gunn's 'only good scripts' promise as naive; scripts get rewritten in production. They compare Gunn's early tenure to Feige's early failures and argue Clayface shows the seams of a butchered Flanagan script.

•

35:13 — Skydance Merger & Future DC Strategy: With Skydance owning half the studio, the hosts predict fewer B-tier DC films, more tentpoles (Batman/Superman), villain projects moving to HBO Max, and pressure to deliver a DCU Batman announcement by late 2027.

•

38:07 — The Batman Part 2 & DCU Batman Timeline: Matt Reeves stepped back for personal reasons; Steven Soderbergh is finishing production. The Batman Part 2 stays on track for Feb 2028. DCU Batman (new actor) likely announced late 2027 for 2029 release, possibly timed to Batman '89's 40th anniversary.

•

62:22 — Lanterns Season 2 & Industry Consolidation: Lanterns S2 delay is financial/bureaucratic, not creative. The hosts discuss streaming consolidation into 4-5 mega-apps (Disney/Hulu, Netflix/NBC, Skydance/HBO/Paramount, Prime/Sony, YouTube) and the future of theatrical exhibition.

Speakers

•

Eric Voss — Host

•

Jessica Clements — Co-host

•

Brian — Producer

⋮