May The Odds Be Ever In Their Favor w/ Mckenna Grace | Reading Reddit Stories

Original Media · 55m · English · YouTube · Smosh Pit

TLDR

Shayne, Courtney, and guest Mckenna Grace read and discuss four 'Am I the Asshole' Reddit stories. The stories cover a man who unknowingly dethrones his girlfriend's dad in a hotdog eating contest, a woman asked to write essays to attend her sister's pandemic wedding, a best friend ambushed by her friend's fiancée about romantic feelings, and a woman whose future father-in-law threatens to boycott the wedding over her Mockingjay tattoo from The Hunger Games. In each case, the hosts agree the OP is not the asshole.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The reigning hotdog eating champion (the 'Doggler') only ate 12 hotdogs in five minutes, a surprisingly low number for a four-time winner, suggesting a small-town competition with weak competition.

•

The bride in the essay story required parents to write essays too — the OP's mother called to say it only took her 20 minutes and the OP shouldn't complain.

•

The fiancée in the ambush story texted the wedding party group chat to uninvite the OP, but the entire group — including David's family and David himself — laughed and agreed with the OP's assessment of David's flaws.

•

The father-in-law's hatred of The Hunger Games is so extreme he threatens to cut off his son and skip the wedding over a Mockingjay tattoo, yet the franchise's anti-authoritarian themes make his reaction ironically on-brand for a Capitol sympathizer.

Key takeaways

•

The hotdog eating contest story reveals how family traditions can create unexpected conflict when an outsider unknowingly disrupts them, and how grievances often surface months later during unrelated arguments rather than in the moment.

•

The wedding essay story illustrates how pandemic-era restrictions led some couples to create performative, humiliating hoops for guests to jump through, turning a celebration into a competition for attendance.

•

In the best friend ambush story, the fiancée's insecurity manifests as a trap: she demands honesty about why the OP isn't attracted to her partner, then punishes the OP for providing the exact honesty she requested.

•

The Mockingjay tattoo story highlights a major relationship red flag when a partner sides with a controlling parent over their fiancée's bodily autonomy, especially when the tattoo predates the relationship and holds personal meaning.

•

Across all stories, the hosts emphasize that the person creating the conflict is often not the one being judged — the girlfriend bringing up the hotdog loss months later, the bride demanding essays, the fiancée orchestrating an ambush, and the fiancé yielding to his father's unreasonable demand.

•

Mckenna Grace shares her genuine fandom for Smosh and internet culture, noting she grew up on musical.ly/TikTok and YouTube, and avoids Reddit directly, consuming stories through curated formats like this show.

•

The hosts' chemistry and shared history (Shayne and Courtney are married) inform their judgments, particularly on wedding stories where they draw on their own experience navigating guest lists and family dynamics.

Notable quotes

“I've always loved, what, it's like the laugh you lose. Like, I've always liked that one whenever everybody gets up and does a thing.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:45

“I also don't like to exclusively consume like, my Am I the Asshole stories from, what is it? Like the Subway Surfers videos like on TikTok.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:06

“I've made a good amount of edits in my time. Yeah, I'm an editor.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:48

“If I'm entering a hotdog eating contest, I'm not holding back. I don't care who I'm competing against. If I look around and it's all children, I'm like, 'Sorry, you're losing.'”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:05

“Don't ask questions if you can't handle the answer.”

▸ Notable quotes · 38:35

“It's your body, your choice. Why does father-in-law care about a tattoo on your arm so much so that he's threatening to cut you off? Father-in-law sounds unhinged.”

▸ Notable quotes · 49:14

Chapters

•

0:00 — Intro and Guest Introduction: Shayne introduces the episode and guest Mckenna Grace, star of the upcoming Hunger Games movie. Mckenna reveals she's a longtime Smosh fan and former video editor.

•

4:16 — Story 1: Hotdog Eating Contest: OP beats girlfriend's dad ('The Doggler') in a hotdog eating contest, eating 16 hotdogs to his 12. Girlfriend later claims dad was wounded. Reddit verdict: Not the Asshole. Update reveals girlfriend exaggerated dad's reaction.

•

20:20 — Story 2: Wedding Application Essays: Sister requires 500-word essays from all guests to attend pandemic destination wedding. OP refuses. Parents pressure her. Reddit verdict: Not the Asshole. Bride's logic called manipulative and unfair.

•

32:30 — Story 3: Best Friend Ambush: OP ambushed by best friend's fiancée at bridal party dinner, pressed on why she's not in love with him. OP answers honestly about his flaws. Fiancée tries to kick OP out of wedding. Group chat backs OP. Reddit verdict: Not the Asshole.

•

43:50 — Story 4: Hunger Games Tattoo: OP gets Mockingjay tattoo. Future father-in-law hates Hunger Games, threatens to boycott wedding. Fiancé sides with father, demands tattoo removal. Reddit verdict: Not the Asshole, flags fiancé as the real problem.

•

53:00 — Wrap Up: Hosts thank Mckenna, promote Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping (Nov 20), and joke about Doggler Nation tattoos.

Speakers

•

Shayne — Host

•

Courtney Miller — Co-host

•

Mckenna Grace — Guest

•

Emily — Producer

⋮